Salone News

Remittances and Homeland Development

1 May 2013 at 18:00 | 882 views

By Dr. Peter A. Dumbuya, USA.

Introduction

According to recent reports by researchers affiliated with the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD), the World Bank, African Development Bank (ADB), and International Organization for Migration (IOM), among others, an increasing number of Africans are now domiciled outside their home countries. The number has topped 30 million or about 3 percent of the continent’s population. What has caught the attention of researchers at UNCTAD and other international institutions is the growing amount of remittances migrants from developing countries are send back to their home countries. These amounts are now said to have exceeded the combined amounts of foreign direct investment (FDI) and official development assistance (ODA) to these developing countries. These figures have profound near and long-term consequences for Sierra Leone in particular and Africa generally.

That Hurried Phone Call: Send Me Money

The World Bank’s “Migration and Development Brief 19” of November 20, 2012, reported a significant increase in “officially recorded remittances to developing countries.” These are estimated at $406 billion in 2012 compared to $381 billion in 2011 ($341 billion in 2010 and $316 billion in 2009). Remittances to developing countries are forecast to increase to $438 billion in 2013, $482 billion in 2014, and $534 billion in 2015. Information released by the ADB shows a fourfold increase in remittances to Africa since 1990, topping $40 billion in 2010. These amounts do not take into consideration informal money transfers (such as money spent when migrants visit their home countries) and personal property that migrants often ship in to families and friends in their home countries. Western Union and Money Gram are said by the ADB to control 65 percent of the remittance market in Africa. The U.S. is home to most migrants from and also the source of most remittances to developing countries.

The World Bank reports India ($70 billion), China ($66 billion), the Philippines ($24 billion), Mexico ($24 billion), and Nigeria ($21 billion) as the top five recipients of remittances from migrants. For a country like Liberia, remittances account for 31 percent of its gross domestic product (GDP). Table 1 shows the amount of remittances to Sierra Leone between the end of the civil war in 2002 and 2012; they constitute about 3.4 percent of GDP by 2011. Between 2003 and 2010, flows of remittances from Sierra Leone to Sierra Leoneans in the diaspora, on the other hand, amounted to between $2 million (2005) and $4 million (2007), an indication that the country is becoming more dependent on outside sources of funding for various familial and societal projects.

Table 1: Remittances to Sierra Leone in US$ Millions

Year

2002

2003

2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

2009

2010

2011

2012

US$

22

26

25

2

16

42

28

47

58

77

80

Source: Migration and Remittances Fact book 2011, p. 220.

Remittance flows to Sierra Leone now compare favorably with the country’s ODA ($400 million), state reserves ($200 million), and exports ($300 million). In 2010, for instance, figures released by the office of the U.S. trade representative show that U.S. imports from Sierra Leone amounted to $29 million, whereas U.S. exports to Sierra Leone stood at $61.1 million, thereby creating a U.S. trade surplus of $32.1 million. In other words, in 2010 Sierra Leoneans abroad sent in more money ($58 million) to their home country than the country’s overall trade with the U.S.

Cost-Benefit Analysis of Remittances

Remittances to Sierra Leone and other developing countries are a blessing to hard-pressed families and the state alike. They are used for a variety of purposes such as education, health care, rent, transportation, food, and other day-to-day living expenses. They are an invaluable source of foreign exchange for the government and, institutionally, a spur to the growth of banks and other financial institutions.

Push and pull factors have also had a negative effect on the country’s ability to retain skilled personnel. A significant segment of the migrant population is comprised of skilled professionals. An entry in Migration and Remittances Fact book 2011 indicated that skilled professionals who have left the country for greener pastures accounted for 52.5 percent of the tertiary-educated population of Sierra Leone. The brain drain is manifest in our nurses, medical doctors, and other professionals who are leaving the country because of poverty, low wages, corruption, and other obstacles to doing business at home.

Anecdotal evidence shows a lack of return on investment in the form of remittances. Businesses that remittances are supposed to fund either do not materialize or are often run to the ground because of mismanagement and a lack of business acumen. Often enough, the money is “eaten,” meaning it has been spent on consumables, merchandise is not replenished, and the business atrophies as a result.

Personally, I resent being called a “jus cam,” which is what a teenage girl, one I had never met before, called me on a visit to Masiaka town in 2007. As I understand it, it means either I had just arrived or I had “just come” into the country, apparently after the civil war. In Freetown, I have heard the same description of visiting Sierra Leoneans, but when I asked an acquaintance whether the same term can be used to describe, say an Indian merchant on Siaka Stevens Street, she shrugged her shoulders as if to say “you got me.” These are some of the indignities we subject each other to as Sierra Leoneans, the assumption being that those of us who are domiciled abroad or overseas belong to a separate category of the “others.” We may live in the U.S. or Europe, but we care about our country so much so that we remit money to our families and friends on a regular basis, and also contribute in significant ways to the development of Sierra Leone.

Most frustrating of all is people’s attitude toward money and work. Recipients of remittances often show their gratitude, usually out of the hearing of donors, by saying that “there is more money where this came from.” This attitude is erroneous because it is based on the belief that there is an endless supply of money out there which someone else has to earn and remit to them without any thought of reciprocity. It is completely devoid of a work ethos which is at the core of the country’s inability to climb out of grinding poverty. It also shows a lack of correlation between work/earnest labor and money. It has promoted a culture of dependency that all of us, particularly our national and local government leaders, must counter with a robust work ethic. Only through hard work can we build a truly prosperous, stable, and democratic society.

Conclusion

Like the national budget, remittances are subject to the unpredictability of the international economy which has been in a recession since 2007. Therefore, as host countries are buffeted by economic and fiscal stresses, they are resorting to restrictive immigration policies which will, in the long run, if not sooner, affect migrants’ ability to remit money back home.

President Ernest B. Koroma closes out his second term in office with an ambitious “Agenda for Change.” One of the principles of this poverty-alleviation strategy is private-sector job creation. One of the many daunting challenges facing the current and future governments is how to create job opportunities especially for the more than 70 percent of the unemployed young men and women of Sierra Leone. With the general population nearing or exceeding six million, it is essential that we make job creation number one priority. As the government looks to raising the annual economic growth rate to 10 percent, remittances are one way to create jobs by self-employment, while the other is to create an enabling environment conducive to general private-sector job creation.

For instance, the ministries of finance and development, trade and industry, and labor and social security, can pool their resources together to establish and fund a small business agency tasked with providing guidelines and structural support to small businesses. The goal of such an organization is to give Sierra Leoneans, most of whom who are small business owners and street/roadside vendors, an opportunity to break into the wholesale and import-export business. After everything has been said and done, the path to prosperity and political tranquility lies in sustained economic growth with employment for all Sierra Leoneans, so that that late night or early morning phone call can be a thing of the past.

Comments