Salone News

Dr. Abdulai Conteh Addresses Sierra Leoneans in Maryland

11 July 2013 at 21:48 | 3592 views

Institutional Challenges in Sierra Leone: The Role of The Political Class; the Judiciary; the military and Police; the Educational System; and Religious Leaders. A Need for Constitutional Reform?

Being keynote Address delivered by A.O Conteh, formerly, 1st Vice President; Attorney –General; and Minister of Foreign Affairs of Sierra Leone, and Chief Justice of Belize; and currently, Justice of Appeal in The Commonwealth of The Bahamas and Cayman Islands, at the Reunion of the Old Kolenten Students Association (OKSA), at the Radisson Hotel, 9100 Basil Court, Largo, Maryland, USA, on 5th July, 2013.

Salutations!!!

There is some inexplicable phenomenon abroad both in Sierra Leone and in the Diaspora, since April, 1992, the year immediately following the coming into effect of the present 1991 National Constitution.

This phenomenon is the urge of successive regimes, whether military or civilian, to change, replace or reform the national Constitution. Some attempts in the past even went so far as to produce, albeit, in draft, what could have been its replacement.

The current national Constitution is itself the product of historical necessity. It marked the first time when, after nation-wide consultations, and a national referendum, the people of Sierra Leone for the first time, voted themselves a national instrument that is supposed to delineate the powers, functions and role of the various organs and institutions for the governance of the country.

The historical raison d’être of the Constitution was that it resoundingly marked a break with the then 1978 Constitution which had introduced the political monolith and stultifying system of one-political party governance in the country. The new 1991 national Constitution, it is hoped, has buried for eternity the one-political party system. This system, it may be recalled, had become like in most of Africa and beyond, fashionable. But its undoubted unedifying aspects later made it plainly out of fashion and simply unappetizing.

Mark you, it must be said that, perhaps unlike in most other countries where the one-political party system prevailed, in Sierra Leone, it was in most electoral constituencies up and down the country, more a system of plural candidates under the umbrella of a single political party.

The system however, could not prevail forever as it was intrinsically unfulfilling to most Sierra Leoneans. The wonder still is how, for a relatively, politically mature and sophisticated polity that we had in the country, Sierra Leoneans sleep-walked counter- intuitively into a system that was anti-historical in the country’s socio political heritage.

There were, of course, many practical factors on the ground that made this possible. Some contended that it was an antidote to the regionally and tribally divisive drift of party politics. No doubt, political scientists and historians will theorize about these for a long time to come.

But significantly, to the abiding credit of Sierra Leoneans, they peacefully voted in a national referendum to revert back to the multi-party system of governance that had been the legal and socio-political legacy and tradition of the country even before independence and for some years thereafter.

However, given the recent experiences of the country under the new multi-party dispensation, are we, as a people, condemned forever at election time, to be more loyal to the tribe or area that we happen to come from?

This is the one and extremely important political challenge facing the country: How to forge alliances across regional, ethnic and other divisive forces, including religion, so as to present a cohesive national platform for electoral purposes under the new dispensation.

In my view, so much rides on this. Can we individually and collectively rise up to it? I believe we can and should.

The present national Constitution came into effect on 1st October, 1991.

The fact that it has survived to this day, despite the horrific ravages wreaked on the country by two successive illegal military regimes and the incomprehensible and woefully destructive criminal enterprise that is, in some charitable quarters, referred to as Foday Sankoh’s or the RUF war, is no doubt some testimony to the vigour, relevance and enduring quality of the national Constitution.

Let me add here in parenthesis before I move on: when the dust finally settles on that painful era in our country’s life, the so-called “civil war” will be seen for what it truly was: no more, no less than a criminal enterprise foisted on the innocent and unsuspecting people by a rag-tag band of desperadoes who had no meaningful political or ideological motivation other than to spread death, destruction and pillage, and amputation of limbs over the country. Let us hope and pray that they and their ilk have been consigned to the trash bin of history for all time.

Let it be said, and loudly, and clearly that none of the vicissitudes, misfortune, and in some cases, plain bad governance that have blighted the progress and welfare of the country, has anything to do with its national Constitutions.

And remarkably, the country has had, in some half a century, since its independence, a spate of national Constitutions: some four in total: 1961, 1971, 1978 and 1991.

