FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Philadelphia, PA, USA
J
uly 5, 2009
Contact:
Anthony Abdul Karim Kamara, Jnr.
Public & Media Relations
Email: tony-kamara@gmx.us
Instructive Memo to Mission of DENI-SL Consultants and Consultants’ S.O.P
In an effort to deliver a cohesive message and to enable the DENI-SL team of consultants to work cooperatively and in the interest of and for the people of Sierra Leone, the Technical Director of DENI-SL, has issued the consultants with a memorandum sketching out the landscape of what work is required to do an excellent job. Appended to it is a group consultants Standard Operating Procedure (S.O.P.). This document has also been filed with the Office of the President (OP) in Freetown. In the interest of transparency, the DENI-SL Steering Committee has decided that this document be shared with the Sierra Leonean public verbatim as a news release. Please feel free to go through it as you may choose. This document can also be found at our website at: www.deni-sl.com
I want to congratulate you all on being accepted by the Government of Sierra Leone as Consultants for DENI-SL. Sierra Leone is clearly poised to pioneer this authentic African initiative and pave the way for other countries to follow. It is my understanding that all of us received our individual “Letters of Appointment” from the Office of the President last Friday and that our appointment took effect on June 18, 2009. You were selected for this ground-breaking mission because of the expertise you bring to the table in this group effort. Bravo!
After we sit down with ODA and jazz up some of the Personal TORs and adjust some of the mis-matched positions and titles and also, most poignantly, address the issue of “missing positions along with their missing deliverables,” we’ll post everybody’s picture (with a bio-sketch) on the internet so that the Sierra Leonean Diaspora can see who are the brains at work in Freetown on their behalf. As you may already know by now, we have an emerging website that is entirely devoted to this global project at www.DENI-SL.com that will highlight any and all of our activities in Sierra Leone during the course of our due diligence.
Feel free to encourage your friends, family, acquaintances, colleagues and all your other contacts, be they business or casual, to visit our website frequently and browse to their heart’s content. They are bound to see a picture of you there every now and then. We are also using the website as our promotional tool to maintain the enthusiasm in the Sierra Leonean Diaspora communities all across the globe before the program is officially launched by the President later in the year.
It is gratifying to note that your fellow Sierra Leoneans have wholeheartedly endorsed DENI-SL judging from the immense enthusiasm that our Global Coordinator, Amadu Massally, has generated on several internet SL-specific discussion groups. These tuned-in folks will be looking to us (the consultants on the assignment) to do an outstanding job on DENI-SL that makes them proud and eager to participate with no reservations. So I urge all of you to rise to the challenge and deliver a performance of your life in whatever you, whether it is giving a talk, writing a MEMO or answering a question on DENI-SL. We will not have a second chance for a first impression.
It is fair to say that not only will the Sierra Leoneans be eyeing what we do, the international donor community funding DENI-SL will train their eyes on us too, to see how we perform (see Fred’s 5/18/09 letter to UNDP, item 3 in the list below). We need to deliver a roaring success to dispel the myth that the so-called elite Africans cannot deliver unless they are guided by foreign (Western) experts. We are the Westernized generation of African professionals that will shatter that myth once and for all on a massive global program called DENI-SL. We’ll demonstrate that we are as competent as any professionals anywhere in the world.
As the creator of DENI and the Technical Director of its application, it is incumbent upon me to point the way forward as to how best to execute the DENI-SL program so as to achieve the twin objectives of: “getting 500,000 (or more) ordinary Sierra Leoneans to participate at the rate of $300 (or more) per person to raise $150 million (or more) for GoSL.” It all starts with making sure that our message (as 6 independent-minded professionals) is not discordant to our target audience – the people of Sierra Leone.
We don’t want to inadvertently create a situation where one consultant may be saying one thing to one group in one location while another consultant is saying the exact opposite of the same thing to another group in another location. That would compromise our collective integrity (if the press picks up on it) and do serious damage to our public relations. Therefore, we must strive to maintain a uniform and consistent message with all of our contacts wherever we are. This necessarily requires that we develop a common understanding of DENI as to “what it is” and “what it is not.” In view of this, I suggest that we take care of the following as a “must read” list of critical documents:
1. Our S.O.P.: This is our very first order of business in Freetown before we talk to anybody else as a group and in fact before we square off with each other ourselves as the consultants on the mission. This is critical. It is the sine quo non of all the documents and discussions that will follow. It stands on its own as a separate overarching issue. I cannot over-emphasize its importance. The attached two-pager is your first document to review before all else because it will affect the conduct of our deliberations on practically everything else that we do as a Team. On the other hand, GoSL will have its own separate protocol for all of us a single group that we’ll have to abide by. That is an entirely different matter.
