Salone News

Abass Bundu’s Three Possibilities and Seven Commandments

28 December 2010 at 21:41 | 903 views

Opinion

By Dr. Sheik Umarr Kamarah, Professor of English and Linguistics, Department of Languages and Literature, Virginia State University, Petersburg, Virginia, USA.

On Saturday, December 18, 2010, Dr. Abass Bundu gave a keynote address in America on the occasion of Fundraising for the “Maada Bio for SLPP Flag Bearer Campaign,” in which he made certain claims that sit without ease both within the keynote address itself as an argument, and on the couch of Sierra Leone’s historical reality.

My goal in this response is not to speak against Abass Bundu’s candidate or even his motive for choosing that candidate since it is his right to choose and promote any aspirant of his choice. My interest is in critically evaluating the reasoning that informs some of Dr. Bundu’s conclusions, and questioning the validity of some of the claims he makes. There are quite a few statements or issues raised that one can quibble with in this keynote but I only wish to address some:

In Part IV of his speech, entitled, The Special Role of Youths in the 2007 and 2012 Elections, Abass Bundu clearly outlines the condition of the youths of today in Sierra Leone. He makes reference to the collective chronological age of today’s youths in order to show that the youths of today were born towards the end of the “first APC” era, and so know precious little about the “horrors” of the old APC. In the process of making his case, Abass Bundu opines that, “ They can’t even remember the APC, neither the misrule of President Momoh’s APC government that precipitated the rebel war.”

This bit does not comfortably jive with the reality of our political history. It is disquieting that Abass Bundu would blame Momoh’s APC government, which represents only the last six years of APC rule, for the rebel war.

Coincidentally, it is the period of APC rule in which Abass Bundu did not participate. Joseph Saidu Momoh came to office in 1986, nearly two decades after APC came to power in 1968. No sane mortal would deny that the conditions for a national explosion had long been created before Momoh took over that rotten piece of governance machinery from Siaka Stevens. Abass Bundu was an integral part of that APC machinery that derailed the dignity of the Sierra Leonean, and violently threw the country into mayhem. To attempt to absolve Siaka Stevens’ rule from blame for the rebel war is, to say the least, a mark of intellectual dishonesty.

Earlier in the speech, Abass Bundu talks about the 2007 elections and how the APC “spiced up their campaign with propaganda.” He argues that the APC successfully demonized the SLPP as a tribal party by pointing “ to the party’s then front-line leadership: Solomon Berewa, as the flag-bearer; Alhaji U.N.S. Jah, as National Chairman; J.J. Saffa, as National Secretary-General;…” In essence, APC were able to show that SLPP was a Mende man’s party as reflected in their South-Eastern or Mende line up. In other words, if the ethnic or regional composition of the line up were different, one would surmise, APC would not have succeeded in demonizing SLPP. Abass Bundu makes the point that the best way to “defeat the APC propaganda is to present a better idea; one that defeats tribalism; one that inspires the citizenry to think as one…” He also believes that if SLPP follows the motto, “One country, One People,” the great divide will be bridged. This is all well and good.

But in Part VI, entitled, The SLPP, the PMDC, the Flag Bearer and the Prospects for 2012, Abass Bundu’s call to present a better idea that “defeats tribalism and inspires the citizenry to think as one,” is undermined by the argument he advances in favour of one of the three possibilities he postulates with regard to the SLPP flag-bearer for 2012:

"First, a northerner as SLPP flag-bearer, pitched against President Koroma
of the APC, can mean only one thing: the president in 2012 is a northerner.
This could play neatly into the hands of Charles Margai, who could then use his
messiah-like posturing to good effect among his people in the South. Second, a
westerner as flag-bearer, the dynamics would be more or less the same as for the
first option. Third, a south-easterner as flag-bearer: this creates an entirely different
dynamic. Unlike 2007, in 2012 south-easterners would have had the benefit of hindsight,
and knowing that Charles could again deny victory to the SLPP, his message is unlikely
to be as palatable as it was then."

Many questions immediately jump at the reader. What is wrong with having a northerner as president in 2012 if that individual is the people’s choice? Also, what significant changes have occurred in the “front-line of SLPP leadership besides replacing Alhaji U.N.S. Jah with John Oponjo Benjamin? If Abass Bundu’s candidate becomes the flag bearer, the line up in 2012 will be even more Mende than it was in 2007. Is this Abass Bundu’s better idea that should bridge the great divide? Is this not privileging one group (ethnic or regional) against the rest within the big tent that is SLPP? So, this grand old party, guided by the noble ideal of “One Country, One People,” must now helplessly succumb to a possibility that blatantly undermines the very ideals upon which it rests; ideals that Abass Bundu takes the time to highlight as the guiding light of SLPP?

