By Dr. Peter A. Dumbuya, USA.
Series Focus
Although UNICEF and WHO have reported that Target 7(c) of the Millennium Development Goals had been met in 2010 with two billion people gaining access to safe drinking water, much work remains to be done for the 780 million people who lack access to this precious resource. Therefore, this essay, the second in the series, focuses on the urgent need to merge the current urban and rural water supply companies, and thereby create a comprehensive national water supply policy that meets international (human rights) standards. This should be done pursuant to the government’s obligation to protect the health, safety, and welfare of the people, to promote economic development, and to maintain domestic tranquility.
Introduction
In addition to its mineral resources (diamonds, iron ore, gold, bauxite, etc.) and arable land, Sierra Leone is blessed with a 300-mile Atlantic coastline and many rivers (Rokel, Sewa, Great and Little Scarcies, Mano, etc.), big and small. However, in spite of the country’s water assets, most Sierra Leoneans lack access to safe drinking water that is treated and piped into their homes, businesses, schools, and places of employment. According to a report prepared for the government, only 22 percent of the country has access to safe water resources (15% for sanitation). The problem is even more acute in Freetown where more than one million people live with a water supply system that was built in the 1950s for a few thousand residents.
The UNICEF and WHO report cited above describes a water situation so dire that residents now pay anywhere from three to six cents per bucket of water, in a country where 70 percent of the people live on less than $1.00 a day. This situation, therefore, calls for urgent action on the part of national and local government leaders to craft a national water supply policy, and scrap the current urban-rural water policy which is a holdover from the Colony-Protectorate divide of yesteryears.
History of Missed Opportunities
It is not for a lack of water resources that the provision of safe drinking water has become a life-and-death struggle, as the recent cholera outbreak has amply demonstrated. It has to do with a lack of political leadership and commitment to invest in the country’s basic infrastructure on the one hand, and on the other, a lack of public demand to do something about it. How else can one explain a project that began in 1954 to supply safe drinking water to Freetown and its environs but still lacks institutional coherence, a plan for the provision of water and revenue collection, and a plan to deal with leakage, wastage, and theft of services. When the then Guma Water Scheme began in 1954, it was expected to hold over two million gallons of water in its reservoir. This immediately prompted the Freetown City Council to raise the water rate to help defray the £56,000-plus cost of the project. This is what the Daily Mail reported about the project on December 29, 1954 (pp. 1, 8): “Ratepayers, however, will take heart that what they are being called upon to pay for has begun to be an active proposition.” The “active proposition” the newspaper referred to was the arrival in Freetown of heavy equipment to start the reservoir phase of the project.
Since its establishment in 1961, the Guma Valley Water Company (GVWC) has not been able to fulfill its mandate to provide safe drinking water to residents in Freetown and its environs. On top of that, Parliament created a separate company, the Sierra Leone Water Company (SALWACO), in 2001 to supply water to “specified areas” in the Provinces. Both companies are overseen by the Ministry of Energy and Power (MEP).
The 2012 World Bank report (referred to in the last essay on water and sanitation) states that GVWC supplies 18 million gallons of water a day to Freetown residents when the actual demand is for 35 million gallons of water a day. The report also indicated that between 2004 and 2011, the period for which external donors funded water and sanitation projects in Sierra Leone, 25,000 people (the target was 150,000 people) were provided access to improved water sources in the Freetown urban areas, compared to 167,000 people (the target was 150,000 people) in the rural areas. In that time period, 7,500 water meters were installed in Freetown.
The law that established SALWACO in 2001 authorized it to provide “satisfactory water services at reasonable cost and on a self-sustaining basis without adversely affecting the environment” (section 13) to the following “specified areas” or cities/towns: Bo, Kenema, Koidu, Makeni, Yengema, and Lungi (section 2). Without defining what is “satisfactory,” the law empowered SALWACO to set water rates and charges in respect of premises (buildings, land, etc.), industrial and commercial establishments, schools, and hospitals (section 38). The Company’s “general water rate” on premises is based on their “assessed annual value,” whereas a “water supply charge” is applicable to “premises which are supplied water by means of a service pipe,” the installation of which the owner or occupier of the premises has to request from the Company (sections 40, 45).
