Commentary
The collapse of educational standards in Sierra Leone and what went wrong in the country once the Athens of West Africa.
From Canada, Anthony Karim Kamara Sr discusses what he believes to be the reasons for the educational decline and collapse of standards.
Western education was introduced into Sierra Leone and the rest of British West Africa by the Church Missionary Society (CMS) in the early 19th century with Sierra Leone leading the way in this direction. This was to repair the damage done to Africa by the injustice, brutalities and inhuman treatment of Africans caused by the slave trade which saw millions of Africans trans-shipped across the Atlantic to labour on the islands in the Caribbean Sea, Central and South America. The CMS Missionaries started the very first primary institutions along western lines in the mountain villages of the Freetown peninsular. In spite of a number of initial setbacks and frustrations resulting in closures and re-openings, their focus was on success as failure was not an option.
Having led the way in Western education in West Africa, one would imagine that Sierra Leone should by now be the best and the leader of other Anglophone countries in the sub-region; they should be looking up to Sierra Leone as the model for educational accomplishments. Unfortunately this has not been the case. Educationally, our country is at the tail end today. The first university institution in West Africa, Fourah Bay College, The Athens of West Africa interestingly started in 1827 without a single secondary school either in Sierra Leone or West Africa. It was eighteen years later that the very first secondary school for Boys the CMS Grammar was opened in 1845 in Freetown and four
years later another for Girls, the Annie Walsh Memorial School was started in 1849.
I have just returned from a short vacation in Freetown and during my short stay, I watched on SLBC Television debates by academics and other supposedly enlightened persons in society on the reasons for the decline of education for which both Governments the SLPP and the APC seem indifferent to address. Both the SLPP and APC are to blame for this shameful situation and they both try to shift the blame on the kids and parents. By the end of this contribution, readers will be able to point their fingers at which party was more responsible for the ruin of this country’s educational system.
All educated Sierra Leoneans of age 55 and above did their primary schooling partly in the colonial era and their secondary after 1961. I did my primary schooling in the 50s and my secondary in the mid 60s. I know too well the British system we found in our days.
Throughout the colonial era, primary education in Sierra Leone was of eight year duration and at two levels. The first level included Class 1 and Class11: next was the Standard (Std) level: Standard 1 to V1. This makes it a total of 8 years of primary education, at the end of which the student normally took what was known as “The Common Entrance Examination” for entry to secondary schools. The student was offered a choice of two schools, a First choice and a Second choice of schools. The Common Entrance is not the same as today’s Selective Entrance Exams which a student would pass and cannot find a place in the secondary school because of low pass grades. Arithmetic and English Exams of the Common Entrance can hardly be challenged by any Form 11 of today. There were no multiple choice questions and therefore there was no way to guess the answer to a question. All who passed the Common Entrance found places in the schools of their choice unlike the situation today under the Selective Entrance Exams (SEE). In fact after 1962, a third level of two more years was added to the Primary system with the introduction of what was called Senior Primary (SP 1) and Senior Primary (SP2). Government thinking behind the two additional years was to adequately prepare the new entrant to Form 1 and be more mature for the secondary level. They would have been introduced to French, algebra and geometry prior to Form 1. This made a total of ten years of primary education for the child. Government hoped to temporarily recruit Sixth form leavers to handle these subjects which the average primary school teacher could not teach. Sixth form teachers proved to be the best in those days. These additional two years were however discontinued because the sixth form leavers were too focussed on going for their university studies, and the primary school teachers could not handle them as most never went to secondary school. The explanation was convincing, and so the system was once again reverted to the eight year duration, which was still good anyway. All these developments took place from colonial times up to the two Margai administrations, Sir Milton and Sir Albert Margai. Schools were few and therefore the quality of education was unquestioned.
We used primary English and mathematics text books from England in all subjects,-Queen Primer Parts 1 to 6. Even by the time some of us entered the secondary school there were no text books by West African Writers as it is today. It was all books used in England by English kids.
But with the restoration of constitutional rule in 1969 following the overthrow of the National Reformation Council (NRC) of Juxton-Smith, a national government was formed from both the SLPP and the APC under Mr Siaka Stevens as Prime Minister and was to last for three years (1969 to72) at the end of which by-elections were to be held and a return to party government, which saw the APC government in total control in 1972 and continued till 1992 after 30 years in power when President Stevens’ preferred successor Joseph Saidu Momoh was overthrown by the military junta under Valentine Strasser.
