African News

How SLPP Lost the 2012 Elections

17 August 2011 at 01:44 | 747 views

Commentary

By Alfred Munda SamForay, USA.

This may be a post-mortem before death; or perhaps a way to look back to the future. However one looks at it, the Sierra Leone Peoples Party (SLPP) or Sierra Leone Peoples Problem, as the case may be, by selecting Brig. Gen. (Rtd.) Julius Maada Bio as its flag bearer to challenge the incumbent Ernest Bai Koroma of the All Peoples Congress (APC) for the 2012 general and presidential elections has in my view already lost the elections without any one casting a single vote.

Let me preface my comments by saying that as a person, Maada Bio is a very likable man. He is a fine young man and an affable and approachable one at that. He comes from one of the one hundred and forty nine ruling houses in Sierra Leone. He is without a doubt a very intelligent and highly focused man who came to the United Sates following his handling over power and obtained a masters degree from American University, one of the country’s finest institutions of higher learning. He is a patriot with battle scars to show for it. He is a soldier’s soldier who fought a good fight during the country’s eleven-year civil war and in his own way contributed to the peace we all now enjoy. Bio also made history both civil and military when as military head of state he peacefully handed over power to civil authorities by forcefully overthrowing his boss, junta leader and head of state, Valentine Melvin Strasser, who himself came to power by overthrowing his own boss and Commander-in-Chief, Maj. Gen. Joseph Saidu Momoh, an elected president.

And there in lies one of Gen. Bio’s dichotomies: He staged a coup – two coups, actually – to return the government to constitutional rule. That is the erroneous proverb – do evil that good may come. But as Shakespeare’s Mark Antony said in his funeral oration after the murder of the emperor and Bio’s namesake, Julius Caesar, “The evil that men do lives after them; the good is oft interred with their bones”. So it is with Julius Maada Bio, the former Officer and Gentleman who wants to be a soldier statesman. As legal luminary, John Lansana Musa points out in his recent commentary on the Sierra Leone discussion forum, Leonenet: “Indeed, Maada Bio took the OATH OF ALLEGIANCE at Benguema when he passed out as Second Lieutenant to uphold the Constitution of Sierra Leone. But alas, he betrayed the solemn Oath of Allegiance he swore to uphold as a young officer when on 29th April 1992 in the breakfast hours at Freetown, in confederacy with the Tiger and Cobra Battalions, he overthrew a constituted Government of Sierra Leone, an action he now struts and boasts about.”.

In addition to the obvious and inherent unconstitutionality of military coups in general, there is also in the case of Gen. Bio, the unsettled matter of extra-judicial killings of people deemed unfit to live by Bio and Strasser. As APC Secretary General, Victor Bockarie Foh, recently stated: “NPRC junta was involved in very serious human rights abuses, ranging from the extra judicial execution of James Bambay Kamara, Colonel Yayah Kanu and others”. But Mr. Foh is not the only inquiring mind who wants to know why former Inspector General of Police, Bambay Kamara, journalist and actor Salami Caulker, Col. Yayah Kanu and others were killed without due process of law. People at the International Criminal Court (ICC) at The Hague also want to know why Kamara and others were killed. With Muamar el-Gadhaffy of Libya and Omer Hassan al-Bashir of Sudan basically telling the ICC to mind its own business or go to Hell (where it belongs, I think), Mr. Bio is a much easier target for the semi-official criminal court of the world. While Libya and Sudan are not signatories to the ICC charter, Sierra Leone is and so by Act of Parliament, which Bio dissolved when he and Strasser took office in 1992, any head of state of Sierra Leone is legally and morally bound to answer to the court. And it is doubtful that the self-serving edict Bio issued before he left office indemnifying himself and his junta colleagues will protect him from prosecution. The decree read, in part: “No action or legal proceeding, whether civil or criminal, shall be instituted in any court or tribunal for or on account of, or in respect of any act, matter or thing done by any person or persons acting in concert or individually to assist or bring about the change in Government which took place on 29th April 1992, and accordingly, it is not lawful for any court or tribunal to take any decision or make or entertain any order or grant any remedy or relief in any such action or other legal proceeding.”.

CAN JULIUS MAADA BIO DEFEAT ERNEST BAI KOROMA?

I may have already answered this question in my opening paragraph but I will be much obliged if you indulge me further. For beyond the legalities or illegalities of Mr. Bio’s past life as a general, the real question for him and the party he represents is what is the point of this campaign? Contrary to the APC scribe, Victor Foh’s brotherly (or not so brotherly) advice to Mr. Bio and the SLPP, I don’t think they will resist the temptation to give Bai Koroma another five-year term of office. The trouble with being head of state as early in life as Mr. Bio did is that there is not much else in life to do afterwards, especially, when nobody elected you to office, in the first place. Of course, Bio will not win if he does not run. But what happens when he does run?

