From the Editor’s Keyboard

Transforming Public Finance Management in Africa (Part 2)

18 April 2009 at 21:05 | 891 views

By Kaifala Marah (Guest Writer),London.

PLANNING AND RESOURCE ALLOCATION

The national budget is a reflection of the philosophical, legal, social, political and economic aspirations of a nation and provides the framework within which these are prioritized and financed in an affordable manner. The budget-making process, therefore, in addition to its technical and financial aspects, is highly transparent and accountable to the citizens of Ontario, who finance it through taxation. The process inspires confidence in PFM and enhances ownership by the citizens, leading to better outcomes.

Objectives of a strategic budget process

The function of the budget process is to make choices between competing claims on scare public resources. In order to do this, the process in Ontario brings together all current claims with potential future claims arising from existing ones in an orderly manner.

Government cannot properly assess the optimal mix of expenditure outlays if it is not aware of all the options and their costs and benefits when it makes spending decisions.

A first principle of the budget process is that the choices must be informed by government’s strategic priorities. Spending decisions must take into account important policy objectives. On the other hand, policies should not be decided without reference to affordability.

In essence, budget and policies have to be decided together, this places the budget process at the heart of operationalising government’s development objectives. In Ontario, it is the task of the budget process to reconcile affordability with pressure for more and better public services.

This is not an easy task as it involves diverse and complex information sets and multilayered decision-making. Traditionally, governments have managed this complexity by budgeting in an incremental fashion, where new claims on resources were simply added to existing spending baselines, i.e. the current and future spending implications of all previous policy decisions.

Traditional budget structures where also not very good at linking resource allocations to policy priorities. Budgets were structured according to administrative units and line-items, a reflection of the priority placed on the budget’s function as an input control and accounting tool. Programme structures that link allocations to the expected policy achievements were absent.

In addition, policy development and financial planning were separated at all levels of government, with planning units working in the absence of resource limits, and budgeting officers working in isolation to allocate available resources between different inputs. Budgeting was seen as a technical exercise to be left to the technicians.

Systems such as these resulted not only in increasing deficits and debt service burdens, but also in poor spending quality. A modern approach to budgeting seeks to address these critical shortcomings.

Its aim is to endure that the structures, processes, rules and instruments used to decide between competing claims on resources will deliver the most strategic mix of out-puts given government’s development priorities and available resources.

Fiscal Policy

Fiscal Policy is the economic term which describes the actions of a government is setting the level of public expenditure and how that expenditure is funded. The starting points for expenditure programming are the establishment of fiscal objectives and a realistic assessment of resources likely to be available to the government. It is set within the overall vision of the government and it’s consistent with its national goals and objectives

The objectives of fiscal policy

Fiscal policy is concerned with the levels and composition of taxation, and government spending and borrowing. It encompasses fundamental policy issues, including the role and size of the state, equity between different, generations (because borrowing imposes a burden on future generations, whereas investment provided future benefits), the role of government in promoting growth and job creation and the amount and type of public services.

Fiscal policy has both macroeconomic and microeconomic objectives. In developing countries it should set desirable limits to government programmes and forecast external financing, through concessional borrowing or development partner grants.

The impact of external financing is both macro and microeconomic. The funds received have an impact on the external account aggregates, such as imports or exports and on the overall level of revenue, expenditure and borrowing. They also have an impact on the composition of expenditure, crowding in domestic resources in specific spending areas as counterpart funding, enabling government to spend more on non-donor funded spending, and creating long-term recurrent spending obligations. In countries that do not receive external assistance, fiscal policy is concerned with setting targets for forecasting domestic revenue only.

However, in most African countries the irregular flow of donor funds may upset not only the fiscal health of the system, but the overall development agenda of the country. The challenge therefore is one of sustainability of donor support, which in the medium term creates a vicious cycle of fiscal dependency with some of the immediate impacts being continuous indebtedness and the weakening of the domestic resource base.

Fiscal policy contrasts with monetary policy, which describes policies on the supply of money to the economy. The essence of fiscal planning lies in the drive and need to realise the social, economic and political goals of a nation. Fiscal framework provides a plan for achieving the stated goals and objectives within the overall realm of public finance.

The macro-fiscal framework

A country’s fiscal policy sets the macro-framework. This determines the total level of resources available for expenditure, and is a function of government’s fiscal policy objectives and macro-economic and revenue forecasts.

The macro-fiscal framework provides a basis for projecting public expenditure allocation over the medium term and creates the context within which key budget issues relating to revenue, expenditure and the financing of the budget deficit can be investigated.

Specifically, it involves making projections of the resources that are expected to be available to finance public expenditure over the medium term.

