Opinion
By Ajan Fofanah, UK.
It would be a blessing to know that all mankind are, or can be project managers, if the appropriate logistics are readily available to accomplish our projects. Carrying out some of our activities of daily living like heading a family or an institution, managing the home, or leading a country are all project management.
The only disparity in my assertion is that we all have different knowledge, skills and experience, and that some project managers are more equal than others. This is because some of them are certified, and therefore have the acumen to successfully manage a range of complex projects.
Some professionals may infer that I am being too simplistic or audacious to describe everyone as project managers, a reminder that projects are encounters which are to be accomplished within a specified period of time, may help to buttress my frank assertion, and exonerate me from any deliberate or inadvertent transgressions.
At the same time, these professionals would be appeased by recognising that they are the ones with the expertise, and are therefore better placed to successfully manage the life cycle of projects. All projects need to be initiated, according to need; carefully planned, executed or implemented; and of course evaluated, to determine whether the projects have achieved the deliverables, which will justify the essence of projects.
Mentioning the project life cycle seems effortless, but to effectively and efficiently conceptualise and successfully manage each stage of a project is the very art which creates the foundation for measuring project success.
Measuring project success can be a very thorny task, because even when the deliverables of a project are pronounced to be achieved, sometimes, they do not fully reflect our project specification. Projects also sometimes overrun their schedule and the budget that was originally anticipated.
When these parameters (Project specification, schedule and budget) are employed to measure project success, one could clearly see why many projects in Sierra Leone could be described as ‘White Elephants’, and especially the ‘Bumbuna Phase 1 Hydro-electric project’.
In the first place, the Bumbuna Phase 1 project was not well specified, not accurately timed and its cost was a complete shamble. Therefore, it did not only overrun, but caused serious financial hardship for our previous and current governments; it also failed to deliver the amount of energy that the country was deceived to expect.
If I were to reflect, many Sierra Leoneans were made to believe that the Bumbuna Phase 1 project will potentially provide energy for the whole country, with surplus to sell to other neighbouring countries. Unfortunately, it ended as an awful and complete failure; and had to be resurrected and completed by the present government.
Indeed, the wreckages and burden of the Bumbuna Phase 1 project have indisputably instilled, in both past and present generations, a syndrome of failure, denial and pessimism.
In view of some indubitable facts, there is sufficient justification to describe the past Bumbuna phase 1 project as a ‘White Elephant’ project. But is this kind of project failure only peculiar to our country? No! Yet, in the western world, many other strategic projects have failed. Although it is premature to index some of these failed projects, as that is not the essence of this piece; but, some of these western projects could also be described as ‘White Elephants’.
By their very nature, all projects are risky and prone to failure. While many reasons may contribute to this, projects usually fail or become White Elephants irrespective of where they are commissioned. This is mainly because of poor risk management approaches. However, it is developing countries that are mostly to bear the brunt of such failure, as they are often deficient of the perseverance and resources that are needed to rescue their own White Elephant projects.
Throughout Sierra Leone’s decades of long history, the need to have a sustainable energy system that will drive the country’s development has always sparked major economic, political, and social concerns. As energy reserves play a very prominent role both in terms of trade volumes and strategic or political importance, one would appreciate why the current government has decided to launch its ambitious Bumbuna Phase 2 hydro-electric project
In spite of the government’s aspiration, many Sierra Leoneans are predicting that Bumbuna Phase 2 would be another White Elephant project. While this prediction is partly fuelled by the indelible stain and shambolic experience of the previous Bumbuna Phase 1 project, some people are also of the view that the government would fail, because its ‘Agenda for Change’ has been fraught by too many projects---simultaneously managed by the government.
As opined by the skeptics, having too many concurrent projects, in the midst of competing priorities that need to be titrated with our present limited financial resources, may undoubtedly put some strain on the government and impede the success of the Bumbuna Phase 2 project. But, most importantly, having many projects is also just a clear and strong message that the government is very determined to fast-track the development of the country to another conspicuous height.