In the 2012 elections, I propose that all Bai Koroma has to do is win 80 percent of the North, 60 percent of the West, 50 percent of the East and 40 percent of the South and by my own calculations, he will get 65 percent of the national vote and avoid the need for a run-off as was the case in the 2008 elections. How APC will do that is left to the brains at the party’s national and regional secretariats. This projection is not without due regards to the East where Bio lives and does business, or the South from where he originates. Nor am I in the least ignoring a possible coalition between Bio’s SLPP and Charles Margai’s Peoples Movement for Democratic Change (PMDC) presently disaffected by its short-lived marital bliss to the ruling All People’s Congress. But with a well entrenched Bai Koroma in the goal, to use a football analogy, grounded by the power of incumbency and backed by a well heeled line of APC defenders, Maada Bio is going to look like a one-legged striker in a penalty kicking contest.

For his part, Bai Koroma is a gentleman, not a brawler. Despite his large physique, he is the least bit intimidating in person and is not easily provoked. His smile and even his manner of dressing are disarming to his opponents. Most of all, no one can call him lazy or disengaged. Unlike his predecessor at State House, Koroma has never really left Sierra Leone; he grew up there, went to school there and as such it is not easy to pull a wool over his eyes when it comes to political shenanigans. As they say in America, he has been there, done it and has tee-shirts to prove it. But like Barrack Obama of the United States, Mr. Bio has never really done any thing of national significance other than becoming head of state. So SLPP will have to figure out how to engage Bai Koroma and convince the people of Sierra Leone that a young man who has never even been elected Paramount Chief or any other office is a better choice to lead the nation than the one they already have. Even the Americans are now finding out that youthful exuberance does have its drawbacks even as they struggle to maintain their leadership in a tumultuous world with an inexperienced presidency.

HISTORY IS NOT ON BIO’S SIDE

There is also a historical reason why SLPP lost the 2012 elections. Setting aside whatever happened in 1957 and 1962 to antiquities, the party has never won an election without its perennial whipping boy, Sam Hinga Norman of blessed memory. In the absence of Norman, there is simply not enough testicular fortitude in the grand old party to go toe to toe with the APC. When Bio’s predecessor as Leader of the SLPP, Ahmad Tejan Kabbah, in his infinite wisdom – or lack thereof – took upon himself to defy the national consensus and the advice of his own cabinet, not to mention common sense, to handover his most ardent defender, Hinga Norman, to the UN-backed special court for Sierra Leone, Kabbah not only signed a death warrant for Norman, he also signed the political death warrant for the SLPP. For by arresting, torturing and eventually killing Hinga Norman, the special court rather than avenging the South-East which bore the brunt of the civil war, actually engineered the transfer of power from the Sewa River region to the north of the Mabang River region of the country. As such, it is very doubtful that Mr. Kabbah will live to see power returned to the South-East. To put it more bluntly, if SLPP could not win the general elections in 2007 when they printed and counted the ballots, how are they going to win it in 2012 when someone else prints and counts the ballots?

THE FUTURE IS ON BIO’S SIDE – I THINK

If history is not on his side, Mr. Bio can perhaps count on his age as an advantage. The next, next general elections in 2017 are only six years away and at fifty three years of age, Bio will still be a relatively young man for presidential purposes. Then perhaps, he will be matched against someone closer to his age, Alhaji Sam Sumana, if APC sticks with its incumbent vice president. Even in 2027, when he is sixty-three years of age, Bio can still be a viable contender for president. The people living then would have long forgotten the sins of the NPRC or the SLPP. Although legally speaking, there is no statute of limitations for murder, it is doubtful that twenty years or so from now any one will be highly interested in what Bio and his colleagues did as young military officers in one of Sierra Leone’s tumultuous moments, and in time, all the aforementioned hindrances will have faded into history, perhaps. In any case, by then Bio would have become a veteran contender like John Karefa-Smart or Namdi Azikwe of Nigeria.

I WISH PAPA BIO AND MAMA SALONE WELL

If the purpose of selecting Mr. Bio as the flag bearer for the opposition SLPP is to ensure that Bai Koroma is not returned unopposed to State House thereby supplanting our nascent democracy, then this is very good for God’s Favourite Country, Sierra Leone, . If Bio’s presence in the 2012 race ensures a peaceful and civil transfer of power or re-election of President Ernest Bai Koroma, we will all be the better for that. In which case, we can be sure as Abraham Lincoln said that “the government of the people, by the people and of the people shall not perish from the earth”. Or in the words of the Sierra Leone national Anthem, “That blessing and peace may descend on us all.” As I stated in my opening statement, I have no quarrels with Mr. Bio and I applaud his conversion from junta leader to a full fledged democrat. I wish him and Mama Salone well.

Comments