A sound macro-fiscal framework is a precondition for effective budget management. It provides an accurate projection of revenues and expenditures. There are several ways in which a weak framework will affect budget management.

For example, if the framework overestimates revenue and underestimates expenditure, the country will either need to borrow more than it should or had planned for or will need to make in -year expenditure cuts, thereby disrupting service delivery.

On the other hand, there is a significant opportunity cost to underestimating revenue or overestimating expenditure. If revenue is underestimated, the country forgoes opportunities to implement policies which could make a critical contribution to development.

If expenditure is overestimated - for example when absorption capacity is not taken sufficiently into account when allocating funds - funds may be trapped in one spending area, whereas they could have been better used in another, or the country may have borrowed when it did not really need to.

A weak framework therefore not only affects a country’s ability to manage its public finances prudently; it also affects its ability to make the best decisions about what should be funded and when.

Setting medium-term fiscal policy objectives

Over the past two decades, PFM in most African countries has moved from the annual setting of fiscal policy targets to medium- to long-term policy framework. Setting fiscal policy targets over the medium term has a number of benefits, including:

Facilitation of transformation, by creating scope for substantial reprioritization of policies and creating an integrated planning framework;

Enabling government to plan spending over the medium term, with a large number of benefits for the improved allocation and efficiency of public spending;

Encouraging investment by enhancing the predictability of taxes, interest rates and government demand

Increasing the transparency and creditability of government fiscal policy by explaining how the government intends to meet its targets, thereby contributing to lower debt service costs and lower interest rates;

Enhancing the opportunities for the participation of Parliament, the public and civil society institutions in budget making and in evaluating and monitoring the performance of government;

Increasing public and private sector efficiency by reducing changes to fiscal policy, so creating more stability in the tax system and in levels of public spending.

By using macroeconomic models, fiscal policy objectives are translated into fiscal policy targets which concern the overall level and distribution of spending, taxation and borrowing. Setting fiscal policy objectives and targets will, however, only deliver benefits if the targets are transparent and credible.

This is a function of how strong the linkages are between planning and budgeting, and budgeting and budget implementation. Key budgetary institutions for credible fiscal policy are realism and honesty in fiscal forecasting, transparency and government’s ability to set and enforce a strict budget constraint at aggregate level and for all institutions that have a claim on the public purse, both during the budget planning process and implementation.

The medium-term expenditure framework (MTEF) approach to budgeting has been adopted by many African countries to facilitate the maintenance of:

1. Aggregate fiscal discipline;

2. Strategic prioritization of expenditure between and within sectors; and

3. Improving technical efficiency in the use of scarce resources.

Well-crafted fiscal policy objectives are less likely to be thwarted by in-yea and ad hoc adjustments if the regular provision of timely reports on actual revenue and spending is an institutionalized practice. This is one way in which a credible MTEF system is dependent on complementary reforms elsewhere in the budget cycle.

Providing timely and credible information about government’s actual fiscal operations is another way in which the MTEF and budgeting system needs to be transparent in order for fiscal policy to deliver on its objectives. Developing, approving and publishing fiscal policy objectives and the resulting macro fiscal targets and framework need to be institutionalized appropriately in the budget cycle.

The main elements of the macro-fiscal framework and their function in the budget process are set out below:

Discussion of the medium-term macroeconomic outlook;

Projection of public revenues and a discussion of the underlying trends and assumptions;

Projection of how to finance the budget deficit and discussion of the underlying issues;

A breakdown of the main expenditure aggregates distinguishing between statutory and non-statutory expenditures.

Revenue projections

Public revenues comprise tax revenues, non-tax revenues (including income of budgetary institutions and external grants) and social fund contributions accruing to both central and local governments. The projection of revenues over the medium-term needs to be informed by:

An understanding of recent domestic revenue trends and patterns and the factors under-lying them;

An understanding of development partner grant financing commitments, including an analysis of risks associated with their reliability;

An assessment of the ‘tax burden’ and the scope for and desirability of further increases in the share of GDP taken as public revenues;

An assessment of agreed or planned tax policy changes and their expected impact o revenues;

An assessment of the scope for improvements in revenue administration.

Based on this analysis, an initial projection should be made of revenue as a share of GDP for each of the main revenue sources.

Since the revenue projections will reflect the implementation of planned tax policy measures and changes in tax administration, it is important to spell out what these measures are and the necessary actions to be taken to ensure their timely implementation. The projections should also take account of the impact of changes in major government spending aggregates, such as the size of the Government’s wage bill, where these are likely to have a significant impact on levels of revenue collection.

