Analysis

Pathways from Poverty in Sierra Leone

22 March 2007 at 09:14 | 1139 views

"Although our moral sense promptly tells us who is poor, because poverty is ocular (we can quickly see it), it is not very easy to provide a quantitative threshold or cut-off point below which we want to characterize people as poor. The World Bank uses a $1 and $2 a day as a threshold; meaning that someone who cannot earn a $1 or $2 a day should be classified as poor. Some critics think that this threshold is too low and it actually defines abject destitution. Those of us living abroad might take a dollar or two for granted, not so in some areas of the world."

By Christopher Warburton, USA.

Dedicated to The Sierra Leone Youth League of America

Who is poor?

Poverty is a state of destitution. That is, it is a state in which individuals find themselves unable, or struggling to provide basic needs. By “basic needs,” I allude to things like food, shelter, clothing, and transportation. In actual fact, some of these needs could be classified as fundamental rights which every human being is entitled to in his/her capacity as a human. These rights were generally acknowledged by the United Nations (UN) General Assembly in 1948.

To the extent that they were generally acknowledged and adopted as a UN resolution, does not necessarily mean that they could be easily implemented. One problem with international law is that rules or laws could not be easily enforced because the UN is essentially a confederation of sovereign states with no strong center. These rights are therefore procedural rights with emphasis on entitlement, which does not necessarily assure positive consequence. In other words you can have a right to land, but that does not necessarily mean that anyone is obligated to make sure you don’t starve. These rights are more meaningful if we can relate them to goals or objectives. An Economist called Amartya Sen, who is also a Nobel Prize winner, argues for a right-objective correlation, and today we tend to evaluate procedural rights against capabilities.

Although our moral sense promptly tells us who is poor, because poverty is ocular (we can quickly see it), it is not very easy to provide a quantitative threshold or cut-off point below which we want to characterize people as poor. The World Bank uses a $1 and $2 a day as a threshold; meaning that someone who cannot earn a $1 or $2 a day should be classified as poor. Some critics think that this threshold is too low and it actually defines abject destitution. Those of us living abroad might take a dollar or two for granted, not so in some areas of the world.

Poverty may be measured in relative or absolute terms. The absolute measure uses income per year to determine how much is required to purchase basic needs. Relative poverty defines the percentage of individuals or families that could be placed in the lowest percent of individuals or families receiving income. Data collection in Sierra Leone seems to be rapidly improving, but I do not have a current data for those living below the poverty line. The Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) estimates that about 68% of Sierra Leoneans were living below the poverty line in 1989. This means that only 32% of Sierra Leoneans could afford basic needs in 1989. I was also not able to obtain a current number from the World Bank or Central Statistics Office (CSO). It is difficult to extrapolate what the number might be because of net migration (i.e. the difference between those leaving the country and those who are migrating into the country from neighboring Guinea, Liberia and elsewhere) although the economy is growing at about 7-8% according to the CIA and World Bank.

Why are some people poor?

Poverty is mostly the result of:

(i) Deprivation of capability/opportunity;

(ii)Lack of education;

(iii)Joblessness/unemployment;

(iv)Lack of economic growth (increase in national output);

(v)Lack of income or lack of bequest/gift/remittances; (QED)

(vi) Adverse or no redistributive policies when there is market failure**

Notice that I have excluded the exchange rate because it has no direct impact on poverty, even if there is a potentially remote effect, such an effect is not apparent. I am of course implicitly ascertaining that inflation is not synonymous with exchange rate. I will discuss this in detail later.

(i)Deprivation of capability/opportunity

If people are deprived of opportunities to realize their full potential, they cannot possibly make an upward mobility to earn a decent wage, enjoy property rights, or income to advance their welfare. This is largely a policy oriented problem; meaning that if a government does not provide the environment for its citizens to really maximize their human capabilities, they could easily be trapped in poverty. For example, deprivation of the right to choose a government that is responsive to societal needs, or the abject lack of avenues to get an education or satisfactory health care to realize god-given potential, could easily perpetuate poverty. Statistics on Sierra Leone for 2001 show that for a population of 6 million, which is growing at an approximate average annual rate of 2.3% (CIA), there is zero government operated school. Two thousand six hundred and seventy-nine are government assisted; and twenty five, are private schools (CSO). This does not seem to provide adequate opportunity for learning.

