Analysis

A Tribute to Musa Khalil Suma (1942-2007)

7 March 2007 at 21:11 | 5426 views

"Musa Suma’s formative experience growing up in the tribally, religiously, and culturally diverse homes in the rural provinces and in the urban capital city of SL laid the foundation for his lifelong practical commitment to the morally uplifting principle of equal opportunity for all S/Leoneans, irrespective of social status, age, sex, or tribe, or other ascriptive quality."

By Mohamed A. Jalloh,USA.

On behalf of my family and myself, I would like to extend to Mrs. Ramatu Suma, nee Hassan, the children and grandchildren, Ms. Yeabu Suma, Mr. Momodu Janneh, Jesmed Suma and the rest of the entire family and friends of the late Alhaji Musa Khalil Suma, our heartfelt sympathy upon their grave personal loss.

It is one of the certainties of life on earth that every man or woman who comes into this world must exit it, sooner or later. Yet, no man or woman can know the exact date and time of his or her own exit. Accordingly, those among us who worship God know it to be their sacred duty to do good deeds and follow His teachings. That obligation starts from the first day that we are capable of doing so until that certain, but unknown, time when we take our exit to face Him to account for our deeds on earth.

Sadly, that day has come much too soon for Musa Khalil Suma, former Managing Director of the Sierra Leone Produce Marketing Board (SLPMB), one of SL’s leading foreign exchange earners during his tenure. At the time he suddenly passed away on Monday, February 26, 2007, Mr. Suma was also the owner and chief executive officer of the privately held Sumatu International, a holding company with subsidiaries in SL, Guinea and the UK. With Alhaji Suma’s untimely death, SL has lost one of its great business minds among the generation of its highly educated sons and daughters which came of age at our country’s independence in 1961. That generation, born in the 1940’s and brought up in a golden age in SL when education was considered among the highest priorities for most families, has now entered its sixth decade of life. For some of them, including the late Mr. Suma, reaching the Biblical landmark of three score and ten years of life on earth would be one of the few goals that would forever remain out of their characteristically ambitious reach.

As the torch of life is passed from our beloved compatriots who have preceded us to the great beyond, to those of us still left to forge our way here on earth, it becomes our solemn duty to eulogize them. And so I shall do for our recently departed father, brother, uncle, nephew, cousin, and friend — the late Alhaji Musa Khalil Suma. I do so with humility and praise to God (or Allah, in the Arabic language of Islam), the maker of heaven and earth.

Among the many admirable qualities of the late Musa Suma were his devotion to Islam, his humility, his empathy, and his lifelong commitment to the pursuit of excellence in education and business. In a demonstration of another of his estimable qualities — his legendary generosity — Mr. Suma dedicated himself to a rare goal in SL. That goal was the personal and professional development of others, particularly SL’s promising youth. That is how Musa Suma — the academic over-achiever with multiple graduate degrees in economics who had benefited from the kindness of many S/Leoneans at critical points in his life — generously gave back to the society that had nurtured him from his humble beginnings.

Among the most influential of those benefactors was the late Pa Arthur Williams, a longtime senior teacher at St. Edward’s Secondary School in Freetown. Mr. Williams not only opened his home to a young Musa Suma when the latter traveled to Freetown from Kambia to attend the sixth form at St. Edward’s, but he also daily mentored him. It was Pa Arthur, as the legendary history teacher was known to Mr. Suma and many generations of Old Edwardians (including myself), whom Mr. Suma credited for his introduction to the principles of economics and nationalism.

Musa Suma’s formative experience growing up in the tribally, religiously, and culturally diverse homes in the rural provinces and in the urban capital city of SL laid the foundation for his lifelong practical commitment to the morally uplifting principle of equal opportunity for all S/Leoneans, irrespective of social status, age, sex, tribe, or other ascriptive quality.

It is with humility that I acknowledge that I was among a large number of young graduates of Fourah Bay College and Njala University, hailing from every tribe in SL and ranging in age from barely 21 to their early 30’s, who had the privilege of benefiting from the tribe-blind and status-blind disciplined mentoring of one of the most brilliant business minds that SL has ever produced — Alhaji Musa Suma. In return, Mr. Suma reaped the reward of dedicated service from a cadre of young professionals from the time he was promoted Managing Director of SLPMB at the tender age of 35 in 1978 through his retirement five years later. During that time, he transformed SLPMB into one of the best run companies in either the private or public sector in SL.

