Salone News

The Speaker as Parliamentarian: Repeal Section 77(1) (b)

3 March 2014 at 06:13 | 1534 views

Essay

By Dr. Peter A. Dumbuya, Freetown, Sierra Leone.*

.

Introduction

In rethinking the judicial power under the current 1991 Constitution, I called for clarity and precision in the demarcation of the original and appellate jurisdiction of the courts, principally the Supreme Court of Sierra Leone, so as to aid the public, Bar, and Bench in navigating the labyrinthine world of the law. Even though, as Alexander Hamilton confided in Federalist No.78, “The Judiciary, on the contrary, has no influence over either the sword or the purse; no direction either of the strength or of the wealth of the society, and can take no active resolution whatever,” its role, even as “the weakest of the three departments of power,” is still central to maintaining the rule of law and protecting our fundamental rights and freedoms against encroachment by the other two branches of government. Hamilton, therefore, predated Chief Justice John Marshall (in Marbury v. Madison, 5 U.S. 137 (1803) when he wrote that “The
interpretation of the laws is the proper and peculiar province of the courts.”

In this essay, I emphasize, albeit in passing (since this issue has been dealt with in my essay on presidential power and the separation of powers/checks and balances), the concept of “fusion” found in the 1991 Constitution with regard to the composition of Parliament.

Section 73(2) vests legislative power in Parliament which comprises the President, Speaker, and Members of Parliament (Section 73(1)). My learned friends and colleagues, Hon. Justice Dr. Abdulai O. Conteh and former Special Court Judge Dr. Bankole Thompson, have already weighed in on the necessity, or lack thereof, of amending Section 79(1) of the Constitution relating to the election of the Speaker from among Members of Parliament (MPs) or from among
current or former Judges/Justices of the Superior Court of Judicature. Here, I offer another critical exposition of what’s new and what could have been done to solidify the position of Speaker in a Parliament that seeks to flex its role as a co-equal branch of the government with the right to choose its own leader from its own rank and file.

Amending Section 79(1)

Prior to amendment, Section 79(1) read as follows: “The Speaker of Parliament shall be elected by the Members of Parliament from among persons who are Members of Parliament or are qualified to be elected as such and who are qualified to be appointed Judges of the Superior Court of Judicature or have held such office:

Provided that a person shall be eligible for election as Speaker of Parliament
notwithstanding that such person is a Public Officer or a Judge of the High Court, a Justice of the Court of Appeal or a Justice of the Supreme Court, and such person, if elected, shall retire from the Public Service on the day of his election with full benefits.”

In January 2014, “The Constitution of Sierra Leone (Amendment) Act, 2013” appeared in the Gazette. It repealed and replaced Section 79(1) with the following:

“The Speaker of Parliament shall be elected by the Members of Parliament from among persons who are-

(a) Members of Parliament and who had served as such for not less than five years; or

(b) qualified to be Members of Parliament and who had served as such for not less than ten years,” and who are not less than forty years.

Objections to the proposed amendment coalesced around two broadly defined groups.The first group of objectors, including non-governmental organizations (NGOs) and civil society organizations (CSOs), suggested that the issue should be looked into by the Constitution Review Committee (CRC), and thus urged the President not to sign the bill. The second group comprised mainly lawyers/judges who argued that Section 79(1) already provided for the election of the Speaker from among MPs.

The goal of the MPs in favor of the amendment was embedded in the “Memorandum of Objects and Reasons” the Attorney General and Minister of Justice appended to the Bill, published in the Gazette on October 23, 2013, but subsequently removed from the Act (No.5, 2013). It read:

“The object of this Bill is to clearly and unambiguously state the persons who
qualify to be Speaker of Parliament and the mode of election of Deputy Speaker.” Gone are the provisions relating to the election of the Speaker from among current or former Judges and Justices of the Superior Court of Judicature. May be the election as Speaker of a current or former Judge/Justice of the Superior Court of Judicature, the other branch of government, did
not dovetail with notions of parliamentary independence or fell afoul of the separation of powers concept as we understand it today.

