Opinion
By John Lansana Musa, Freetown, Sierra Leone.
Courtesy Leonenet (UMBC)
Indeed Maada Bio commands respect among his supporters. But the lionization of Julius Maada Bio as a political giant and compared to even General Colin Powell takes the cake for exaggeration in politics in catchpenny newspapers, internet blogs and (Leonenet).
If we did not already meet the other 18 contestants in the race for Presidential Candidate at the SLPP Convention or known them for their discernment in society, we may join this parade for Maada Bio. We can only thank the SLPP delegates for this lantern parade. Let us take at look at what the delegates have wrought. Were they looking for a FLAG BEARER or PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE?
We know what a real presidential candidate inspire among delegates. But what is a FLAG BEARER?
In modern usage, the noun, Flag-bearer refers to a leader of a political party. This coinage is predominant in African politics now to refer to the Presidential Candidate. It derives from the Spanish - portaestandarte, banderado, portabandera, meaning flag bearer, flag holder, ensign bearer, colour-bearer.
In the military, it refers to the soldier who carries the standard of the unit in military parades or in battle. One may hazard a guess that it may also refer to those bearing school banners or flags at a school march past.
In truth, a Presidential Candidate on the other hand connotes the principal leader of a political party who competes for the control of the machinery of Government. He or she has political gravitas instead of the strength of one carrying a flag or banner in front of troops or a parade. A voter is more likely than not to perceive a presidential candidate more seriously than one bearing the flag or colours in front of troops.
In light of this battery of synonyms, did the SLPP delegates elect a FLAG-BEARER or a PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE? To respond to this tongue-in-cheek inquiry, we ought to look at how the contestants dovetailed in accordance with the preferences of the delegates. Based on the essential background and experience of the 19 contestants, they looked as follows:
TRADITIONAL, ORGANIC INTELLECTUALS & PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
Engineer Andrew Karmoh Keili (57 votes)
Engineer Usman Boie Kamara (186 votes)
Pediatrician Dr. Anthony Kakpindi Soyei (7 votes)
Lawyer Dr. Bu-Buakei Jabbi (1 vote)
Professor Morie Komba Manyeh (2 votes)
Lawyer Ambassador John Ernest Leigh (2 votes)
MILITARY EXPERIENCE
Major Ishmael Sengu Koroma (US Military) (1 vote)
Brigadier Julius Maada Bio (RSLAF Warrior & NPRC Coupmaker and counter-coupmaker) (238 votes)
CABINET COUPLED WITH INTELLECTUAL EXPERIENCE
Dr. Kadi Sesay (English Professor cum Cabinet Minister) (28 votes)
Momodu Koroma (Physics Lecturer cum Cabinet Minister) (12 votes)
Alpha Wurie (Chemistry Lecturer cum Cabinet Minister) (2 votes)
Emmanuel O. Grant (Legislator cum Cabinet Minister) (2 votes)
Alpha Osman Timbo (Lawyer cum Cabinet Minister) (44 votes)
LEGISLATIVE EXPERIENCE
Elizabeth Alpha Lavalie (Parliamentarian) (1 vote)
PARTY ACTIVISTS
Abu Hassan-Koroma (SLPP - USA) (1 vote)
Kadi-Palmer Johnson-Cole (SLPP - UK) (1 vote)
RANK & FILE SLPP MEMBERS
Francis Obai Kabia (International Public Sector) (9 votes)
Umaru Dumbuya (Municipal Government Service) (2 votes)
Having had this close look at the contestants, it is apparent that the delegates discounted the experience of traditional, organic and professional intellectuals although they countenanced Andrew Keili and Usman Boie Kamara, but not enough to elect them. Keili, in particular is a not only a sure-footed political and policy analyst, his experience spans a generation and three years. But three months’ military experience weighed more on the delegates’ minds than that.
More than this, the delegates frowned on the Tejan Kabbah Cabinet Ministers especially Momodu Koroma who had been a breath away from the Presidency and once faced the electorate as Vice Presidential candidate. The delegates dismissed the experience of Dr. Wurie and Emmanuel O. Grant. The delegates hugged Dr. Kadi Sesay and Alpha Timbo remarkably over their Cabinet colleagues but denied them victory. Dr. Kadi Sesay was expected to score higher than 28, but the delegates were thinking of a Flag-bearer.
Has the much touted Kabbah-Berewa legacy been consigned to the ash bin of history in the preference for Maada Bio’s tenuous stewardship over five Cabinet Ministers who hitherto superintended several Cabinet Portfolios in 11 years? Have the delegates rebated intellectual, professional experience and public service as a requirement to be the bellwether of the SLPP?
What is more, Legislative experience did not impress the delegates, nor did they take into consideration party activism of any kind from abroad or at home. Small wonder there were no delegates from North America to add muster to the election.