These provisions of the law raise a number of issues: (1) how does the Company correlate the “assessed annual value” of premises with the amount of water their occupants utilize in any given month, assuming these are premises without water meters; and (2) for premises that are not connected by a service pipe, are their owners assessed water rates and charges, and if so, what is a reasonable water rate or charge when there is no way to measure how much water their occupants have used up? An additional issue arises in section 41 of the law wherein the Company, with the approval of the Board of Directors, can exempt certain premises from the payment of water rates and charges. This section defeats the purpose of the law which is to create a Company that provides water services to important provincial cities and towns (where 70% of the population lives) on a “self-sustaining basis.” The burden of providing safe drinking water will be borne by some, while others become free riders. The government, therefore, has to summon the fortitude to inform the people, in no uncertain terms, that water or any other services are not for free; everyone must pay for these services.
Also of concern is section 39 which states that “Section 38 shall not confer legal rights and shall not be enforceable in any court of law but the principles contained therein shall nevertheless be fundamental in the determination of the Company’s rating policy for water supply.” Similar restrictive language is found in the 1991 Constitution (section 14). To whom is this section directed? One can only surmise that it applies to owners and occupants of premises. Does section 14 comport with the UN General Assembly’s declaration that access to water is a now human right? Instead of expanding rights as a matter of constitutional practice, legislators in Sierra Leone restrict rights with the use of the word “shall,” which is mandatory, while the Company “may” (permissive) supply water to premises. Nevertheless, the law is replete with instances in which the Company or the owner/occupier of premises has recourse to the courts of law: when the owners of premises fail to pay water charges (section 43); for damage to private property (section 49); and for offenses committed under the law (sections 51-60).
Nationalizing Water and Sanitation Policy
In 2007, the government of Sierra Leone finally sought help from the UN Economic Commission for Africa (ECA) to formulate an integrated national policy on water supply and sanitation facilities (see note 2 above). The subsequent report noted that “The GOSL believes that access to good drinking water and safe sanitation facilities by its fast growing population of 5.6 million people (2001) of whom about 70% live in the rural areas is necessary to improve health, reduce poverty, increase production and set her on a path of sustainable economic growth and development” (p. 9). However, modernization of the water and sanitation services had been hampered by the lack of a coordinated approach to the problem, and by a lack of investment in basic infrastructure. According to the ECA report, only 2 percent of the country’s gross domestic product (GDP) had been spent on this critical infrastructure, which everyone now believes is the key to a better life for Sierra Leoneans.
The goal of the national water and sanitation (WATSAN) policy is to achieve full coverage of water supply (for 3.9 million people) and sanitation facilities (for 4.2 million people) by 2025. The ECA estimates a capital outlay of upwards of $200 million to achieve this laudable goal.
A long-term practical solution to the problem of poor and inadequate water supply services and unhealthy sanitation facilities is the adoption of building codes that make indoor plumbing mandatory for all premises, commercial and industrial buildings, schools and colleges, places of employment, and any other structures that are used for human occupancy in Sierra Leone. This will facilitate the assessment of rates and charges for water usage that is measured by water meters instead of the assessed annual value of premises, because there is no correlation between such assessed value and water usage by owners and occupants of buildings.
Conclusion
Every report that I have read in preparation for this and other essays has pointed to the health and socio-economic benefits a nation like ours can reap by providing safe drinking water and improved sanitation facilities for its people. In a speech in Accra in July 2009, President Barak Obama reminded his audience that “countries thrive when they invest in their people and in their infrastructure.” Sierra Leoneans have to educate themselves about these critical infrastructure issues and bring pressure to bear upon their various representatives to adopt building codes that mandate indoor plumbing and other time-tested, quality-of-life improvements at home, in the work place, and in recreational facilities. Therefore, it is worth repeating what I proposed in the previous essay, which is the establishment of a safe water-delivery system that pipes water directly into homes, businesses, industries, and schools, among others. This service should be integrated with a sewer system and coordinated nationally by GVWC and SLAWACO in tandem with the District Councils which now share responsibility with other stakeholders for the provision of water and sanitation services in the Provinces. When this is done effectively and efficiently, this headline, “Cholera Epidemic Envelops Coastal Slums in West Africa” (New York Times, August 23, 2012, p. A6), can be a thing of the past.

Comments