2. Our next order of business is to thoroughly (I mean thoroughly) review the eleven (11) documents that constitute the DENI Program for Sierra Leone (DENI-SL) as follows:
(1) Fred’s June 2008 letter to Sho-Sawyer
(2) Amadu’s December 13, 2008 letter to Hon Minister Kanu
(3) DENI Concept Paper
(4) Terms of Reference
(5) The Deliverables
(6) Provisional Implementation Timetable
(7) Amadu’s article that was published in Newspapers in Freetown in January 2009
(8) PowerPoint Slides used by Hon Minister Alpha Kanu on December 22-23, 2008 to introduce DENI to visiting Diaspora and home-based Sierra Leoneans.
(9) Instructive to MEMO on the DENI Concept. This is where the “heart & soul” of DENI is found and nowhere else in all the documents you’ve seen or will review
(10) Selection of Consultants, courtesy of DENI-Africa; a shared role with a cooperating government. Note that DENI-Africa does not have “Hiring Authority.” It only makes recommendations to the funding agency.
(11) DENI-SL UNDP Project Document (submitted to ODA): Look for two take-aways here: (i) the 5 point criteria for judging an effective PRSP and (ii) how DENI-SL benefits Sierra Leoneans twice.
3. Fred’s May 18, 2009 letter to UNDP: With focus on Sierra Leone as the GO TO Poverty Reduction “Mecca” for African development practitioners who will want to emulate its example.
I assume all of you already received this document.
4. CPAP: SL Country Program Action Plan: Courtesy of Agatha John: which outlines as the name implies, development programs implemented by UNDP (and partners) in SL. Knowledge of this protocol is important so we don’t end up making unreasonable demands on GoSL.
5. The Original set of six Personal TORs plus the two specially prepared for Joe and Len.
The TORs were intended to pinpoint the activities and deliverables that would advance the cause of DENI in Sierra Leone and also feed data into the final product – The Project Implementation Document - that would be posted on our website for all to see. Understand that ODA has made some drastic changes in these TORs that we will have to review and (together with ODA and the Selection Committee in Freetown) hammer out a compromise.
6. SL-PRSP vs. DENI: Follow the directions below to find the document on IMF website:
Clink on the link http://www.imf.org/external/np/prsp/prsp.asp ----.. scroll down along the countries to Sierra Leone and read the PRSP of your country critically - Progress Report 2008. This is the donor-mandated "Bible" for all developing countries. You can’t sit down to talk development matters with development practitioners unless you are thoroughly versed in this document.
Does it address Poverty Reduction to your satisfaction? Where does it fall short, if at all? Which gaps can DENI fill, if any? You be the judge and let us know when we get to it. Every Sierra Leonean on the DENI Mission must read and react to it. We will need your reaction when we review it together.
Use the 5-point criteria on page 1 of the "Instructive MEMO on DENI" (or in item # 2 (11) above) to judge the SL-PRSP or use your own criteria. If you chose to use your own criteria, tell us what it is.
7. Other Financial Services Act 2007. The Stock Exchange laws in Sierra Leone.
We have to pay special attention to this Act. It is the law of the land. It will directly affect the near future of all DENI-acquired SOEs given the structure of DENI.
8. The SL Stock Exchange discussed in 3 business articles by Mohammed Jalloh in Freetown
We have requested a business meeting with him in our Daily Work Plan.
9. Collective Investments Act, 2008: Courtesy of Joe Demby (in London): Still a bill pending before Parliament and not yet an Act. But we need to keep abreast of any and all developments in the financial sector of SL that might impinge on DENI-SL, either negatively or positively.
10. By-Laws for DENI-acquired SOEs: Samples: Courtesy of Vidal Smith and Sonnie John (US). Len Gordon-Harris will be our lead horse on this one.
11. Progress Report on the Privatization Process: December 2004
Courtesy of Vidal Smith (Chicago) - A good read and very pertinent to our mission.
12. Review website at www.DENI-SL.com what’s there? What’s not there? And most importantly, what should be featured there? Ponder that.