I had the honor of first meeting the late Mr. Suma at a time when I myself had barely come of age. The meeting occurred at a place to which I was no stranger — the Sierra Leone Produce Marketing Board. I had worked there as an intern four years earlier while I was still in my mid-teens, during the vacation following the end of my first year at Fourah Bay College in Freetown, SL. The meeting, which occurred about three months after I had started working full time at SLPMB as an Accounting Assistant (the entry level position for college graduates with an economics degree and a specialization in accounting), was a testament to Mr. Suma’s open-door policy to every employee. It ended with the start of what would turn out to be a direct working relationship between us at SLPMB that would end five years later upon Mr. Suma’s retirement as Managing Director and his entry into private business as owner and chief executive officer of Sumatu International.

During our meeting, Mr. Suma observed the first ever trend analysis of SLPMB’s financial results which I had compiled on my own, in addition to performing my regular duties as an accounting assistant. I had embarked upon the project after I had discovered that no such analysis existed at SLPMB. Following the meeting, Mr. Suma referred me to the head of the accounting department (Accounts Manager) for an interview to evaluate my suitability for a promotion. I was interviewed subsequently by a panel comprising SLPMB’s Financial Controller and the Account Manager, and, based upon my performance, I was promoted to the position of Accountant. My first assignment would have been daunting for any recent graduate, even one who had the additional advantage of being the first S/Leonean to ever graduate from Fourah Bay College in its then nearly 150-year history with an honors degree in economics with a major in accounting, as I was privileged to be.

However, it was a testament to Mr. Suma’s uncanny ability to assess the strengths and weaknesses of the hundreds of employees who worked under his supervision that he instructed that I be assigned to one of the toughest jobs at SLPMB at the time. It was also evidence of two of Mr. Suma’s many other admirable qualities. First, he had an unshakeable commitment to the morally upright principle that neither age nor tribe should be a barrier to any capable S/Leonean’s opportunity to serve his/her country. Second, he was committed to the principle that employees should be rewarded only as a result of their performance. Those twin qualities and many others illustrated in my personal story and that of many others who were fortunate to have worked with Mr. Suma represent the secrets of his phenomenal success as the most accomplished managing director of the largest parastatal in SL at the time — SLPMB. Musa Suma’s stellar accomplishment was made even more remarkable by the fact that he was the youngest person ever appointed managing director in SLPMB’s 47-year history.

And that was how I, a S/Leonean from the Fula tribe who had not met Mr. Suma (a S/Leonean from the Susu tribe) before I started working at SLPMB in 1978, came to be assigned to the challenging job of heading the accounting department at the SL Palm Kernel Oil Mill (SLPKOM) in early 1979. The mill was a subsidiary of SLPMB that manufactured palm kernel oil and cake from palm kernels for export to Europe. A few months earlier, Mr. Suma had demonstrated his characteristic commitment to nationalism by successfully prevailing upon the APC government of President Siaka Stevens not to renew the management contract for SLPKOM with a British company. At the time, that company was being paid a huge amount of scarce foreign exchange by the SL government to manage the operations of SLPKOM, which was making losses.

In the wake of the government’s decision, Mr. Suma assembled a team that included other young S/Leoneans. Significantly, most of them were Fourah Bay College graduates in their twenties and early thirties, who belonged to many different tribes, from Aku to Creole to Mende and Themne. It was this team, led by Mr. Suma, which took over from the expatriate management of SLPKOM in 1979, and managed the company’s accounting, engineering, human resources, manufacturing, marketing, security and other corporate functions. Remarkably, within 18 months, the SLPMB management team had successfully turned around the erthswhile money-losing operations of SLPKOM under its expatriate management to a profitable business managed entirely by young S/Leoneans.

As Mr. Suma promoted members of our class of proven FBC graduates to top management positions in SLPMB during the succeeding years, his commitment to developing promising young Sierra Leonean graduates only increased. This coincided with SLPMB’s emergence as the premier choice for employment for many young college graduates in SL during the early 1980’s. It gave me great satisfaction to play a leading role in recruiting the most qualified graduates from the economics and accounting departments of FBC to what was then much-sought employment at SLPMB.

The attraction of SLPMB as a magnet for S/Leoneans seeking a fair reward for their skills was not an accident. It represented a deliberate policy by Mr. Suma to introduce financial, human resource, marketing, and other corporate policies which were designed to promote reasonable profitability in the operations of SLPMB, while promoting accountability to the SL government. Thereby, Mr. Suma guaranteed accountability for SLPMB’s activities to the ultimate owners of SLPMB — the people of SL. Indeed, during his tenure as managing director, SLPMB recorded the highest profit in its history even though it was paying the highest proportion of the world market price of its cocoa and coffee exports to SL’s farmers. In order to appreciate the phenomenal strides made by SLPMB under the direction of Musa Suma as its managing director, it is necessary to take a look at SLPMB before and after Mr., Suma’s tenure. So as to keep this tribute to a reasonable length, only the most significant of Mr. Suma’s numerous accomplishments will be noted.

