By Ron Cheong, Canada
Canada is a trading nation.
We do not merely sell goods; we build relationships. We do not merely ship products; we weave
supply chains, partnerships, and trust across borders.
For decades, we believed that the Canada-U.S. relationship, though sometimes
quarrelsome, was ultimately anchored by mutual interest and common sense.
We believed that the economic logic was too powerful to ignore: that two
integrated economies would not deliberately wound themselves.
The Age of Erratic Tariffs – Treaties Unilaterally Torn-up by Tweet
But we have learned something sobering in recent years.
A trade agreement can be signed in ink, yet undone in practice by impulse.
A promise can be written into a treaty, yet suspended by a tweet.
And stability, true stability, can vanish not because the rules disappear, but because one side
decides the rules are optional.
This is the reality Canada must now face.
The question before us is not whether the United States can formally “walk away†from
USMCA. The deeper question is whether the United States can behave as if it already has, by
imposing tariffs, inventing pretexts, and turning the border into a bargaining table.
And the answer, plainly, is yes.
Tariffs have become more than a trade tool. They have become a political instrument, used to
intimidate, to extract, to force compliance. The old assumption that economics would restrain
politics has been reversed. Politics now seeks to dominate economics.
So what must Canada do?
We must do what middle powers have always done in difficult times: we must be calm,
strategic, and unafraid.
We must not panic.
We must not posture.
And we must not fold.
Because there is a difference between compromise and surrender.
There is a difference between diplomacy and dependency.
There is a difference between buying peace and paying tribute.
Yes, Canada must keep the relationship intact. Geography is not a choice. The United States
is our largest market, our closest neighbour, and the central artery of our trade. We cannot
decouple overnight, and we should not pretend otherwise.
But we also cannot accept a future in which Canada lives under permanent threat, where every
election cycle in the United States becomes a new round of economic hostage-taking.
That is not partnership. That is not friendship. That is not free trade.
That is a protection racket.
What Canada Can Give: Safe Concessions That Buy Stability
So Canada’s strategy must be clear.
We should offer early cooperation where it strengthens Canada as well: serious border
management, coordinated enforcement against organized crime, and a credible defence
posture in the Arctic. These are not concessions to Washington. They are responsibilities to
ourselves.
What Canada Must Never Give: The Concessions That Turn a Country into a
Client
But we must draw red lines where Canada’s future is at stake.
We must never surrender dispute settlement, the very mechanism that prevents a middle
power from being crushed by arbitrary decisions. Without neutral enforcement, agreements
become theatre: words without protection, promises without remedy.
We must never accept permanent export caps or “voluntary†quotas, on lumber, on autos,
on energy, on anything. Quotas are not stability. Quotas are a leash. Once accepted, they do
not end; they multiply.
And we must never give away our right to govern our own future economy: our digital
rules, our data sovereignty, our cultural independence. The wealth of the next century will
be built not only from oil and steel, but from code, platforms, and intellectual property.
Canada cannot afford to trade away tomorrow to quiet the noise of today.
The U.S. Can Hurt Canada - But It Also Hurts Itself
And let us be honest about the American side of this equation.
Tariffs do not only hurt Canada. They hurt the United States too. They raise prices for American
families. They disrupt American factories. They inflate American housing costs. They punish
American farmers. The border is not a wall between two separate economies, it is a seam in one
shared industrial fabric. Tear it, and both sides bleed.
But Canada bleeds faster. And that is why we must act with discipline.
Our goal must be stability, yes. But stability without submission.
Canada’s answer to the age of erratic tariffs is not outrage. It is not flattery. It is not fear.
It is strategy: defend what must be defended, yield only what is safe to yield, and build the
strength that ensures we will never again be so vulnerable.
Canada’s objective is not to “win†an argument with Washington. It is to reduce exposure
to Washington’s volatility. That means securing predictable access where we must, retaliating
selectively where we can, and building alternatives where we should.
The lesson of the tariff era is simple: agreements matter, but leverage matters more.
Canada must therefore build leverage—through diversification, domestic capacity, and
alliances with other advanced economies facing the same coercive tactics.
We cannot control U.S. politics. But we can control Canada’s vulnerability to it. The
measure of success is not applause or headlines. It is whether, five years from now, Canada
is harder to pressure, harder to isolate, and harder to economically threaten.
That is stability. Not submission.

Comments