The then Majority Leader, now Speaker, Hon. S.B.B. Dumbuya, correctly stated the constitutional fact that Parliament can, without waiting for the CRC, amend the ordinary provisions of the Constitution pursuant to Section 108(1-2), as opposed to the entrenched provisions that have to be approved in a referendum consonant with Section 108(3). In this regard he stated, after winning the Speaker election in a landslide (100 to 15 votes) against Hon.
Dr. Bu-Buakei Jabbi, that “Parliament, …, waits for no man in the enactment of its laws.” With regard to the mode of electing the Speaker, the then Majority Leader also correctly stated the practice in many, if not most, countries where the Speaker is not only elected from among members of the legislature, but also keeps his/her seat as a member therein. This is what he had to say in Parliament as reported in the Standard Times newspaper of January 27 2014, page 18:

“This day marks the crystallization of an idea that had not only been
conceived for so long; it marks the rectification of a situation which to many had been consider[ed] not only as most preposterous and untenable, but also diametrically at variance with what obtains in other jurisdictions and patently incompatible with the now much-talked about concept of international best practice-that of having a Speaker of Parliament from out of Parliament.”

With all deliberate speed, Parliament fulfilled part of the pledge, which, according to Hon. Dumbuya, is the creation of a “Parliament for the Parliamentarians.” This effort, however, left intact another part of the Constitution, Section 77(1) (b), which threw the new Speaker out of his Constituency by requiring that he “shall vacate his seat in Parliament.” In a weird way, instead of consolidating the role of the Speaker as Parliamentarian, the exercise threw out the proverbial baby with the bath water!

A couple of examples will suffice. In the United States, the Speaker (Hon. John Boehner of Ohio) is elected from among Members of the House of Representatives, and, unlike what obtains in Sierra Leone, he is still a Member of Congress. Similarly, in the United Kingdom, the Speaker of the House of Commons (Hon. John Bercow) keeps his seat as an MP for Buckingham.

Section 77(1) (b) Lurks in the Shadows

The 2013 amendment (Act No. 5) to the 1991 Constitution, while abrogating the requirement that the Speaker could, in addition to Members of Parliament, be elected from among persons “who are qualified to be appointed Judges of the Superior Court of judicature or have held such office,” did not end the practice of separating the Speaker from his Constituency, and thus placed
Parliament in a continuing situation where its Speaker can no longer be a Member of Parliament.

Why, then, did Parliament not repeal Section 77(1) (b) that mandates an MP to vacate his seat “if he is elected Speaker of Parliament”? Does the new Section 79(1) (b) effectively do what repeal of Section 77(1) (b) could have done for candidates for the highest office in Parliament? Will the fact that the current Speaker is no longer an MP, pursuant to Section 77(1) (b), cause one to
raise a constitutional issue should he decide to run for the same position on the dissolution of the current Parliament, pursuant to Section 77(1) (a)? The fallback position seems to be the new Section 79(1) (b) with its ten-year limitation period and age requirement for former MPs to be eligible for election as Speaker.

In seeking answers to these questions, I requested a meeting with the Hon. Speaker (no relation) and then sent him, ahead of time, the crucial question on the failure to repeal Section 77(1) (b). Then on Friday February 28, while conducting research in the Library of Parliament, the Speaker called me to his office across the hallway. In a frank and candid manner, he told me why Section 77(1) (b) was not repealed along with the amendment to Section 79(1): it was due to an “oversight” on the part of Members.

I appreciated the Speaker’s candor and forthright manner in which he discussed this critical issue with me. Next, we discussed the new Section 79(1) (b) which provides for the election of the Speaker from among persons who are not only qualified to be MPs, but had also served as MPs for at least ten years, and are at least forty years old. The latter point, minus the new age requirement, reinforces the argument that an MP was eligible to be elected Speaker of
Parliament prior to repeal of Section 79(1); otherwise why should the new Speaker have to give up his seat in the legislature?

Conclusion

The Speaker, in my professional judgment, should keep his/her seat in Parliament, as is the practice in democracies where the twin concepts of separation of powers and checks and balances are critical to the rule of law.

Further, to minimize any constitutional ambiguity over the election of the next Speaker, I suggested to the Hon. Speaker, respectfully, the utility of repealing Section 77(1) (b) so that the Speaker can hold on to his/her seat in Parliament.

At its core, this is what I understood the then Majority Leader to have meant when he spoke of the need for Parliament to assert its independence from the other two branches of government and thereby become a “Parliament for the Parliamentarians.” As an MP, the Speaker will be accountable both to his/her constituents and to the nation as a whole. Under our separation of powers concept, this realignment will place the Speaker on a par with the heads of the Executive and Judicial branches of government, namely the President and Chief Justice respectively.

Ask any constitutional lawyer, and he/she will tell you that legal drafting, even when done with due diligence, is not as easy as it looks; we spend countless numbers of hours in and out of courts dissecting legalese!

*Dr. Peter Dumbuya teaches History at an American University. He is currently a Fulbright Scholar at the Law Department, Fourah Bay College, University of Sierra Leone. He is also a professional lawyer.

Comments