Salone News

Why shouldn’t I support the repeal of the Public Order Act?

13 August 2009 at 02:39 | 722 views

Opinion

By Sheka Tarawalie, Freetown.

Bad laws are created by bad politicians. And once enacted, bad laws - like a disease - become hard to get rid of. The whole fiasco over the 1965 Public Order Act, with special reference to Part V which criminalizes libel, should be squarely placed at the feet of the Sierra Leone People’s Party. Yes, I mean the SLPP.

But with current happenings (as the Sierra Leone Association of Journalists [SLAJ], under the presidency of my friend Umaro Fofanah, is making things look like), it would appear that the All People’s Congress is a government that must be denigrated and discredited for this bad law.

Today, in Umaro’s view, this government is bad, vis-à-vis the Public Order Act. But this same Umaro, just a few months ago, during World Press Freedom Day, had complimentary words for the APC government on how journalists are enjoying press freedom in Sierra Leone. Speaking at a UNIPSIL-organised programme at Hotel Cabenda, Umaro said a friend from another country had called him to complain that they were merely commemorating the day, while he replied, ‘we are celebrating here in Sierra Leone.’

No one would dispute with Umaro on that. He didn’t say then which country the friend had called from. But I would just imagine it could have come from The Gambia. The Gambia is a stable and progressing country, which a few years ago had to send its sons and daughters to Sierra Leone for tertiary education, but today can boast of one of the strongest economies in the sub-region with infrastructural developments to show for that, including the building of universities that has now cut off the sending of their sons and daughters here for further studies. But in terms of press freedom, there is no comparison with Sierra Leone, as journalists are constantly under suppression in The Gambia (yet, Britain says if we want visas, we need to go through The Gambia). Just a few days ago, six were imprisoned in a long line of beatings, disappearances, alleged murders, and ranscakings for journalists and media houses in Banjul.

Journalists in Sierra Leone under the Ernest Koroma government have something to celebrate about, have something to thank God for. It’s almost two years in power now, and we are still to get any situation warranting urgent action from press freedom stakeholders. Apart from a female journalist going beyond the bounds of ethics and decency through ‘suicide bombing’ cartoons and articles and then going into self-imposed hiding when no one was running after her , only to come out and be granted self-bail until she misused the privilege, journalists must be thankful that at least none of their kind has been imprisoned. Even when Jonathan Leigh of Independent Observer fell foul of former Transport Minister Kemoh Sesay and was privately taken to court, an apology was enough to let the errant journalist off the hook. The issue regarding Sitta Turay of the New People and a State House photographer was more of a bar brawl than a political game.

In summary, the Ernest Korma government has no political prisoners, no journalists behind bars. And this is in the face of clear libelous publications that another government would have easily used to jail journalists. Take the case of the New Vision newspaper (a clearly opposition paper) publishing that the President had spent colossal sums of money in traveling abroad, with a succession of front-page lead stories insisting that they had evidence to the effect. Yet, instead of using the 1965 Public Order Act, government went to the Independent Media Commission (IMC), where the New Vision still displayed recalcitrance until they were found guilty. What came out of it was a public apology from its editors and a retraction (which perhaps caused Sorie Fofanah and Sheik Bawoh to run away to open Global Times). Government did not go any further, but the President wholeheartedly forgave the erring editors. There’s also the case of Awareness Times which placed horns on the picture of the President and turned another upside down, but was let off; only for the paper to go further and concoct emails claiming to come from Zimbabwe to insult the President, as the IMC found it guilty. Instead of government going to court, it was the paper that ran to the courts.

If we put two years of President Koroma’s APC side-by-side with just the first year of Tejan Kabba’s SLPP in terms of press freedom, the former is a pale and shining shadow under the dark and brutish colossus of the latter. On assuming power, the SLPP, with a majority in Parliament, used the House as a court to jail journalists. I was the first victim, with no right to a lawyer, no right of appeal – just for writing about government corruption. The next in line were three editors of the now defunct Expo Times who were sent to Pademba Road for criticising the government’s collaboration with Nigeria’s Sanni Abacha in a gangster way to arrest rebel leader Foday Sankoh at a time when they should have been talking peace. Hilton Fyle of 1-2-3 newspaper was also sent to jail. Not only that, President Kabba made a statement that the judiciary was too lenient with journalists, unleashing a spate of attacks and court actions against journalists. Beyond that, the SLPP government thought the 1965 Public Order Act was not strong enough, was not powerful enough, and then they put together legislation to further stifle the press with stiff criteria and tough penalties. The bill was about to be assented by the President when a coup turned the tables in 1997.

But that’s not even the reason why I said at the beginning that the blame for the current fiasco should be ascribed to the SLPP. The fact and plain truth is that the SLPP enacted the 1965 Public Order Act under the leadership of Albert Margai with the primary aim to silence the opposition APC before the 1967 elections. It turned out that the SLPP lost those elections and therefore found themselves afterwards at the receiving end of the very bad law they created. The APC, for obvious reasons, was not keen to change the law. Certainly, this would not be the cup of tea of the shrewd Siaka Stevens. You wouldn’t have expected Momoh to do otherwise.
Yet, after a tumultuous period of coups and palace coups, one would have expected the SLPP, after regaining power in 1996, to have cleared and cleaned the sins of their forefathers by repealing the 1965 Public Order Act, even on a campaign promise to do just that . But all they did was to call for more draconian laws. Even those journalists that denounced the junta and supported the re-instatatement of Kabba, on his return, were among the thousands choked at Pademba Road for the crime of collaboration turned treason, of which current Information Minister I.B. Kargbo was sentenced to death. Another journalist was executed along with 23 military officers. Thereafter, through the same Public Order Act or its antecedents, many other journalists, most notably Paul Kamara and even Sorie Fofanah, faced the wrath of the law and its agents under the SLPP.