13. ECOWAS-wide DENI Workshop in Freetown
Review the two key documents: The Background Note and the Draft Agenda
14. African Remittance Conference: Review the recent invitation from Cameroon for AREC – 2009 and ponder its implications for DENI-Africa going forward
15. “Civil Society Landscape in Sierra Leone” by Mohammed Gibril Sesay
There are reportedly 400 NGOs/CSOs/CBOs in the country. How can we co-opt them to serve the cause of DENI-SL? Ponder that?
16. SL Appropriations Act 2009. What’s GoSL Budget for FY 2009
17. DEAD AID" by Dambisa Moyo. This book is currently the rage in development circles in Africa. Reportedly, African Presidents have read it. Western leaders have read. Gordon Brown and Obama, too, have read it. International Institutions have read it.
18. The Wisdom of Crowds. A good read that will tickle your intellect about group ethics.
19. The Implementation Budget for DENI-SL
I’ve this Budget fully developed. Awaiting Peer Review only.
20. The Full Grant Proposal to be submitted by GoSL to donors in Freetown
I’ve completed the text narrative to go along with the Implementation Budget.
Ready for DENI Team review.
21. PRESENTERS: 2-week intensive course in Freetown.
Training Course Outline to be completed in Freetown
22. CALL CENTER CSRs: 2-week intensive course in Freetown
Training Course Outline to be completed in Freetown
23. DENI-SL Foundation: Unlike other NGOs in the country, the DENI-SL Foundation will be structured as a home-grown institution that is not entirely financially dependent on foreign donor agencies. It will have two wings: a Private Sector Development Wing and a Charitable Activities Wing.:
PRIVATE SECTOR DEVELOPMENT WING:
To establish a permanent dialogue, networking and partnership between Sierra Leoneans at home and (abroad) in the Diaspora.
To maximize involvement of Sierra Leonean Diaspora in investment and entrepreneurship initiatives in Sierra Leone.
CHARITABLE ACTIVITIES WING
Strengthen the NGO collaboration between the Sierra Leonean Development Partners and the Sierra Leonean Diaspora towards sustainable development. A full outline will be ready for Team review in Freetown.
24: Presidential Announcement to Launch DENI-SL to all Sierra Leoneans worldwide:
I have already drafted the text of this critical speech. We should be mindful of the spin.
We will review my draft together at the of our due diligence before we submit it to the OP.
25. DENI-SL Detailed Daily Work Plan: I’ve completed the Daily Work Plan: Ready for DENI Team review in Freetown with ODA and NCP. It is self-explanatory. It dovetails with item #11 above.
For us to be individually and collectively effective in our mission, DENI requires that we spend a full week (Monday thru Friday) to review all of the listed key documents when we assemble in the nation’s capital before we meet with any government officials and other stakeholders in the country. Most of the documents from #2 to #25 will be coming to you in quick succession in the next few days. Please remember to acknowledge receipt of each and every one of them.
After we go through this review exercise, you’ll see why all these documents hang nicely together to provide the context in which DENI-SL will have its desired impact. That is the environment for DENI for all intents and purposes. DENI was not designed to function in a vacuum.
Only the appropriate documents from the list above will ultimately be presented to government officials copied in this email. This extensive (but by no exhaustive) list serves only to remind them that we (the six consultants on assignment) need a full week (of a retreat of sorts) to ourselves to master the details of DENI-SL together before we go out there to face the public. This is critical. Otherwise, we run the risk of a discordant message, if not total chaos, in the course of our due diligence. I consider one week of “grooming” ourselves intellectually for a rigorous assignment that will last at least three months as a good investment of time
Most of the listed documents were touched on during the 6 months of Amadu’s Steering Committee. But that was always done with a light touch and not with the critical eye of a consultant. So, when you review these documents, remember to bear down on the nitty-gritty. As they say, the devil in the details. So, feel free to poke holes in every document you read to make sure that it stands up to scrutiny. Don’t just skim through a document to get a sense of what it’s all about. Master it. Little knowledge is dangerous! You don’t want to be reminded incessantly to go read Fred’s “Instructive MEMO on DENI” because that’s where the “heart and soul” of DENI is located and not in the “DENI Concept Paper.” See?