In 1973, when a young S/Leonean economist working at the Ministry of Finance, Musa Khalil Suma, was appointed deputy managing director of one of SL’s largest foreign exchange earners, SLPMB, at the age of 30, he arrived at SLPMB to find many unwelcome surprises in SLPMB’s management and in its accounting, marketing, purchasing, and security operations, viz.

More than a decade after SL had obtained its independence from Great Britain in 1961, SL’s largest foreign exchange earner from its agricultural produce, SLPMB, was still being run by a British citizen as its managing director. Mr. Suma also discovered that, upon his appointment as deputy managing director, he became only the second college graduate among the several hundred SLPMB employees. Moreover, he was the only SLPMB employee with a degree in economics. Needless to say, he was also the only one with a graduate degree.

The new, young deputy managing director also found unwelcome surprises in SLPMB’s accounting operations. SLPMB did not have an adequate system of internal control for verifying the purchases from farmers of palm kernels, cocoa, coffee, and ginger that were received at SLPMB’s headquarters at Cline Town in Freetown for export. Accordingly, there was inadequate assurance that payments made by SLPMB were being made for produce that had actually been received into SLPMB’s stores. The probability for fraud was extremely high under such inadequate systems of internal financial controls. Indeed, six years earlier, the Beoku Betts commission of enquiry had actually found massive fraud involving produce allegedly bought and exported by SLPMB that it found to have been perpetrated by SLPMB officials in collusion with officials at SLPMB’s supervising ministry, the Ministry of Trade and Industry.

Yet another problem identified by Mr. Suma in the system for buying produce was one that cost both the SLPMB and small farmers dearly. It involved the inadequate service provided by the private buying agents who bought produce from small farmers and sold it to SLPMB. Where these small farmers produced only a small crop or farmed at great distance from the major roads, their produce proved unattractive to buying agents. The ability of these farmers to sell their crop to SLPMB was therefore limited. Both they and SLPMB lost revenue as a result of their failure to deliver any of their produce to SLPMB.

In addition, Mr. Suma discovered that SLPMB did not have an adequate system for evaluating and monitoring the purchases of non-agricultural items such as office supplies, fuel, etc., that were required to run the vast operations of the company. Again, this inadequacy raised the probability of malfeasance in the purchasing activities of the company.

Yet, to his greatest surprise, the newly-appointed deputy managing director soon found out that he was relatively powerless to make the urgently-needed changes required to correct the anomalies he had discovered. This was because, having been recruited from outside SLPMB, he was perceived as an outsider by the rest of the management of SLPMB throughout his five-year tenure as deputy managing director. He was therefore kept away from the key levers of power within SLPMB’s management. Accordingly, it was only upon his promotion to managing director that he had the first real opportunity to make the sorely-needed changes.

In response to the inadequacy of the internal controls over SLPMB’s purchases of palm kernels, coffee, cocoa, and ginger, Mr. Suma took several corrective steps. They included the installation of a brand new weighbridge that recorded the independently verifiable weight of any and every lorry delivering produce to SLPMB’s stores in Freetown, both on their way in and out of SLPMB’s stores. This made it easier to verify the actual weight of produce purchased by SLPMB. In addition, a comprehensive payment system was installed in which payment was made by SLPMB only upon the presentation of authenticated weighbridge tickets, consonant warehouse receipts and independent verification by SLPMB’s Internal Audit department.

Moreover, a check could be issued only with two signatories, one from either the managing director or the deputy managing director, on the one hand, and the other from the Accounts Manager or another designated manager within SLPMB’s finance departments. This eliminated the possibility of fraud in SLPMB’s management absent collusion between the Managing Director or Deputy Managing Director, on the one hand, and the Accounts Manager or his or her alternate, on the other. Even then, the annual external audit conducted by the international firm of Peat Marwick & Co. would uncover any such malfeasance, if it had not been discovered by SLPMB’s internal auditors, unless the external auditors were themselves complicit and/or incompetent.

As regards similar problems of inadequate internal control affecting non-produce purchases, the new managing director also installed a comprehensive system for evaluating and monitoring all such purchases made by SLPMB. This involved strict adherence to budgeted limits and post-expenditure evaluation. That included variance analysis which identified any variation between the budgeted amounts and the expended amounts, for corrective action.

In order to resolve the other operations problems of SLPMB he had inherited, including an aging and inadequate fleet of lorries to transport produce from SLPMB’s stores in the eastern, southern and northern provinces to Freetown, Mr. Suma replaced SLPMB’s aging fleet of lorries with 23 brand new Mercedes Benz lorries. To address the need to reduce the down time resulting from routine service and repair work on SLPMB’s large fleet of vehicles, including light vehicles, while increasing the transparency thereof, Mr. Suma built an in-house garage for the servicing of all of SLPMB vehicles. Furthermore, in a specific effort to extend the reach of SLPMB’s purchasing activities to meet the previously neglected needs of small farmers in remote areas of SL, Mr. Suma also created a subsidiary of SLPMB called National Produce Company (NAPCO). NAPCO’s field employees were assigned the task of traveling to remote villages to make sure that every farmer who wanted to sell his/her produce to SLPMB would be afforded a timely opportunity to do so at the applicable published producer prices paid to all farmers.