Charles Margai, Abass implicitly argues, will frown upon SLPP picking a northern flag-bearer, and will use that fact to convince “his people,” who are Mendes, to stay away from SLPP. But Charles Margai himself is already in partnership with a northern president. Is Abass Bundu speaking for Charles Margai or is subtly exploiting region and tribe to promote his choice for the 2012 SLPP flag bearer? The logic in this argument leaks. One would think that if SLPP is the party of equality, democracy, and ideas, the only thing that should matter in their contest are, competence, character, vision, record, national appeal and potential to win. Why would region or tribe matter?
But the following words from Abass Bundu, further spell Abass Bundu’s self deconstruction: “Pragmatism, not tribalism, should now influence our choice in favour of an aspirant from the South-East. Our supporters there would no doubt come out in droves on polling day.” So, SLPP supporters will only come out in droves if a South-Easterner is chosen to lead the party. Only a Mende, in other words, can bring out the Mende vote. This does not only contradict earlier statements made by Abass Bundu about SLPP, it is also lame, unimaginative, and even more divisive than any APC propaganda. Where is Abass Bundu’s thinking cap? This is no Pragmatism, my dear Abass, this is crass regionalism or tribalism promoted to serve a selfish end.

Finally, Abass Bundu postulates seven conditions that I refer to as Seven Commandments.

Just as there are competing narratives about our country and why it is in deep morass, there
also are competing views about the qualities of the person who will hoist it out of the morass.
Whilst we each are entitled to our list of the qualities our national leader must possess, such list can be subjected to critical analysis by the citizens that leader intends to govern. Abass Bundu, in his keynote address, proposes seven conditions that the SLPP flag bearer must satisfy if he should have a chance of beating the incumbent, Ernest Bai Koroma. While I agree with some of the conditions, I have a problem with most of them because of the implicit or explicit (in some cases), reasoning underlying them.

In the first place, Abass Bundu, in talking about the SLPP flag bearer, consistently uses the pronoun, he. Well, one can argue that he is using the representative or universal he in British English that stands for both male and female referents in a discourse. However, even the British have become sensitive to the argument about the gender bias inherent in the use of he to represent both sexes. It just sounds odd to me that in a contest in which three of the twenty-three candidates are women, a recognition of that fact is absent in Abass Bundu’s presentation. It makes, at least, political sense, if not decency, to use he or she as a recognition of the three women in the contest. It leaves me wondering whether this is just about the nature of the English language itself, or a matter of the writer’s socialization.

Conditions (ii) and (iii) both emphasize the need for the flag bearer to have been a president or head of state since the opponent could have had a five year experience as head of state by 2012. This is a pretty vapid and unimpressively transparent condition. According to this condition, only Ahmed Tejan Kabbah, Valentine Strasser, and Maada Bio would qualify to contest against Ernest Koroma. But Ahmed Tejan Kabbah and Strasser are not in the race; that leaves Maada Bio, Abass Bundu’s candidate the only qualified individual. This suggests that Abass Bundu’s conditions are crafted to suit only his candidate’s profile, but not to cater for our national aspirations. The current condition of our state suggests that all our past leaders have failed the country. Why must we go back to the same basket of barren leadership that has failed us, to pick one that will shape our future? Nothing can be more counterintuitive. This is a classic case of retrogressive thinking.

Condition (iv) talks about chronological age. For Abass Bundu, the flag bearer “must be of an age that the youths can easily identify with as one of their own.” Really? Haven’t we been there before? Dr. Bundu must be seriously suffering from a senior moment here. In 1992, military officers ousted the APC government. That coup ushered in, by then, the youngest leader of state in the world, Captain Valentine Strasser. He was later removed from office and replaced with Maada Bio, another very young leader at the time. Their regime, the NPRC, was the regime of the youths. Interestingly, Abass Bundu, not a youth at the time, worked for the NPRC along with Maada Bio, his current Flag Bearer choice. The NPRC, the government of the youths, was an enormous failure and a mighty disappointment? Their era was a moment when the usual idealism associated with youths was sacrificed on the altar of unbridled corruption and naked violence. The nation experienced but a dance of ineptitude and pain. I know we hardly learn lessons from history, but this one is worth learning from. Thus, this condition is not only difficult to buy, it is also myopic.

Condition (vi) seems benign on the surface but lends itself to a variety of interpretations. In the context of Sierra Leone politics, this condition can have an unsavoury spice to it. No doubt, looks are important in elections around the world but they are never a major reason for voting for a candidate. America loved Bill Clinton and Al Gore but were scared of Dan Quayle, an equally handsome and young man. So, substance often trumps looks. Now, in our country, we have a rich record of our leaders, who happen to be all male, being philanderers. In that context, this condition can be seen to be subscribing to the idea of “kolonkonizing” the state and “kupaynizing” state house. Also, since Abass Bundu’s syntax eliminates the woman from the narrative of the contest, one would argue that the only function he can find for women is cheerleading. Theirs is to admire and be attracted to the “hot” flag bearer. It is difficult to deny the existence of a sexist undertone in this condition. Clearly, beneath the sleek veneer of One Country, One People perches a desire to craft a personal agenda. Hence, the turmoil in the keynote.

Comments