Some of you may have your own good ideas gathered over the years from your previous assignment. That is great. Don’t hesitate to bring them to the table during our “in-house” deliberations. We will see where they fit, if at all, in the overall DENI scheme of things. We will not submit any document to the GoSL (i.e. ODA) until all of us have reviewed it (and signed off per our SOP rules) to ensure that it conveys our collective wisdom. Anybody who submits a document to the GoSL without this Peer Review will have violated our group ethics. That would be considered private communication that we will collectively disown. This “quality control” measure will not apply to published documents that are already in the public domain but will only apply to those documents that we generate ourselves from scratch in the course of our due diligence.
At the end of an email with a long “TO DO” list like this one, it is important to remind you that there is only one document attached herewith for your immediate review, Rules of the Road (a.k.a. Our SOP). This single document controls our Modus Operandus (MO) of how we will review the rest of the documents and everything else going forward right down to the end of our mission. Now, brace yourself for a barrage of the other documents coming your way soon – but only to the Consultants and not to government officials copied in this email. The rational for copying this very first and only operational memo to government officials is to put them on notice that there will be occasions when we will ask for time-out to regroup. It means we have a weighty issue on our hands that we want to deliberate on before we submit our collective judgment.
I look forward to working closely and constructively with all of you on this robust, comprehensive and ground-breaking initiative for all Sierra Leoneans worldwide.
APPENDIX
Group Consultants “Standard Operating Procedure” (S.O.P.)
Declare your analytical independence! The art of consultancy has been variously defined as "thinking outside the box in search of creative and innovative solutions to intractable problems" and defending proposed solutions, recommendations and opinions with the most compelling logic you can muster. Each one of you has been accepted into this select group of competent, mature and highly opinionated individuals because of the nature of the mission. It requires people of that caliber. Together and individually, we will be addressing issues (pertaining to resource mobilization and poverty reduction) on which practically everybody has a set (if deep-seated) opinion. How do we overcome that entrenched culture of cynicism? We need to be different. Business as usual is not going to cut it for us. We need to listen differently (listening is a skill per se), think and reason differently, behave differently, sound differently, react differently and argue differently. We need to be tough on ourselves in order "to succeed where others have failed." This is the reason why we will devote the evenings of the first week of the DENI Mission in Freetown on an intensive orientation.
Inevitably, we will differ in our approaches to various issues, which is actually desirable in group consulting. That brings out the best in each of us. How, then, do we resolve our differences of opinion? We need to abide by a mutually agreeable set of “rules of the road.” How else can we cope with the egos of six mature, independent and highly opinionated consultants some of whom have worked independently as the sole Consultant on their previous assignments? They had no boss to seek approval from and no one to question their professional judgment except their paying client. For this reason, I want us to establish and agree on the value of analytical thinking. Nobody in the DENI mission will be spared from this rigor - not you, not me. Nobody’s opinion should be dismissed off hand for whatever reason. Everybody’s opinion will be fully entertained. You win best when you win by compelling/unassailable logic. Thus, everybody will be subject to a rigorous scrutiny for what they say, do, don’t do or fail to do. No exceptions. This rigorous peer review is going to be our standard operating procedure (SOP). If any of you has better group model, let’s hear it.
In the course of the DENI mission to Sierra Leone, each consultant will ordinarily have individual assignments to handle in various exacting details emanating from the TOR. You take the assignment and off you go to do it single-handedly. There will be nobody to seek help from or to sit down with you to work it out together. You are “it” in your own right as the consultant on the assignment. You are one among equals. There is no one to spoon-feed you or hold you by the hand and guide you. You will stand or fall upon your own resourcefulness. Your opinion will be respected and valued as such. Even though there will be as many as six Consultants on the Team, everybody will have their own daily assignments to which they have to produce credible answers in a timely fashion. There is no wrong or right answer. But there is such thing as a good answer and a bad answer. All we will be looking for is a consensus on the optimum answer. Every answer has to be complete and substantiated by logic and defended as such - as the most logical among all other options conceivable. That is how you win over your fellow Consultants, on the one hand, and the government officials, on the other.
For folks with good backgrounds like all of us on the DENI Mission have, I’d expect you each one of you to come back with an answer in a timely fashion. If at the end of 4 hrs, you are still struggling, then we have a problem of competence but not a crisis yet. But definitely, if at the end of 8 hrs you still can’t figure out how to proceed, then we have a problem and a crisis of performance and that is unacceptable. Eight (8) hours at your desk is a full day of work and you’d have to be paid for a full day of producing nothing! The project can’t survive on that kind of performance. It will fail, sooner rather than later. And everybody will laugh at all of us as incompetent Africans.