Key macro-fiscal framework principles

The macro-fiscal framework is the key instrument through which government monitors its financial health. How effectively the framework can fulfill this function depends on:

How comprehensive it is: if expenditure items are not included in the framework, for example all transfers to public enterprises, there can be no assurance that scarce resources are allocated to priority programmes and that legal control and public accountability are properly enforced;

How well it manages risk: If the framework does not make some allowance for risk, it is weakened. Albeit on account of external macroeconomic shocks, natural disasters or unexpected liabilities falling due;

The quality of data: If the macroeconomic or revenue projection models are bad, the quality of the frame work will be affected. Similarly, if government does not have good information on projected development partner grants of proper information on the forward costs of existing services and the cost of new policy proposals, it may agree to undertake projects and approve new policies that are not realizable within the planned framework;

How likely it is to be enforced: The planned macro-fiscal framework is only as good as its implementation. When the budget is weak as an instrument of law, in-year decisions become more significant for determining what will be financed. Even if the approved macro-fiscal framework is based on accurate data and is the result of a robust competitive process, it will be undermined by in-year decisions. But a quality of framework is unlikely to result from the budget preparation process when all actors know that it will have little or only a limited effect. Implementation discipline is a precondition for rigorous planning.

Therefore, how effective the macro-fiscal framework is in ensuring optimal budget outcomes is a function of the processes, systems and rules that are used to prepare, approve, implement and audit the budget.

Parameters of decision-making

The macro-fiscal process and its outcomes are governed by a set of decision-making rules that seek to maximize budgetary outcomes. The rules are aimed at ensuring that government will undertake only the activities that it can afford in the short, medium and long term, that it will first direct resources to its highest priorities and that the frame work will be implemented with maximum efficiency.

A first requirement for the framework is to maximize predictability of resources and minimize the risk of a mid-year crisis that will put governments fiscal, monetary and debt management objectives at risk.

A second requirement is that the rules of the macro-fiscal framework should maximize competition for public resources. Only under such conditions will government be able to: (i) improve the quality of spending by shifting funds from low priority to high priority activities; and (ii) prevent its spending obligations from growing increasingly unaffordable as new priorities are added, while old spending commitments are still met.

A third requirement is that the rules for the macro-fiscal framework should minimize the risk that new claims on resources will arise during the spending year. Such claims either put fiscal policy or spending policy objectives at risk by diverting funds from other spending areas, or result in additional borrowing and higher debt service cost in future years.

These requirements mean that:

* Government should only take into account external grant financing that is definitely committed.

* Government does not include development partner budget support flows into the core fiscal framework on account of their high unpredictability. However, it should identify the spending activities that will be funded by these resources under a second revenue scenario.

*Government commits to not changing fiscal policy, the fiscal strategy or the parameters of the fiscal framework substantially during the remainder of the budget preparation process in response to individual spending bids. The only changes to the main frame work revenue and spending ceilings should be on account of updated macroeconomic and revenue projections, given agreed fiscal policy objectives.

*Government will eventually identify and include in the overall macro-fiscal framework all revenue streams and spending obligations that are not appropriated through the main budget. These will include all extra-budgetary funds. A main budget framework and resource envelope would result from subtracting these revenues and expenditures from the overall macro-fiscal framework.

*Government will take the necessary steps to take into account contingent liabilities, for example government guarantees, when deciding the fiscal frame work. This will include listing these liabilities as a transparency measure.

Balancing priorities

The allocation of the budget is one of the most important decisions of any government. Budgetary choices define government’s ambitions and recognize the limits of what it can achieve given the resources at its disposal. Budget choices are political choices.

It is difficult to measure and compare the benefits of different public spending programmes. There is no spreadsheet or formula which enables government to choose among spending priorities. Deciding whether one activity is more important than another is ultimately about political preferences and is a value judgment.

However, in a functional budget process these value judgments are made on the basis of the best available information and high quality technical analysis. The role of the technocrats therefore becomes more important, since they undertake the critical analysis, set out choices and provide assessments of trade-offs against standardized criteria.

These different roles of technocrats and politicians play out at different levels. At ministerial level, individual ministers provide leadership for key tradeoffs within a function of government, while Ministry officials are responsible for running a process of planning, programming and analysis to expose the key choices.

At national level, the Cabinet takes the lead in deciding between competing priorities, while officials in the Ministry of Finance, together with the Ministry of Planning and national Development are responsible for providing similar advice on key trade-offs between the functions of government.

The author is a Sierra Leonean-born financial expert working as Adviser, Public Expenditure Management, Governance and Institutional Development Division, Commonwealth Secretariat, London

Comments