Commentary
By Cillaty Daboh, USA.
I have been following the reports on activities of the pending chieftaincy elections in various parts of the country. From what I have read so far, our chieftaincy election and their retention of office have not kept pace with developmental aspirations of our nation.
This has led to some people asking if the institution is needed in modern day Sierra Leone. My answer to that is a resounding yes. However, if the institution is to continue to remain relevant, certain reforms have to be made to the institution.
Many will argue against reform citing the monarchies in Europe especially the British who thanks to them we find ourselves in this quagmire. Let us not forget that the British monarchial system has been reformed over the years in line with the times we live in. We do not have any monarchy wielding the powers of Bloody Mary or the Louis dynasty that existed in France. In the British monarchy succession to the throne is well established. We know that if the current Queen dies today, there is no contest; Prince Charles automatically becomes the King of England.
Such a succession process is not clearly spelt out in our monarchy, that is chieftaincy. We see many families from the same house contesting against each other leaving the House divided.
In our chieftaincy system there is cause for exclusion and injury to the citizen’s civic privileges by denying them the right to vote and be voted for solely based on who their parents are or their gender.
On November, 18th 2009, the Awareness Times newspaper online edition reported on a “Big Bitterness Brewing in Binkolo” over the rights of candidates to contest for the vacant chieftaincy position. According to Awareness Times one of the candidates was disqualified from contesting because a resident of the chiefdom alleged that the candidate’s “Mother was not a legally wedded wife of Alimamy Dura of whose ancestry, children of the ruling house are certified”.
But the disqualified candidate, according to another story by a citizen of the chiefdom residing in the U.S in the Standard Times Press online, is the most popular candidate and according to the same report the only one among the candidates who has not only lived with his people in joy and pain but has also brought development projects to his people. Despite these facts the candidate can be denied his civil right as a citizen just because he is an alleged illegitimate child or “bastard”. As if he has control over the conditions and situation surrounding his birth. In Kono a woman was denied her right to contest for chieftaincy solely based on her gender notwithstanding the fact that she was born from royalty, a condition that is a prerequisite for qualification for contesting.
The chieftaincy water got muddier when I read the online edition of the Exclusive newspaper of Nov. 23rd captioned:
“Over chieftaincy Right….. Margai petitions APC-May Call for an Injunction.”
According to Margai and quoting section 8(2) of the constitution the
“only recognized ruling houses are those that had been established and in existence as such at independence on April 27th 1961.”
But how were these houses selected in the first place.?
Paramount chieftaincy in Sierra Leone came about partly as experimentation for the British colonial system of divide and rule.
In their divide and rule experimentation the British tried to woo Africans by signing treaties of friendship with authorities or authority figures who were not necessarily chiefs of their locales. These authority figures had to be wealthy merchants, men of influence or those who have signed treaties with the British. Interestingly some of these influential men were asked by the chiefs who were not necessarily “paramount” in their areas. Ruling families as we know today were either chosen from those families who signed the treaties or they were just wealthy men in their areas.
Would the Margais have then acquired chieftaincy through the the family patriarch Mr. Margay, a prominent businessman in Bonthe later to become Mr. M.E.S. Margai, and father of our first two Prime ministers and grand father of the erudite lawyer Charles Margai now filing this injunction on behalf of the Margai family.?
We know that Mr. Margay himself was not from Bonthe. He had made enough money to become influential and maybe became one of the signatories to the treaties of friendship with the British or the British just found him progressive so as to entitle him to royalty in the Lower Banta chiefdom. It may be too that Mr. Margay was married to a lady from a royal house for him to claim the title as well.
It therefore begs the question why Mr. Momoh, a citizen of the area according to this same report, whose mother is a Margai should not be qualified to contest the chieftaincy elections though his cousins and uncles have right to ?.
With the “ paternal lineage” rights in our constitution let’s say Mr. Momoh’s mother was a paramount chief married to Mr. Momoh who is not from a ruling house, why will the young Mr. Momoh be disqualified from claiming what’s rightfully his mother’s but his cousin is able to do same by virtue of his cousin being his mother’s brother’s son.?
I understand that in those days, a man’s wealth was not only measured by the number of cows he had but the number of women as well. As such women were considered properties. May be that’s why right to chieftaincy is by “ paternal lineage” Those days are gone. No longer do our women walk behind us but by our sides.
What is more interesting is when you read the constitutional qualification for a chieftaincy candidature. Mr. Margai quoted the constitution thus:
“ A person is qualified to stand as a candidate if-(a) he was born out of wedlock to rightful claimant in a recognized ruling house in the chiefdom or (b) he has direct paternal lineage to a rightful claimant in a recognized ruling house whether born outside wedlock or not.”
This begs the question as to why the candidate in Binkolo was disqualified solely on the basis of been born out of wedlock, or why was the lady in Kono disqualified solely based on her gender? It is obvious the above cited reasons for disqualification are all unconstitutional.
What this section of our constitution tells me is that even though our chiefs wield enormous power, one does not have to be morally, physically or otherwise competent to become a chief. It does not matter if he/she is a crook Just be born into it and you have to wield enormous powers without working for it. It does not even matter if the chief house you are claiming your right to was a terrible one that destroyed the chiefdom, but as descendant of the bad chief we will reward you with good for your father’s evil deeds and you are at liberty to victimize those your dad victimized
Chieftaincy elections are supposed to be local matters but our national politicians have over the years interfered in these elections and even the governance of the chiefs duly elected. Chiefs have been banished from their chiefdoms or deposed under the two political parties that have ruled our country. In the 70s during the APC era chiefs were “elected not on merit or right but by political favoritism. This seemed to continue under the SLPP as was in the case of Biriwa chiefdom chieftaincy elections.
What is the Solution?
Before I come up with my solutions I want to make it clear to those who may be thinking that I want to take a back door route to chieftaincy. Been a great, great grand son, grand son and son of paramount chiefs, I stand to benefit from the current discriminatory system than anybody else. I am sure all claimants to the ruling houses are proud that they come form these houses. But I am sure they would not want to be judged by the evil deeds of their parents. So why should they be compensated not for what they have done for their communities but for their grandparents signing a piece of paper which in all cases was sell out?
1. The so-called declaration of rights have brought an enormous toll on so many people. It is life sentence of shame and disgrace in our culture to be called a “bastard”, much more so to be done in public like they do in the declaration of Rights. Our civil servants have not helped the situation and become evil servants and declare harvest time when ever there is chieftaincy election in the chiefdoms. To avoid such debacle being played over and over again in a country yearning for peace and development, parliament must take a second look at the chieftaincy act and open it to all adult tax paying citizens of the chiefdom.
2. To be qualified to contest for chieftaincy a candidate must be a property owner in the chiefdom. Such property shall not only be family land/house but must include a house in his/her own name in that chiefdom.
3. Such must have continuously paid his/her local tax in that chiefdom for at least seven years at the time of election.
4. The election of paramount chiefs must be opened to all tax paying adults in the chiefdom and the electoral system of electing chiefs be abolished.
5. Like our parliamentarians and president, paramount chiefs should be accountable to their people through elections. For chiefs it should be every ten years.
It is costly and very divisive to remove a bad chief from power. In many areas people have resorted to an expensive chiefdom “palava” to remove their bad chiefs. Some of those chiefdom “palavas” have had national consequences. I am sure the people will be patient with a bad chief and save themselves an expensive court battle and a divided chiefdom if they know they have the power to tell that chief that you aren’t good for us in an election. Why would somebody bother doing a good job if he knows he cannot be fired form that job?

Comments