The present 1991 Constitution could be said to be the first truly autochthonous instrument that the people themselves ordained in free and nation-wide referendum as the basis for the governance of the country.

But it is truly remarkable to have, in a space of some 40 years, four national instruments that are supposed to provide for the governance of any country!

There must be something unsettling and disturbing in this, given the nature, purport and function of a country’s national Constitution.

A national Constitution is of course, not the Law of the Medes and Persians, set immutable in stone for all times. And I should make it clear that I am far from saying that our present Constitution does not need tweaking in places or reform at all. It is after all, a human product and cannot be perfect for all times.

That paragon and, perhaps, arguably the progenitor of nearly all modern written Constitutions, the Constitution of the United States of America, was promulgated by ratification on 17th September 1787, some eleven years after the Declaration of Independence in 1776.

But the first ten amendments were only ratified on 15th December, 1791. These form together what is collectively called the Bill of Rights. These today are proudly and popularly referred to as the American Magna Carta. It is undeniable that the American Bill of Rights, in so far as it provides for fundamental human rights and freedoms of the individual, has provided the touchstone of many modern Constitutions, including, I dare say, the present national Constitution of Sierra Leone.

What is worthy of note is that since its promulgation in 1787, over some two hundred and twenty years ago, there has been no serious talk or call for its wholesale replacement or substitution by another Constitution.

Instead, up to 1992, some two hundred and five years since its promulgation there have been only twenty-seven amendments.

What then is the reason for the talk or call for the reform or replacement of the nation’s present Constitution?

Is the cause or reason for some of the undeniably bad and poor governance of our country since independence attributable to our national constitution?

I will say and, say so resoundingly “No!”

The fault is not, and has never been, with any of the national Constitutions we have had, including the aberrant one-party Constitution of 1987 to 1991.

That Constitution was, in so far as party-political dispensation was concerned, an undoubted, albeit, fashionable aberration. But decidedly, any empirical study and analysis of the prevalent situation then would show that that Constitution was made possible by the failure of certain key institutions in the country.

These institutions included the Political Class, the Judiciary and the Legal profession, the Police and the Military and to some extent, the educational establishment and the religious leadership in the country.

The role played by some of these institutions, although not in equal measure, even today, cannot be exempted as contributories to the failures, setbacks, and challenges that have bedeviled the country since independence.

I make bold to say that the role and contribution of the political class in the country to the national debacle since independence, cannot be over-emphasized.

This class is not only the usual suspect but must in my view be held to be the prime culprit.

From the political class is recruited the political elites that have for most of the period since independence governed the country.

The stability, development and progress of any country is necessarily linked to the vision, commitment, maturity, and integrity of its political class. And by “maturity”, I don’t simply mean age. It is an amalgam of life’s experiences, judgment and balance.

The more feeble, unimaginative, immature and unresponsive to the aspirations and circumstances of the people the political class is, the greater the chances that a country will be singularly challenged in its quest for stability and progress.

I speak from personal experience and insight as I once had the privilege to occupy the upper echelons of the political class.

In my time, undoubtedly mistakes and missteps were made in the governance of the country. Let there be no mistake or doubt about this.

But one salutary lesson mistakes can teach is not to repeat them, again; and it is for the political class to learn those lessons and not to repeat the mistakes of the past and then move forward.

But it seems that one abiding affliction of the class is collective amnesia, with a resultant inability to learn from past mistakes and missteps.

Otherwise who would have thought that the spate of allegations and stories of corruption rife in the country would make their appearance so soon after the cataclysms of the recent bloody and destructive history of the country; or of stories of malfeasance and misfeasance involving abuse of office said to be rampant in the country; or even of whispers that are audible in some quarters to have the current president of the country, against all the odds and the national Constitution, go for yet a third term, when his constitutionally mandated second term comes to an end?

Who can forget the cacophony of sycophancy that nearly derailed late president Stevens’ attempts to step down voluntarily from office? The sight and sound of “loyal” delegations from some parts of the country to persuade him to still stay on are eerily reminiscent of recent reports of plans to have President Koroma “detained” in State House until he abjures plans to abide by the Constitution with respect to his retirement.

Sometimes, the leadership of the political class is seduced by the blandishments of its followers into committing serious mistakes in the governance of the country.