(ii) Lack of Education

If Sierra Leoneans are uneducated, they are inherently disadvantaged to get a skilled or high paying job. By saying so categorically, I am also assuming that if there is free factor (labor) mobility, labor will flow to places of need beyond the Sierra Leonean frontiers. In other words, if Sierra Leoneans can’t find a job in Freetown, with sophisticated skills and ability to migrate, they can migrate to other portions of Africa or the world and utilize those skills to earn a decent living and improve their welfare. Of course this does not always mean that those without an education cannot get wealthy. If they are very industrious and fortunate, they can certainly make income and stay above the poverty line. Education merely enhances the prospects of living above the poverty line. To the extent that literacy is defined in terms of English, Arabic and vernacular languages, an evaluation of employment which is based on literacy, must take into consideration the functionality of literacy. Are people literate enough to obtain and retain jobs regardless of the language which they speak?

(iii) Unemployment/Joblessness

If Sierra Leoneans are unemployed or jobless they cannot possibly earn income, except they beg, borrow, steal, or obtain handouts from the government, acquaintances or relatives. There are some people who are particularly vulnerable and not employable in society. These include those who are too old, too young, or too sick to work, but who might also have no family member to care for them. These people are evidently in dire condition and susceptible to chronic poverty. Aggregate poverty will increase if able-bodied workers cannot find a job. In national economies there are unpredictable patterns or cycles of economic performance, which in actual fact are gyrations/fluctuations of output as time progresses. Collectively, these cycles are known as the business cycle. A recession is a time when an economy is not doing too well, national output falls, and people are laid off or sacked. Without adequate income for a protracted period of time, some of these laid-off workers or employable (workers in the labor force) who find themselves out of work, can easily become poorer.

(iv)Lack of economic growth

When Economists talk about economic growth, they are alluding to an increase in national output or income, which is also known as gross domestic product (GDP). GDP is the total value of all the goods and services which are produced within a nation for a given period of time which could be a quarter or a year. The GDP per capita gives the income for each individual in the nation (usually for a year). If we add net factor payments, that is the difference between interest, wages, and rent which are exported and imported, we get the national income which should be attributed to Sierra Leonean productivity. The World Bank estimated this to be $210 in 2004 and $220 in 2005. This means that in 2005 each Sierra Leonean made $220 for the entire year. This is pitiful, but it is also an extremely difficult statistic to calculate unlike GDP. Per capita GDP calculated by the CIA for 2006 shows that if we consider what foreigners produced in Sierra Leone, the income-population ratio is about $900, which is still pitiful.

How can growth decrease poverty?

For the sake of brevity I will not get into factors affecting growth. What I wish to highlight though, is that growth is a necessary but not sufficient condition for poverty reduction. I will discuss this next.

If an economy is growing at an impressive average annual rate, which seems to be the case for Sierra Leone, if the rate is correct (7-8%), that means that employment should be increasing. This is because to produce output, Sierra Leoneans must be working. It is a lot easier to extrapolate this because Sierra Leone is not a capital intensive country. It is more so a labor intensive country and we cannot attribute too much to technological productivity. Here is the problem. The country can be increasing its income, but that does not mean that the income is equitably/fairly distributed. If there is a very bad distribution of national income, that will have no impact on the poverty level. The poverty situation might even get worse. This could lead to what we call Immiserizing growth (sorry you can’t find this in the dictionary. It was coined by a Columbia University Professor, Jagdish Bhagwati). This is a rare situation when growth actually causes misery.