We want everybody in the group to enjoy the DENI mission to the fullest, both personally and professionally. Those who can’t stand the heat may find it very uncomfortable and would have to decide for themselves whether they are enjoying the mission or frustrated by it. We don’t want people to get mad and start using arguments like "That’s how I feel." That is what I call "being emotional and not logical" and we can’t thrive on that. Otherwise, who wins, if we all feel differently? Whose feelings are right? Or rather whose feelings should be imposed on others as constituting the right answer? And how are we ever going to agree on the final product called for in item #10 of the TOR? So, if you disagree with someone on the Team, you must provide compelling counter-arguments which in turn will be subjected to Peer Review.
Your arguments (and peer reaction) will show you clearly where you fall short of the optimum answer, not any single individual on the Team. Isn’t it gratifying to know that no individual on the Team has the power to judge a fellow consultant except by peer review consensus? In this way, our disagreements will not get personal. It’s all about what the group agrees to as the right thing to do. Any individual opinion that garners a simple majority (4 out of 6) wins the battle. End of argument. This assumes that everybody on the mission must have an opinion on all the items in all the Personal TORs. Even the author of DENI (Fred Kwoba) cannot be assumed to be right all the time. Feel free to disagree with him if he doesn’t make sense and challenge him until he convinces you with unassailable logic. If you learn anything at all in the process, that is considered incidental to the mission. It is not, even remotely, the reason why you are there. This is not an opportunity to learn. This is not an internship. This is an opportunity to perform to your highest professional standards. Therefore, you learn only at your personal and private time and not at the expense of the mission.
We must not be shy about telling Team members about any concerns/issues affecting us individually which might affect our performance on any given day or over time. However, this can only happen when there is a good team spirit. By Team spirit, we mean the ability to relate to and work harmoniously with all parties and individuals involved in the project. Every Team member is responsible for helping create and maintain that kind of positive Team spirit. By that we don’t mean unity. Consultants never speak of unity. Actually unity is a bad word in group consulting. Remember, you are a “Think Tank” unto yourself. You must be brave enough to take positions as if you are the only Consultant on the mission. Experienced consultants speak of consensus on any contentious issue – and there are bound to be many. That way, you can walk away with your head held high even though you may have lost the battle of the moment. You win some and lose some.
We must all treat each other with respect, as anything different will put people on the defensive and can negatively impact Team spirit, motivation and performance. By respect we mean, censure yourself at all times. Don’t use words loosely against your fellow consultants that you will later regret. Words have effect. Words fired are like a missile. Once fired, you can’t recall it. The damage is already done. Even if you apologize profusely afterwards, that still leaves a bad taste in the mouth. It is best to exercise self-censorship so you do not have to be sorry and keep asking for forgiveness incessantly. Sooner or later, that becomes an unbearable source of concern and to reign in the disruptive element, adverse action may be taken against somebody.
The thing that kills team spirit real quick is talking past each other in trying to impress. Our mission is to win, not to impress. Listening to what others are saying is a very important skill. This is the sine quo non of good customer service. It goes with a lot of patience to be a good listener. As a way to show that they are wiser than the speaker, Africans have a tendency to ask too many open-ended questions outside of the subject matter at hand. That is good in a seminar, not in consulting. In group consulting, the rule for handling such stray questions is that the questioner has to go first in offering his response to his own stray questions before others can react. There is a good reason for that. It puts the stray questioner on notice that he is wondering away from the subject matter. All this techniques will be tested during our orientation. You will see. I promise you.
Finally, we should all sharpen our debating skills because we are going to need them. The African elite love to argue. So be prepared for contentious discussions at every stop on the DENI mission. In the course of justifying what we or want to do, we will lobby, discuss, debate and argue every step of the way to the very end.
Action Required:
Please eyeball this 2-page document. It will be our Operating Manual. If you think there is something missing, suggest it for inclusion. If there is something in there that you disagree with, point it out and provide counter-arguments. Now is the time to discuss, debate and argue about any of this, not later in Freetown. Once we arrive at the final text, all of us will be bound by it throughout the duration of our DENI Mission in Sierra Leone.

Comments