A singular example that comes to mind was the succession to the late President Stevens. Instead of following the provisions of the national Constitution and the party’s constitution, the succession was state-managed and manipulated to have the head of the military ascend to the leadership of the party and the presidency, all of this to the accompanying chorus of sycophantic refrain of the followers, made memorable in the words of the ditty by the late Dr. Orloh: “Who dat gee Momoh Power? Na God.”

This was part of the orchestration of how the affable and harmless professional head of the military was transformed into the Head of State in an all civilian government!

A lesson to be learnt from that episode is that the retiring president and leader of a political party should not try to manipulate his succession or predetermine his successor in a truly democratic party and country. This is a task best left to the followers to determine. The example of former president Kabbah, who deigned to anoint who his successor should be, and the consequences of that choice for his political party, are a salutary reminder.

It can only therefore be hoped that some valuable lessons have been learnt, so that when President Koroma retires in 2017, as he must, the mistakes of the past would not be repeated with regards to his successor or succession.

The role of the leadership of the political class is to consult and listen to its followers, but when the time comes to make critical choices or decisions, it is the responsibility of leadership to lead. That is the challenge and measure of leadership.

Much is always expected of the political class, particularly its leadership. This is as it should be. For it is to this class that governance of the country is entrusted.

This should be seen as a trust with all the accompanying fiduciary obligations and accountability of a trusteeship.

An institution which became a kind of Valhalla for the elite of the political class was, and still is Parliament. It was however, in the case of Sierra Leone, the unquenchable ambition for members of the political class to arrive at this Valhalla, while they were still alive on earth. The reason for this was plain and obvious, because it was from the ranks of those fortunate enough to arrive in this place, Parliament, by any means possible, that the super elites of the political class were drawn. From independence up until the advent of the 1991 Constitution, Cabinet Ministers and other ministers were drawn exclusively from among Members of Parliament (MPs).

This, I venture to posit was the reason that violence became such a distressing and destabilizing feature of elections in the country.

People became prepared and were prone to do anything it would take to secure a seat in Parliament at elections.

The alluring prize was a Cabinet portfolio with all the perquisites or sweets of office that were supposed to go with that prize.

This necessarily put a crimp on our political process and development: thus the ablest and brightest, but without a stomach for the physical political thuggery that became part and parcel of political contest, were inevitably kept out or chose to stay away from the fray.

One of the distinctive features of the 1991 Constitution however, is that for the first time, a seat in Parliament does not now translate into a seat in the Cabinet or other ministerial appointment.

In fact, the thrust of the new dispensation was that Members of Parliament were meant and intended to be kept away from ministerial appointment. See Section 56 of the Constitution.

Instead, Cabinet Ministers were now to be drawn from outside of parliament. This, it was hoped, would open a wider field of choice of talent, ability and integrity, to the president in appointing his ministers.

But although the choice of candidate for ministerial office was left to the President, the validation and confirmation of that choice was ultimately left to Parliament.

This, it was thought, would lead to an improvement in the quality, ability, commitment and integrity of our Cabinet Ministers, the cream of our political class.

How has this worked in practice? It seems it is still a challenge to understand the rationale and spirit behind these provisions of the Constitution, when we still continue to see MPs now and again, nominated by the president from Parliament, for appointment as ministers.

However, a legitimate question would be: Has the overall quality of our ministers since the advent and operation of the 1991 Constitution been improved markedly or at all?

The jury may still be out on this question.

But whatever the verdict, it must not and cannot now lie at the feet of the President who can only nominate potential appointees.

The fault, if there is found to be deficit in the quality of ministers and other public officers, whose appointment must now be confirmed by Parliament, can now properly only be that of Parliament and not of the President. He only nominates, it is Parliament that approves the nominations.

If Parliament is aware of the central role assigned to it in the governance of the country in the present Constitution and rises up to its responsibilities, much of the malfeasance in the public life of the country we hear so much about, will be held in check and the perpetrators held accountable.

The question must therefore be asked: Are Members of Parliament aware of their role and function to ensure good and accountable governance in the country?

At the risk of committing lese-majesty, and I intend none and mean no offence, I would earnestly commend each Member of Parliament to read the various provisions of the Constitution relating to their functions, powers and privileges. They will find the central place assigned to Parliament in the scheme of this Constitution; and they will realise that, regardless of who occupies State House, the governance of the country can only properly be carried out in concert with them. And that they have a critical role in the process of governance.