But this is not to say the APC government (despite having had cause to grudgingly use the Act to take Sylvia Blyden to court because she does not recognize the authority of the IMC - herself being an advocate for the retention of the law), should not reverse the status quo. I am surprised that anyone would even remotely think that I would be against the repeal of this law just because I am Press Secretary to the President. Professionally, I am first and foremost a journalist, and I am old enough to know that governments come and go, positions pass away, but only death takes your profession from you. We shouldn’t say because the SLPP brought this bad law or because they subsequently added injury to insult, as in the case of Harry Yanssaneh who was beaten to death by an SLPP MP, then the APC should not do anything about it.

Here, the remarks of British Deputy Tory (Opposition) Leader William Hague, regarding a ‘bad law’ in Britain, ring a bell: "A Conservative government will give parliament the opportunity to repeal the Hunting Act on a free vote and in government time. This has been our position and it will remain our position... The passage of the Hunting Act revealed that Labour MPs’ respect for the views of minorities only extended to those minorities whose views they could readily agree with. The result was a piece of legislation so deeply prejudiced and so ridiculously unworkable that its existence weakens and discredits the laws of the land... This is a bad law and bad laws should be repealed, not ignored." It’s as simple as that. Bad laws must be repealed. As was done with the Public Order Act in Ghana under John Kuffour.

In fact my support for the repeal of this law is not at variance with the President’s campaign promise and his current position. Where I differ or beg to differ with SLAJ on this whole argument of decriminalising libel, is this method of trying to make things look like they must emanate from SLAJ. I don’t know why it has to be a matter pursued through the courts, and why those courts must be hounded by SLAJ, and why the police and the whole government must be drawn into a brawl that should not have been started in the first place. Of course I know it was not Umaro’s administration that took government to court. It was Philip Neville’s. But it was one of the packages of Neville’s regime that was campaigned against for Umaro to take over. We did not know it was going to be used as a tool to besmirch a government which, since Sierra Leone’s Independence, so far stands out as the least repressive, most open, most amiable to journalists – as Umaro himself acknowledged on Press Freedom Day. The SLAJ President cannot feign inaccessibility to President Koroma. On several occasions I arranged that. Umaro’s SLAJ has met with President Koroma, and the Head of State reiterated his promise to review the law. The dialogue had begun.

As a pressure group, SLAJ should have continued the dialogue until they would discover that there was an iota of suspicion that the government was not prepared to honour its words. Then there would have been a need to take the confrontational path. And in trade union activities, once such a decision is taken, the association should be prepared to take the long shot. It would not just be about telling your supporters to black-out the judiciary for a few days, it would not just be about asking members to boycott a single press conference. It would mean a thorough plan, with alternatives, until the goal is achieved. It would mean a concerted and long-drawn action. It would not mean merely declaring to remain dread-locked until further notice. Being a students union President is certainly not the same as being the President of SLAJ. In Ghana’s situation, the then President of the Ghana Journalists Association, Gifty Affenyi-Dadzie (a lady), went into dialogue with President Kuffour using the access she had then, and they, together with Parliament, worked in the public interest to decriminalize libel. She sent congratulatory messages to the President for the cooperation. But you don’t just run to the President for cooperation after the police have rebuffed a demonstration whose sole purpose was to soil the reputation of the country in a most unwarranted fashion.

Just a few weeks ago, President Barrack Obama was in Ghana. It should not be a surprise. Article 19, a London-based organisation campaigning for freedom of expression, lauded Ghana thus: "The repeal of [the] criminal libel law puts Ghana at the forefront of African countries when it comes to meeting international standards on free expression.” The United States is the bastion of democratic freedom; Ghana takes the lead in being the first country in Africa to decriminalize libel under the government of John Kuffour in 2001. During the elections, Kuffour had promised just that. Although with all that, the man who championed the bill, ex-Attorney General Nana Addo Dankwa Akufo Addo, could not succeed his President - losing to the opposition’s John Atta Mills. But I’m sure Nana is quite satisfied that his country is riding high in international circles. Sierra Leone should aspire to this.

There’s a very naïve and conservative school of thought holding the view that the Public Order Act should not be reviewed, that libel should not be decriminalized – especially when it has caught Sylvia Blyden. No one should even think of swapping Sylvia’s imprisonment with the repeal of the Public Order Act. Decriminalizing libel does not mean journalists would just be writing anything against members of the public or against public officials. It means journalists would now be challenged through the civil courts, instead of having the police to start looking for you. It means journalists could be fined or get their properties confiscated if found culpable. To me, setting Sylvia free in exchange for repealing the Act would be more of a defeat for her ideologically than making her a press-freedom heroine by sending her to jail.

Let the dialogue begin. Let’s remove this bad law, if we want to be like Ghana. But it does not have to be through confrontation. We have to allow President Koroma, who promised to change the law, to take the lead or be consultatively engaged in the matter; and not push him. Just last Friday, the President recommitted himself in a meeting with the IMC that, “We believe in enhancing freedom of the press, and matters regarding the review of certain rules will be addressed,” calling for a dialogue on the Public Order Act, engaging all stakeholders, including journalists, policy makers, and members of the public.

That’s how we’ve got to do it. We need to scrutinize this law in the public interest. Somebody, writing about Westminster, has written that “One of Parliament’s greatest failings in recent years has been its inability to properly scrutinise the legislation brought before it.” So true for the Parliament that passed the notorious Public Order Act in 1965. Let it not be true of our Parliament and our country this century.

In short, I support the decriminalisation of libel (not even ten more trips to China will get me off this position). Through dialogue.

(This article was originally published in The Torchlight newspaper, www.thetorchlight.com)

Comments