Between 1969 and 1980 there were atleast five Ministers of Education in Sierra Leone all under the APC administration first under Mr Siaka Stevens and later Major-General Joseph Saidu Momoh. They included Augustine J Sandy, J. Barthes Wilson, Abdul Karim Koroma and Dr Moses Dumbuya. Dr. Christiana Thorpe was minister after the overthrow of the APC in 1992.It was during this twelve year period that the country’s educational system saw its decline and ultimate collapse to its present state. Following their victory in 1972, the then APC Minister of Education, Late Barthes Wilson announced changes in the educational system which was to reduce the time spent in primary schools from eight years to six, a reduction by two years. From the beginning of 1973, there was to be six years of primary schooling starting with Class 1 and ending at Class V1 and then the new Selective Entrance Examination (SEE) to replace the difficult CEE for entry to secondary admission. The question now is “What level-headed politician would equate six years of primary education to eight years in quality and content? Readers would provide the answers later. Since that time the system has been gradually moving down south with no effort by anyone to arrest it and reverse the trend. The 1970s also saw the APC administration in physical confrontation with College students as well as the Labour congress. This explains the reasons for the other side describing the APC as a party of mostly petty traders, taxi drivers and thugs associated with violence. They showed little interest in the education of this nation’s children.
In his recent meeting with the Press, the Minister of Education Dr Minkailu Bah told the assembled media practitioners that “students and teachers are to blame for the decline in educational standards”. He also said ‘teachers are wasted human resources’. These are unfortunate remarks by someone supposed to find solutions to the never ending problems of his ministry. The Minister unfortunately did not understand these things as he was too young a Form 111 student in 1975 at the Magburaka Boys’ secondary school when the system went down the drains during the old APC government of the time. Politicians always shift the blame for their lapses and failures to officials in their Ministries and parents and refuse to accept responsibility. But the reality is the system suffered a serious setback from the early seventies when it was reduced from eight to six years and has been ‘progressively ‘worsening over the years, and today it is almost at a point of wreck if not already there from what I saw and heard people say during my recent visit to Freetown.
When Britain sneezes, Anglophone West Africa catches cold according to the old saying. Sierra Leone is no exception to this mess. The introduction of the 6-3-3-4 proved a disaster to Sierra Leone’s educational system as most people did not even understand what the new system would mean for the country and its innocent young students. All that delighted the government of the day was that the new system would be funded by the U K Government. The money aspect was the bait. Dr Moses Dumbuya was the 6-3-3-4 Minister of Education. There was a proliferation of buildings called schools all over the country. These schools were constructed during President Tejan Kabba’s SLPP rule in both visible and invisible areas of the country. The invisible schools were constructed by the Ministry of Education and only existed in the mind of ministry officials, a fertile ground for the dead teachers to return from the under world.The new system was branded as ‘Sababu Education’ which may be ‘good sababu or bad sababu’ education, and in this case it is, in the opinion of many ‘bad sababu’ education, and was popularised by the SLPP’s Minister of Education Dr Alpha Wurie. How could one talk about quality with a weak primary school background followed by an equally weak three year junior secondary schooling and the weakness continues to the next level and finally sent the poorly prepared students to do the four year university programme? Even if the present APC administration is considering a return to the pre-1972 system, it’s going to be an uphill task because damage has already been done to this country’s children and for far too long. The 6-3-3-4 system was introduced during the administration of Joseph Saidu Momoh, the worst Head of State this country has ever seen . President Ernest Koroma may be considering a return to the old way but may not be easy as it has been around for far too long and may only cause more damage to the already damaged system.