What then counted much on the minds of the 600 odd delegates, if men and women of mettle with swollen curriculum vitae were confounded at the ballot box by a man with accidental experience at the conjunction of a failed military regime and the advent of democratic rule?
In passing, it is worth mentioning the 39% poll Julius Maada Bio attained. A victory at 39% on a plurality rather than an absolute majority was anticipated by the SLPP rules in the 1995 constitution. Berewa attained such a simple majority and none raised his dander against him. During the contention over single ballot box or multiple boxes, he supplied a brilliant lawyer’s answer. As statesman and democrat, he was not straddling the fence, he gave an opinion that satisfied the reasonable man.
In the May 1957 SLPP Caucus, Sir Albert Michael Margai defeated Sir Milton Margai by 22 to 21 votes. Had Party adherents not prevailed on Sir Albert to stand down for Sir Milton, Sir Albert might have become the SLPP leader. Learning from that experience, the SLPP adopted the 1958 Constitution requiring a 55% majority to be elected Party Leader. That prospect has been averted in the extant Constitution of the SLPP.
Thus, if a universe of 19 contestants aspire to be the bellwether of the SLPP, the existing election rules supersede the consternation over the results. A number of questions impinge on this matter rather that the number of voters preferring the contestants.
Did the delegates wager electing a PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE, possessing what Alexander Hamilton has called ENERGY IN THE EXECUTIVE in Federalist Papers No. 70, that, “Energy in the executive is a leading character in the definition of good government. It is essential to the protection of the community against foreign attacks; it is not less essential to the steady administration of the laws; to the protection of property against those irregular and high-handed combinations which sometimes interrupt the ordinary course of justice; to the security of liberty against the enterprises and assaults of ambition, of faction, and of anarchy.”
If the delegates desired a woman or man of parts, imbued with the fervour of energy in the Executive, they overlooked that prospect when they picked Julius Maada Bio.
Were the delegates looking for a strongman, to hold and carry the SLPP flag, hence a portaestandarte, banderado, portabandera, meaning flag bearer, flag holder, possessing military manners, disposed to conduct outside the Constitution and possessing license to injure his compatriots at a whim because he possesses an assault rifle while wearing a uniform of the armed forces of the Republic?
Elections where heads are perfunctorily counted instead of weighing the political Gravitas of contestants will invariably cast a pall on many compatriots thinking of how to govern and attain a well-ordered society.
Dr. Yusuf Bangura has been severely criticized for pointing out the flaws in the delegates’ decision to choose Maada Bio based on majority rule alone as a yardstick. His views are widely shared by many critics of democracy as a mere will of the people. As Professor Josiah Ober has said:
“In modernity, democracy is often construed as being concerned, in the first instance, with a voting rule for determining the will of the majority. The power of the people is thus the authority to decide matters by majority rule. This reductive definition leaves democracy vulnerable to well-known social choice dilemmas ... If democracy as a political system is reducible to a decision mechanism based on a voting rule, and if
that voting rule is inherently flawed as a decision mechanism, then (as critics have long claimed) democracy is inherently flawed as a political system.”
The present discontent over Maada Bio’s election as Flag Bearer conjures the reductive definition of democracy which we often hear the SLPP is a champion of. We must stem the social choice of dilemmas which compel anti-democratic practices which impose the product of majority rule such as now obtains and which has soured the aspect of many inside the SLPP. The claims of UNITY inside the party are akin to a volcano rumbling inside the cauldron but has not yet erupted.
The contest for State House cannot be waged merely on the experience of the illegal occupation of State House coupled with disdain for the APC. Julius Maada Bio’s followers say with relish that he has experience as ‘Head of State’ and as a military officer. They are now attempting to convince us that Maada Bio is a creature larger than life. He is what Max Weber has long ago told us what constitutes a CHARISMATIC figure. He is neither!
The new trumpet that we have heard says Maada Bio is the mirror image of General Collin Powell. Military men have gained power lawfully at the ballot box as we saw General Dwight Eisenhower, Naval Officer John F. Kennedy, Military Officer Richard Nixon, Nuclear Naval Officer James Earl Carter, Air Force Officer George H. W. Bush in Congress and the White House. These former military men served their nation with distinction in uniform and later joined politics. Brigadier Julius Maada Bio has turned that experience upside down. Comparing Brigadier Julius Maada Bio to Five Star General Colin Powell is an anomaly.
He twice shot his way to power at State House and strutted about the corridors of Government 19 years ago. If he and his followers later claim that unlawful power as experience, our army will be inspired to seize power and win the race for flag bearer in some political party convention where they will be picked over men and women of mettle as well. Julius Maada Bio is not Colin Powell. He is indeed Julius, but not Caesar! The price for this military experience is too high for 2012 as President Koroma’s First-Ballot victory looms over Julius Maada Bio like a monsoon rain.
Photo: Julius Maada Bio.

Comments