Do Members of Parliament realise that they can veto a Presidential nomination for ministerial or other high public office if they think that the nominee is unsuitable? If so, how else can one explain the reemergence or re-cycling of a former discredited or sacked minister being re-nominated a short while after his removal, only to be confirmed for another ministerial portfolio? There is some disconnect here that is not easily explained. Some critics have ascribed this to what they call “the stuffed envelope syndrome” which it is said, every nominee for confirmation by Parliament must bring along!

Who knows?

Do Members of Parliament know that without their consent or approval no loan can be raised or contracted by the government? If so, do they ensure that only proper loans for clearly defined national projects and objectives are raised? (See section 118 of the Constitution).

Do Members of Parliament know that they can even override a Presidential Veto on any Bill they have passed and make that Bill into law? If so, why the paucity or lack of non- government- initiated legislation on important issues meant to improve public life, including the environment and urban planning? (See section 106, sub-sections (7) and (8) of the Constitution).

Do Members of Parliament know that the life of Parliament is now fixed by law? The Constitution now provides in section 85 that the life of Parliament is five years commencing from its first sitting after a general election. Gone are the days when the life of Parliament was dependent on the whim and caprice of the president. The president can no longer now dissolve Parliament at will. Why then the pusillanimity and the absence or lack of vigor in parliamentary debates holding the Executive more accountable?

It is perplexing to see and hear of Honourable Members of Parliament now being given number tags denoting the constituencies they represent. The honourable tradition and practice of proceedings in Parliament had always been to refer to each Member of Parliament by the geographic designation of his/her constituency. It must sound odd to refer to the Honourable member for Constituency zero or Constituency 14 or whatever the electoral number of his/her Constituency may be.

It should be remembered that the Constitution provides in Section 38 for the demarcation of electoral Constituencies in the country. This must be done with consideration of among other things, population quota, means of communications, geographical factors, density of population, the distribution of different communities, the areas and boundaries of chiefdoms and other administrative or traditional areas. It must be admitted that, giving a numeric tag to denominate the several electoral Constituencies in the country is not quite in keeping with the traditions of the proceedings in Parliament and is at best confusing to say the least.

It must be said that the present demarcation and numeric designation of Constituencies in the country seemed not to be in keeping with the convenience of the local people concerned and in some cases in plain disregard of geographic considerations.

Executive Presidency?

The separation of the Executive (that is, the president and his ministers) from Parliament (the Legislature), which is now a pronounced feature of the present Constitution, was meant to secure a true partnership between these two vital arms of government, so that that partnership will redound to the good and accountable governance of the country.

What has happened, in practice, however, is the over- whelming and, even overweening influence, and often unseen, presence of the presidency in every sphere of the nation’s life and governance which has been allowed to take centre stage.

The Presidency is perhaps the most mythologized office in the country’s governance. Many a power is supposedly ascribed to this office today that is difficult to find validation in the Constitution. This is to such an extent that the office and its occupant are popularly referred to as Executive President or Presidency. It is manifest that often times; the office of the president is taken in vain and sometimes used simply to browbeat someone.

There is one enduring fallacy in our national political and public discourse concerning the president, and, it is this: We all talk about an Executive President. But quite who or what this refers to or means is often not clear.

The office of the President is itself established by Section 40 of the Constitution; and in sub-section (1) it is stated:

“There shall be a President of the Republic of Sierra Leone who shall be Head of State, the supreme executive authority of the Republic and the Commander in Chief of the Armed Forces.”

But quite what “the supreme executive authority” is, is nowhere defined or stated. However, Section 53 of the Constitution in Part II of Chapter V dealing with Executive Powers states:

“Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the executive powers in Sierra Leone shall vest in the President and may be exercised by him directly or through members of the Cabinet, Ministers, Deputy Ministers or Public Officers subordinate to him.”

What is therefore manifest from this and also discernible from several other provisions of the Constitution, is that what we do have or should have in Sierra Leone today is a Presidency subject to the provisions of the Constitution.

Therefore the President, even with executive power and all, whatever that may mean, is NOT ABOVE THE CONSTITUTION; rather he is expressly subject to the Constitution.

The President is president after all, by the grace of God and dint of the law and the Constitution.

