Opinion
By Joseph Conteh, Freetown, Sierra Leone.
In the Africell group CEO’s own words, "the 1 million active subscribers in Sierra Leone is just a benchmark of a promising future with a mere 29% penetration rate and 55% population coverage."
For newspaper editors, journalists, investors, and segments of the general population, we tend to pay close attention to various corporate claims and boasts within Sierra Leone, particularly if they are specific to our own telecommunications sector.
A very noticeable characteristic of the Sierra Leonean market is for GSM operators to come out with figures about their market positions and their market shares which do not always compute, and often serve to confuse and obfuscate. This usually takes the form of Krio slogans in radio adverts, and “outrageous subscriber numbers” on billboards.
Generally speaking, one can normally laugh-off such claims and above statements; that is to say, if such statements were in fact, not so purposely misleading, and potentially damaging to our emerging economy and the country’s telecommunications credibility.
From a journalistic perspective, therein lies a compelling need to rationalize and authenticate such boasts and try and understand the true nature and facts involved.
Firstly, we contacted GSM authorities to better understand how GSM operators determine their market-share statistics (relative to the overall market and in consideration of its competitors own claims). Factored into this analysis is the GSM operator’s number of “valid and active ” subscribers, for which the industry has a clear definition.
Generally speaking, a valid and active subscriber is one who is termed as generating usage of the operator’s service and thus, revenue on behalf of the service. In addition, valid and active subscribers are segmented according to their usage of service, based on 30, 60, and 90 days timeframes. According to our GSM authorities, operators view subscribers who have not generated any outbound calls (revenue) over a period of 45 days or greater, are generally not considered “active“ .
In addition, our sources emphasized that GSM operator’s market-share statistics should only be compiled based on their “active” and revenue-generating subscribers, as operators in the Sierra Leone market often give subscriptions away for free and or, for a nominal charge (Le 1,000 or less), whereby the operator adds the subscriber to their customer database (and the subscriber uses the free portion of the free sim card and simply reverts to their existing operator of choice and throws the free sim card away).
When asked if this should be considered as an “active” and revenue –generating subscriber and part of the operator’s market-share calculations, our sources were emphatic in their response: “NO” ! We also raised the subject of mobile phone users in Sierra Leones who hold more than one active sim card for the purpose of enjoying some free airtime and bonuses provided by a few of our GSM operators; again, the 45 day rule applies and they should not be considered as active, revenue-generating subscribers. In fact our analysis indicates a number of these free or nominal sim cards are often thrown away after the free airtime for voice and SMS has been used.
And finally, to clarify further, we discussed one of the GSM operator’s key financial benchmarks referred to as “ARPU” , (average revenue per user). We posed the same questions regarding what is considered the industry’s view when calculating market-share, their response was straightforward: the 45 day rule applies and the subscriber must generate usage (revenue) exceeding the cost of retaining the subscriber as so called active. Plainly speaking, an active subscriber should generate revenue consistently over a 45 day period to exceed their existing costs to the operator, in order to be considered valid.
Secondly, after discussing the industry benchmarks and how they apply to GSM operators in Sierra Leone, we also analyzed our country’s most recent demographics, as a means to further rationalize and understand how one GSM operator can effectively manipulate the Sierra Leone telecommunications market by way of its market-share claims, irrespective of the facts and a resounding indifference to market value.
In short, Sierra Leone has a population of 5.1 million people, of which 52% fall between: (i) 15 or under and (ii) 64 or over, age brackets. Moreover, the urbanization factor indicates 38% of the population lives within the major cities and surrounding areas, whereas, nearly 62% live in rural settings.
Also, within the rural population, approximately 7% of that population segment lives outside mobile coverage areas. Once you integrate other key socio-economic factors into our overall market, including: daily average earnings per capita, unemployment, and illiteracy; the current and true available market for mobile phone penetration in our country ( as described by GSM sources) is significantly lower than the overall population density. More importantly, market-share claims should not be based on the overall population of Sierra Leone, but rather the true available telecommunications market as it exists in our country today. Critical to obtaining a fully transparent market-share analysis, there lies the need to underpin Africell’s percentage claims, with active and valid subscribers as defined by GSM standards, and apparent in the company’s financial disclosures.
The third step in our analysis (after examining GSM and industry benchmarks and our country’s demographics), we decided to contact NATCOM to determine if there was any validity to what Africell is claiming regarding its one million active subscribers dating back to November’09, including statements made by their group CEO. Interestingly, our sources at NATCOM raised several questions regarding the authenticity of Africell’s active subscriber claim. Their interest focused on Africell’s declared number of registered sim cards in the market. In short, their market-share claims and declared registered sim cards, appear to raise questions of credibility and authenticity as to whether their claims are based on true active and valid subscribers.
Finally, our analysis has led us to Africell. To date, we have received several comments from past and current Africell employees, questioning the validity of their company’s subscriber and market-share claims. We contacted a former Africell senior manager who simply stated : “Their version of one million subscribers is pure rubbish and their practice of embellishing market statistics, has persisted for a very long time within the company”."
They further stated that Africell has 35% of their current subscriber base generating Le 400 or less on average per month. In addition, we spoke with a manager in Africell’s commercial department who confirmed to us that their ARPU is equal or less than $ 4.00 on average per month. Clearly, the numbers began to raise more and more questions regarding the validity and true motives behind Africell’s claims.
In summarizing, given what we have been able to compile, we began to better understand the true motives behind what increasingly appears to be misleading statements and performance claims made by Africell authorities. It definitely appears that once you consider all the factors that we have examined in our discussions and analysis, including : (1) GSM market-share and financial benchmarks, (2) Sierra Leone’s demographics, (3) regulatory inputs, we would submit that Africell does not have one million valid subscribers according to industry standards, and statements to this effect, made by its group CEO, are to be viewed in context to the company’s longstanding tendency to overstate its overall performance amongst its most important stakeholders, the people of Sierra Leone, our government, and our financial institutions. Accordingly, it appears that possibly Africell’s boasts are attempts to hype their perceived market value, notwithstanding their responsibility to adhere to credible and transparent corporate governance as it would be interpreted by its own stakeholders, government oversight organizations, GSM industry best practices, and financial sector analysts.
In conclusion, we have all been subjected to another of what can only be referred to as Africell’s “ Big Lie” . Lets hope they learn from our efforts that honesty and integrity will become one of the cornerstones of our country’s developing economy and social transformation.

Comments