Since the introduction of this 6-3-3-4 system, class sizes have been quintupled in size, and the system became untenable. Teachers can no longer handle the classes, and both the SLPP and APC administrations always indifferent to the education of the poor, shift the blame on teachers as the scapegoats. Class sizes in the pre-1972 years in most schools never exceeded 40 at most. Today there is no government assisted school in the entire Sierra Leone which has a class size of less than 80 and in quite a good number of Schools, the class size is up to 100 with half of the class sitting on windows or standing. What quality would any reasonable person expect from the school system while politicians keep making bogus policy statements and shifting the blame to teachers whom they expect to be magicians in the classroom and parents? The bottom line is, the 6-3-3-4 dealt the final blow on the system. Only government officials and politicians at the Ministry of Education understand its value but surely not the parents or their kids. These students after they pass out of school have the potential of becoming pick pockets and criminals in the society and today hundreds of such kids can be seen every day under the tree at Lightfoot-Boston Street near Connaught hospital peddling dozens of cell phones and other stolen items from Lebanese shops in the city, and in Sanni Abacha street and PZ area watching passers-by ready to snatch whatever they could grab and flee. What about the new BECE examination, what benefit has it brought to the school kids? The BECE exams is just a new name to make Grade 9 students believe they got some secondary education. As a matter of fact it is nothing new to the country. Before some of us went to secondary school, there was the Junior Cambridge Exams taken at the end of the Form 111 in those colonial years; then in the early 60’s the Junior Cambridge was replaced for a new Form 111 Exams which was taken up to 1963/66 which served no real purpose. The Form 111 exams was a gratis examination as it was subsidised by the Milton Margai and Albert Margai SLPP administrations, but was soon abandoned after five years’ experiment, until the re-introduction of this BECE under the Joseph Saidu Momoh administration. Does the BECE do any good to the Junior Secondary school kids? May be the Ministry of Education and the WAEC Office can tell us the answer.
Another agonizing factor in undermining education in Sierra Leone is the delay in paying teachers’ salaries. This is the final straw that broke the system. As far as I can recall, salary delay goes back to the years 1967 to 1970 when the first military junta (NRC) imposed itself in this country under Brigadier Andrew Juxton-Smith. At that time it began with two weeks late in salary payments, and then one month in arrears. During the Siaka Stevens era, it became ‘progressively ‘ worse especially after the OAU Summit of 1980 and today new teacher recruits work for two or three years without approval by the Ministry, thereby putting poor teachers at the mercy of their school Heads for survival. The Ministry of Education under the two APC administrations and the SLPP Kabba administration both hopelessly under-performed in the area of education. They are to blame for the collapse in the system and not the parents and their kids. Instead of accepting their lapses and pitfalls, most politicians are busy praise-worshipping the under-performance of their regimes. Everybody is just concerned about how to survive under the system of the day. In the absence of regular salaries, the teachers have no choice but to resort to private lessons for those students who can pay for them: and make no mistake these private classes have come to stay so long as they are conducted in private homes and nobody can stop them, after all everyone has the right to make a living. Teachers are also ‘Baboons’ not barely monkeys’. They need food for their families to survive.
Another reason people often give as being responsible for the educational collapse is the ten year civil conflict. I beg to disagree. This system had been wrecked years before the ten year civil war broke out. Sure during the internecine period there was anarchy and everything came to a halt. Did the entire SLPP government not go into exile in Conakry? Was the country not left without a visible government? If the rulers of the country could flee the country, who was there to give orders? The country was in a state of anarchy. All those who had the means to flee this country did what they could to escape and became refugees in neighbouring countries. Nobody announced a stoppage of education, but everyone took cover somewhere. The reality was that the war years were years of hunger, pain, homelessness and increasing poverty among the populace in which law and order completely broke down. School kids (both boys and girls) joined the warring factions for survival to help provide for their parents and other loved ones. Of course there were atrocities like rape, inter factional killings. After the war, there were serious social problems including how to re-open schools and persuade the youths to return to school. Even some of the teachers joined in the fighting just to survive. In short every age group of our society became rebels in one way or other. All this simply shows that war is evil and those who caused it will today wonder whether it was worth it. The civil war made almost everyone lawless and it is this lawlessness that has continued to this day, in particular, student violence in school athletics meet and in the classroom. Did Kenema school kids not kill an Okada rider in Kenema last year with a mathematical set compass? Was another Okada rider not killed early this year again in Kenema city by Kenema School kids? School athletics today compare to the annual Paddle carnival in the city when no one with self respect would dare stand along the streets watching a carnival without the risk of being attacked by a drug addict. The war simply made the youths aggressively lawless through the use of prohibited substances which were supplied free of charge in the war years to embolden them.
In sum, the Ministry of Education must try to accept the true causes of the country’s educational decline and find solutions instead of shifting the blame on those responsible for educating tomorrow’s leaders by calling them names to conceal its inability to pay its employees’ salaries for their labour. Nowhere in the world is labour free, it is something paid for and the worker has every right to withhold his labour if not paid. Why in the first place must Government always wait for a strike to start before taking matters serious? Does the government not always receive a 21 day notice for strike action? Why not intervene before the strike commences? The workers have come to realise that the only language government understands is that of strike action.

Comments