Perhaps, the good fortune of the country is to have a president who recognizes the limitations of the office within the bounds of the law and the Constitution.

The governance of the country is not, however, wholly and solely the responsibility of the president alone.

The office is without question, one of veneration and honour; and if its occupant sets the pace, tone and example, he can, together with the advice, cooperation and consent of Parliament, provide the leadership that will enable the country to realize it’s potential for growth and development amid its abundant resources, both human and natural.

The Role and Contribution of the Judiciary.

I have used a broad brush to describe this class to include all the judges, magistrates and members of the legal profession in active practice at the Bar.

What is easily and often forgotten, but in my view, should always be remembered by all and sundry, including the political class, is that in so far as the judiciary is concerned as a group, it is the Rule of Law which has and should always have the first claim on its loyalty and obedience.

This is the essence of the oath which every judge, from the lowly magistrate to the Chief Justice herself subscribed to before embarking on her functions as a judge.

The Judicial Oath is to be found in the Third Schedule to the 1991 Constitution and it may be worth reminding ourselves of its words. It is in the following terms:

“I Jane Doe do hereby (in the name of God swear) or (solemnly affirm) that I will faithfully and truly discharge the duties of the office of the Chief Justice, Judge or magistrate) and that I will support and uphold the Constitution of Sierra Leone as by law established, and that I will do right to all manner of people after the laws and usages of Sierra Leone without fear or favour, affection or ill will (so help me God).”

In my view a legitimate and abiding question is: How many of our judicial officers remember or recall these words the day after they were sworn into office, or try to discharge their duties always in accordance with their oath?

Your guess is as good as mine.

This is not, however, to say that all our judicial officers become oblivious of their oath or carry out their duties unmindful of the import of that oath. We must therefore salute those brave and worthy hearts who strive to be faithful to their oath, even in the midst of trying circumstances.

But the undeniable fact is that there is present in the country and for quite some time even before now, an audible groundswell of dissatisfaction with the administration of justice in the country.

I suspect that there is abroad in the country as well, a proper lack of understanding or appreciation of the role and contribution that the judiciary can and is expected to make towards good governance.

Properly understood and applied the role of the judiciary is that of the protector and last bastion of all over freedoms and liberties, including of course, our personal liberty, the sanctity of property and our contracts and our very lives.

But for too long the judiciary has been perceived as an appendage of the Executive and that it is simply there to do the bidding of the political class. Sometimes, members of the judiciary themselves contribute to this regrettable and unfortunate perception by the way they hobnob and carry on with the political class.

This is the greatest misconception abroad in Sierra Leone in terms of the administration of justice.

But on the contrary, the judiciary is intended to be separate and independent of every other authority in the country.

This is encapsulated in the phrase, the independence of the judiciary.

This independence is now amply provided for in the country’s Constitution so as to ensure that the judiciary is a central and impartial pillar in the good governance of the country.

It is therefore a matter of surprise and disappointment when a sitting Chief Justice or any Judge for that matter, can be ordered by the Executive to proceed on leave, prior to retirement.

This was a discredited device used in the unlamented past to cow the judiciary or get rid of some of its inconvenient members. It was therefore disappointing to see it being utilized again even after the advent and operation of the 1991 Constitution, both by former President Kabbah, and not too long ago, by President Koroma himself.

There are clear and simple provisions in the Constitution and other laws regarding the tenure and leave entitlement of judges; or how to impeach, if necessary, an errant judge.

But the spectacle of a letter from State House sending a judge on “leave prior to retirement,” can only reinforce the unattractive image that judges are expected to be the lions underneath the throne of power, to do their Master’s bidding.

I venture to say without any apology that it is only through an independent, impartial and competent judiciary that the peace, stability and progress of the country can be assured.

The independence of the judiciary is not for the personal benefit or aggrandizement of the judges. It is to ensure that they faithfully, competently, impartially and fearlessly administer justice in accordance with the Rule of Law.

The Rule of Law ensures that no man/woman is above the law and all are equal before it.

In our host country here in the United States, the contributions of the Supreme Court in extending the frontiers of freedom and protection of the law for all are, of course, legendary and are now taken almost for granted.

