Salone News

Cursory comments on the Sierra Leone Petroleum bill

18 July 2011 at 05:16 | 555 views

Opinion

By Samuel Zoker, USA.

This bill should be rejected in Parliament because it has not met the minimum international standard for stake holder review, discussion, analyses and debate for petroleum activities which are destined to have unprecedented irreversible economic, social and environmental impact on SL for better or for worse. In hurriedly reviewing this document for the last several hours, I have attempted to benchmark it against the Norwegian “Petroleum Activities Act” because Norway is globally recognized to have the best resource management regime and outcome for its petroleum wealth. Here are the transparency and stakeholder review and debating requirements to be fulfilled before the Norwegian Directorate of Petroleum (NDP) can open an area for petroleum exploration or production:
Section 2-1
Granting of exploration licence etc.

After opening of an area pursuant to section 3-1 the Ministry may grant to a body corporate a licence to explore for petroleum within limited areas of the seabed or its subsoil.

And Section 3-1 states:

Section 3-1

Opening of new areas

Prior to the opening of new areas with a view to granting production licence, an evaluation shall be undertaken of the various interests involved in the relevant area. In this evaluation, an assessment shall be made of the impact of the petroleum activities on trade, industry and the environment, and of possible risks of pollution, as well as the economic and social effects that may be a result of the petroleum activities.

The opening of new areas is a matter which shall be put before local public authorities, central trade and industry associations and other organisations which may be presumed to have a particular interest in the matter.

Furthermore it shall be made known through public announcement which areas are planned to be opened for petroleum activities, and the nature and extent of the activities in question. Interested parties shall be given a period of time of no less than 3 months to present their views.

The Ministry decides on the administrative procedure to be followed in each individual case.

END OF QUOTE

In contrast, the GOSL has not thought it worthwhile for a national review of this critical bill. Yet again, this government’s orchestrated avoidance of minimal democratic scrutiny of what it has presented as a Petroleum Bill casts doubt on its role as an honest and competent agent for carrying out transactions for our natural resources with foreign commercial interests.

The regime of Petroleum Licence in this bill is not commercially efficient for SL and will be open to manipulation against its commercial interest. The accepted international practice is to have separate Exploration Licence and Production Licence. In the case of Norway, the Exploration Licence has duration of 3 years and the Production Licence has duration of 10 years. The Exploration Licence is not exclusive so that the State’s interest in finding petroleum is not limited by the technical expertise and financial resources of the Exploration Licencee. Also, the Exploration Licence does not confer preference on the Exploration Licencee for a Production Licence. The Production Licence is exclusive for an area and gives the Licencee the right to explore, drill and produce petroleum. The problem with only having a “Petroleum Licence” which combines Exploration and Production rights is that it provides a low entry point to Licencees who may have the technical and commercial capability to explore for petroleum but have no conceivable capacity to produce petroleum. In essence the GOSL will be granting production rights to entities who will turn around and sell those rights far more profitably for themselves than the State who originated the rights could realize because it sold them without the benefit of knowing petroleum reserves data from exploration. I’m aware that the bill has the State’s right of first refusal to buy those rights but this inefficient regime unnecessary invites litigation that the State may not afford. The two Licences should be separate, if only for the commercial reason that Exploration results will set the rent for the Production Licence. and unrelated. These important beneficial features – separateness of the Exploration and Production Licences and their explicit short durations, 3 and 10 years, respectively, have not been captured in this GOSL Petroleum Bill.

Specifically, what the GOSL bill states on these matters in Sections 42-43 is very bad for the nation commercially:

Section 42. A petroleum licence shall confer on the Licencee an exclusive right to undertake exploration and production within a licence area.

Section 43.1 A petroleum licence shall be valid for a maximum period of thirty years from the effective date, except sooner cancelled or terminated as provided in this act.

The treatment of flaring and venting of natural gas in this bill is wasteful to the State and harmful to the environment and ignores contemporary thinking on energy and climate change from greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. The international best practice is to have a CO2 (carbon) tax on flaring and natural gas venting from petroleum activities. This serves as a disincentive to flare and vent hydrocarbons and pushes the Licencee and the State into quickly taking steps to monetize this petroleum resource as well as save the environment from hazardous emissions.

There are other concerns relating to the functional roles and performance targets for the proposed SL Directorate of Petroleum and the Sierra Leone National Petroleum Company, international best practice governance of the local economy in order to avoid the so-called “Dutch Disease” wherein petroleum wealth actually makes the non-petroleum economy perform poorly, etc. that one can provide more detailed analytical comments on if only the GOSL can act responsibly and subject this bill to the due diligence analysis and debate that it deserves in our national interest.

Comments