(v) Redistributive policies and market failure

It is very important to have a mechanism to redistribute national wealth or to cater for those who are beyond the reach of the market. Those who are too sick, too old, too young, or even temporarily unemployed, are out of the job market. The government must therefore ensure that they are cared for. This could be in the form of health care, food supplies, subsidized consumption, or subsidized income. It might also be that the government will have to raise revenue through taxes to meet required social spending. A widespread adoption of some kind of social security program could also minimize the hazards of old age care when the old and infirm (those susceptible to chronic poverty) can no longer take care of themselves.

There is however a fundamental problem with equity (fairness) and growth. There has to be a principle on which the rich or better off can be taxed without compromising growth. The pay as you earn system (PAYE) seems to be a fairly progressive system. This allows the more prosperous and fortunate in society to pay more taxes than the less fortunate, so that the government can provide required social services to alleviate poverty. A caveat here is that, excessively high taxes may discourage payment (which encourages corruption) and cause a disincentive to invest for future growth of the economy. The government must then determine the optimal (best when there is constraint) level of taxation that will not compromise growth.

POVERTY AND THE EXCHANGE RATE

There is no direct relationship between poverty and the exchange rate. I am definitely not confusing inflation with the exchange rate here. It will be a fallacy, although not a fatal one, to advance a theory of such a correlation. Here is why. The exchange rate can impact growth or national income only through net exports. That is, for the exchange rate to affect poverty it must first affect net exports, which means that as a result of the exchange rate, Sierra Leone must export more than it is importing. If that happens, national income will increase. But by increasing national income we do not know if income will be equitably distributed except we are assuming trickle-down economics. Trickle down economics in Freetown is like voodoo economics (supply side economics in America)-it is hoped that because growth is taking place as a result of supply side policies, income will automatically get to the poor. We know for sure that wealth is concentrated in Sierra Leone with a Gini family distribution index of 62.9 in 1989 (CIA). This is way greater than 0 the score for perfect equality.

There are more problems. Suppose the Leone appreciates, well we do not know if foreigners are going to buy more of Sierra Leonean exports to begin with, because Sierra Leonean exports are now more expensive relative to foreign imports. It is probably more likely that Sierra Leoneans will import more, in which case neither net export nor national income is going to increase. What if the Leone depreciates? It is still not certain how foreigners are going to respond and how that will affect national income. We do know for sure that as of now devaluation has not helped the economy. The relationship between the exchange rate and poverty is far-fetched, and at best, a remote fantasy.

What can a youth organization do?

A youth organization can address the causes of poverty to see how best it can channel youthful energies to sustainable solutions. It can assess the intensity of poverty and embark on large scale fund-raising activities to satisfy limited and specific objectives. Chronic poverty is a lost case and not much could be done to remedy it, except to provide care for the weak and those who are not yet in the labor force. It will be more important to pay close attention to the able-bodied members of the labor force, without neglecting the infirm; so that they can be able to get out of poverty and stay out of poverty. This may mean helping them with tuition or start-ups in industry that could be long lasting. Organizing social network groups or partnerships with Diaspora groups for mutual support could also be helpful.

As a contribution to curriculum revision, a youth organization, in collaboration with the Education Ministry, can explore the possibilities of making institutes more responsive to global needs in the area of technology, and data processing, and encouraging US businesses to train Sierra Leoneans to be prospective employees in the outsourcing market. To that end, a youth organization can also establish scholarship funds.

A youth organization can lobby the government, with the help of non-profit organizations to enforce fundamental rights of the Sen variety i.e. rights which are linked to outcomes. It might also be helpful to explore the needs and prospects of markets in neighboring cities.

Sierra Leonean youths should be encouraged to clean the city and hospitals for income and a pioneering youth organization must establish well structured organizations to co-ordinate and monitor anti-poverty programs. Helping with civic-education and work ethic should enhance incentives to work.

Good Luck!!!

Photo: A packed Poda Poda in Freetown, Sierra Leone. Special thanks to Peter Andersen of Sierra Leone web for this wonderful photo.

About the author:Dr.Christopher Warburton is an Assistant Professor of Law & Economics at the John Jay College of Criminal Justice, USA.

Comments