This is a tradition that goes back to the seminal case of Marbury v. Madison (5 US 137(1803)); a landmark case in which the US Supreme Court laid down the basis of the exercise of judicial review. The case helped to define the boundaries between the constitutionally separate Executive and the judicial branches of government.

This distinction and the separation between these two branches of government are reflected in the several provisions of our own 1991 Constitution.

Judicial Review is the process by which a citizen aggrieved by some public action by a public officer can go to court to challenge that action for some redress.

Sadly, even amidst the welter of swirling stories and allegations of public misdeeds of high-handedness or maladministration, very little, if anything, is heard, even in professional circles, of judicial review or recourse to it for the courts to pronounce on the propriety or otherwise of some administrative or public action.

Section 127 of the constitution if deployed properly can be a powerful safeguard not only for the individual, but especially in assuring good governance. It provided in material parts as follows:-

“127 (1) A person who alleges that an enactment or anything contained in or done under the authority of that or any other enactment is inconsistent with or is in contravention of a provision of this constitution, may at anytime bring an action in the Supreme Court for a declaration to that effect.”

Failure to obey or carry out the terms of an order or direction made as a result of any action under this section is, for the first time, made a criminal offence under the Constitution.

A little while back, the Sierra Leone Association of Journalists (SLAJ) sought to challenge the propriety of some provisions of the Public Order Act 1965, in relation to freedom of speech and press. They were however non-suited by the Chief Justice principally, I believe, because of their lack of standing and the provisions of the Constitution which they had sought the court to pronounce upon. Regrettably, the claimants’ lawyers, somehow inexplicably, overlooked Section 127. In my view, if their case was predicated on this section, they might have been on firmer grounds. I suppose this is a case that will wait another day….for another try.

Again, an area where an independent and competent judiciary can come to the national rescue in the face of swirling stories and allegations of public defalcation and other misdeeds, especially as they impact the ordinary citizen, and the national treasury, would be if proceedings, either civil or criminal, for the tort or crime of misfeasance in public office were instituted against perceived malefactors.

Regrettably, very little is heard of this, even in professional circles. But yet we hear so many stories of public corruption and other misfeasance of official high-handedness.

I venture to posit that criminal prosecutions for the offence of misfeasance in public office and/or civil claims for the tort of misfeasance in public office, will, if deployed and handled properly, go a long way to abate instances of alleged misdeeds in public office.

In the face of these legal mechanisms, one may very well query the need and utility of the Anti-Corruption Act and its Commission: A successful prosecution for the offence of misfeasance in public office almost invariably will result in restitution; whereas fines are the penalty of choice under the anti-corruption legislation.

It is undeniable that the judiciary had for long been regarded as the Cinderella of the three branches of government. It has not always rated high in public spending and allocation of resources or esteem for that matter.

This resulted in a demoralized and enervated judiciary some of whose members were said to be prone to be on the take.

This is a regrettable state of affairs and does not conduce to an independent, impartial, fearless and competent judiciary.

It is always a challenge to have, maintain and keep an independent judiciary. But it is a goal worthy to strive for at all costs. The empirical evidence shows that a reliable and functioning Judiciary is part and parcel of the success stories of other countries.

At the end of the day, however the independence of the judiciary is itself only asserted, assured and maintained by the judges themselves, with the pro-active support of the Bar and the public.

Starting courts’ sittings on time, the timely disposition of cases, including handing down reasoned judgments on time are attributes of an independent judiciary, which can only be done by the judges themselves.

The professional body, in this case, the Sierra Leone Bar Association, should always be in the vanguard to assert and insist on the independence of the judiciary. Do we have this in Sierra Leone?

The Role of the Military and the Police

The twin pillars of law and order and public safety, the Police and the Military have not, in the recent past exactly covered themselves in glory.

Soon after independence, they became politicized and their allegiance to the safety of the state and the protection of its citizens became subverted and alienated and appropriated by the political class.

Needless to say, the spectacle of military government is an abnegation of what all good governance is about. But since independence, the country has had its fair share of this unmitigated disaster under various vainglorious acronyms: starting with the NRC,(National Reformation Council, 1967-1968); then the NPRC (National Provisional Ruling Council, 1992-1996); and latterly the AFRC (Armed Forces Ruling Council, 1997-1998)

It is hoped that the recent sordid past with the military and “sobels” (soldier-rebels) and the police in charge of the government of the country will, however, never ever be repeated again!