It is a shame that the Bumbuna Phase 1 project would rightly be labelled as a White Elephant. This is not only because it failed to deliver what was expected, overrun in schedule and budget. But it also lacked transparency and accountability, robust project monitoring and control mechanisms and good relationship management, which are very crucial for any successful project management.
Apparently, many Sierra Leoneans can still recall how the Bumbuna Phase 1 project changed hands from one contractor to another; how some of these contractors were reportedly engaged in dishonest operations; and how some of our own so-called citizens were aware of these illegal activities but condoned these contractors to secure and preserve their own selfish interest, rather than thinking about, and acting dispassionately for the common good of the whole country. This must never happen again, as the demand for energy has become so paramount, as a result of various activities that are indispensable to the country’s development. Also, as the global economy continues to strongly influence the survival of our various global communities.
The ever growing and more globalised economic activities, scarcities, price volatilities and conflicts all call for the proper management and regulation of our projects, especially as the need for Sierra Leone to embark on various projects has become so obvious. But how do we ensure or guarantee the success of the Bumbuna phase 2 hydro-electric project?
In the bid to prevent phase 2 from failing, all Sierra Leoneans, and the government in particular, should strive to generate substantive findings to tackle the challenges of scope creep and to strengthen our Service Level Agreements with our partners/contractors, in order to prevent the Bumbuna phase 2 project from being labelled as another White Elephant.
As a Sierra Leonean who is passionate about the development of my country, I would like to graciously suggest to the government to use, if not already used, a project monitoring and control model titled: ‘Earned Value Management System’, to facilitate the success of the Bumbuna phase 2 project.
The Earned Value Management (EVM) model was first adopted by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA), of the United States government, to manage their ballistic missile defence programme, as well as many other successful projects. It has also been used worldwide. Therefore, Earned Value Management has not only been tested, but also been proven to be the ‘gold standard’ in ensuring project success.
Earned Value Management is a monitoring and control mechanism, by which projects can improve delivery performance through periodic and meaningful cost and schedule performance information, which increases the focus and understanding of project status against schedule and budget goals, throughout the project lifecycle. In simple terms, Earned Value is the contract or authorised budget value of work accomplished on a project, typically to date.
The advantage of using EVM is that, it gives objective measures of status against the cost and schedule goals of a project. In this regard, it will definitely enable us to monitor and track the Bumbuna Phase 2 project, if and when it is creeping out of the country’s specified scope. Assuming that we follow the principles that underpin good practice in EVM systems, it will provide important data to project teams; preventing them to operate in a vacuum regarding their performance; or even worse, function in an environment of false optimism, which would not see the level of challenge or issues in our project, until it is too late to make a real impact on Bumbuna Phase 2 – a failure that often occurs in many projects around the world.
I am not in any way suggesting that Earned Value Management is risk free, as it also has its own pitfalls. Nevertheless, Earned Value will empower us to eliminate any potential risk and/or transform them into opportunity risks, which will successfully enhance the accomplishment of Bumbuna Phase 2.
Additionally, because of the bad experience of Bumbuna phase 1, it would be absolutely expedient for the country to be informed about how much Bumbuna Phase 2 will cost us; as well as how long it will take to be accomplished. Certainly, such information will not only give us a comprehensive knowledge about the project, but also the impetus to contribute to monitoring the earned value of its activities.
Such perceived involvement will provide the opportunity for all Sierra Leoneans to have a say or blow the whistle if and when there is any semblance of the Bumbuna Phase 1 White Elephant. At least, such an approach would encourage all of us to claim ownership of the Bumbuna Phase 2 project, and to irrevocably share the praise of success or the blame for any potential failure.
At this juncture, I would not only vouch for the integrity of ‘Earned Value Management’, but I also reiterate that it is the retort to project success in Sierra Leone. Therefore, I hypothesise that the Bumbuna Phase 2 hydro-electric project will never be another White Elephant, if Earned Value Management is used to monitor and control its delivery, for the ultimate benefit of Mama Salone.

Comments