The need for a well trained and professional army and police cannot be doubted, if it ever was.

But requirements that the army and police should always be under and accountable to the civil authorities; and to ensure a professional and disciplined cadre of men and women, with loyalty only to the institutions of the state and not to anyone individual or group have been a continuing challenge.

In fact in the dark days of One Party governance both the heads of the Army and the Police were incongruously co-opted as fully fledged cabinet members.

These two institutions of internal peace and the protection of the national borders must and should be depoliticized for the sake of good governance. They should never again be used, or allow themselves to be used, as tools by the political class.

It was in order to achieve this objective that ample provisions were placed in the 1991 Constitution regarding the establishment, operational control, command and deployment of these two institutions, and the creation of both a Police Council and the Defence Council: See Part II of Chapter X and Chapter XI of the Constitution.

An important office established for the first time in the interest of the proper conduct of the public affairs of the country overall, was that of the Ombudsman established in Chapter VII section 146 of the 1991 Constitution.

This office and its detailed operation and functions were later fleshed out in a substantive Act of Parliament.

Regrettably, the first appointee to this office did not do much to enhance its stature, operation and functions. In fact he had to leave office under a cloud.

It is therefore heartening to see his replacement in the person of a former judge and Speaker of Parliament.

He is now by all accounts, some of which I personally witnessed, trying to enhance the position and function of the office, including setting up regional branches of the office. If this institution of the Ombudsman is properly utilized and its role appreciated, it will provide an antidote to some of the maladministration said to be prevalent in the country. Above all, it would provide an easily accessible avenue to the ordinary person to ventilate and secure some redress as a victim of that maladministration.

The Role and Contributions of Educational and Religious Establishments.

I can only be brief on the role and contributions of the educational and religious establishment to the challenges facing the country.

One area of our national life that has, since independence, seen exponential growth is education. From primary, secondary to tertiary levels of learning. This is despite the challenges that have beset the country.

This is in keeping with the tradition that made Sierra Leone to be regarded at one time as The Athens of West Africa.

But a lot has happened since. There is now a generally perceived falling of standards, to the lament and despair of everyone.

This depreciation in standards may have some connection with the problems we have had to confront.

This explains why in Chapter one of the 1991 Constitution, on the Fundamental Principles of State Policy there is in Section 9, provisions on Educational Objectives.

There has also been an explosion in the establishment of religious houses in the country. But there has however, been no discernible improvement or noticeable uplifting in the behaviour of the people generally.

There can be no doubt that between the educational establishment and the religious groups proliferating in the country, they can, with proper instruction and guidance, exhort and strengthen us all to meet the challenges ahead as a country.

The question is: are they doing this, or is it only lip service?

Conclusion.

It is evident that our national Constitution is not part of the myriad challenges we have had to confront as a country. Most of these are caused by behavioural and attitudinal disposition.

But the Constitution can provide the space within which we carry on our personal lives and conduct the public affairs of the country

This is why the calls to change, reform or replace it should be welcome. But we must do so deliberately and cautiously, and change or replace it if we must.

We should, however, never forget that the Constitution is the primary and supreme instrument not only of governance, but also of the laws in the country.

We should also realise that any shortcomings in the conduct of our public life are not because of the Constitution, but rather because of the people who are charged with the conduct and operation of the system.

Let me conclude by sharing with you as an unrepentant constitutionalist, what, in my view, is the jewel in the Crown of our Constitution. This is tucked away in sub-section (15) of section 171 of the Constitution. This proclaims as follows:

“ (15)This Constitution shall be the supreme law of Sierra Leone and any other law found to be inconsistent with any provision of this Constitution shall, to the extent of the inconsistency, be void and of no effect”

This magisterially proclaims the supremacy of the Constitution and posits that we are governed by and under the Constitution. This as it should be, if we are to be a republic governed by laws and not by men or women for that matter.

Photo, left to right: Ms Dontrice Hamilton(panelist at subsequent panel discussion after Dr. Conteh’s address), Ms Yolanda Thompson (panelist), Ms. Fatmata Barrie (panelist), Mr. Abu Bakarr Kaloko (Chairman of event), Dr. Abdulai Conteh, Mr. Almami Cyllah and Dr. Sheik Umarr Kamarah (Chairman of panel discussion).

Comments