SLPMB’s operations expanded greatly during Mr. Suma’s tenure. This was due to two main factors. One was the result of the company’s improved operations. The other was the addition of rice distribution to the company’s traditional export activities, after the government’s Rice Corporation collapsed in 1979. As a result, a need arose to expand SLPMB’s storage capacity, office space, and skilled management and mid-level staff. At the same time, Mr. Suma recognized that it was important to compensate adequately not just the farmers who produced the crops SLPMB purchased, but also the staff who facilitated the collection, storage, preparation and export of those crops. Accordingly, Mr. Suma introduced several initiatives to boost staff morale.

Mr. Suma characteristically responded decisively to all the above concerns. He embarked on a storage expansion program during which he built eighteen (18) huge stores throughout SL. Addressing mainly the need to store rice which SLPMB was importing at the rate of roughly 10,000 tons a month during his entire tenure, Mr. Suma constructed rice stores in the populous rice consumption Western Area: Two at Jui, three at Wellington, two at Kennedy Street, and seven at Kissy Dockyard. To boost the storage of mainly coffee, cocoa, palm kernels and ginger, Mr. Suma built additional stores in the eastern and southern provinces — two each in the respective provincial centers of Kenema and Bo.

In regard to the acute shortage of office space amidst SLPMB’s expanding operations, Mr. Suma completely refurbished and modernized the small headquarters building SLPMB had occupied at Cline Town in Freetown since the 1960s. He also built new office buildings at SLPMB’s head office to accommodate the expanding shipping and personnel departments. He replaced the single Toyota minibus that could transport only a minute fraction of the several hundred SLPMB employees with two identical brand new tour-size buses. In a testament to his belief in equal opportunity for all employees, Mr. Suma allocated one bus each to blue-collar workers, including SLPMB’s laborers, and to SLPMB’s white collar workers. He extended the same concept to SLPMB’s staff housing loan program. In any given year that such loans were granted, Mr. Suma required that housing loan recipients included representatives from every level of SLPMB employees, from laborers to management staff.

In response to SLPMB’s staff association’s request, Mr. Suma also built a small mosque for use by SLPMB’s largely Moslem employees to reduce the length of excused absences for prayers. For similar reasons, he constructed a staff canteen that served all of SLPMB’s employees who wished to pay for lunch there. He also established two health clinics for SLPMB employees — one at SLPMB’s headquarters and another at SLPKOM.

Finally, Mr. Suma embarked on a successful drive to recruit some of the brightest S/Leoneans in order to meet SLPMB’s expanding need for competent executives and mid-level managers. As a result, by the time he retired from SLPMB in 1983, all but one of the fifteen members of SLPMB’s management were S/Leoneans with college degrees — a far cry from the period five years earlier when he found only one other college graduate in SLPMB’s management. In another contrast from the period when Mr. Suma first arrived at SLPMB, it was commonplace to find many college graduates among SLPMB’s several hundred employees. Not surprisingly, the result of all the pioneering policies introduced by Mr. Suma at SLPMB was that SLPMB achieved unprecedented success in its operations.

The evidence that Musa Khalil Suma, the youngest person ever appointed managing director of SLPMB, was also its best managing director, is overwhelming.

In 1981, SLPMB recorded the highest profit in its history, while paying the highest proportion of the world market price of produce to SL’s cash crop farmers. It was a feat that was never equaled. It will remain unequalled, due to the fact that SLPMB collapsed in 1992 — nearly ten years after Mr. Suma had left SLPMB with the most solid balance sheet in its history. This fact was attested to by the financial statements audited upon his retirement in 1983 by the same firm of independent external auditors which had regularly audited SLPMB’s financial statements each and every year during Mr. Suma’s tenure as managing director — the internationally renowned auditing firm of Peat Marwick & Co.

In addition, during Mr. Suma’s tenure, other parastatals and government agencies, notably the Bank of SL, regularly visited SLPMB to study ways of adapting SLPMB’s comprehensive financial, personnel and staff welfare policies to improve their own operations.

The wide-ranging and significant improvements installed at SLPMB by Mr. Suma during his tenure as managing director, some of which are outlined above, represented the last such initiatives installed at SLPMB until its demise nearly a decade later.

If there is a surfeit of evidence that Mr. Suma’s tenure as managing director coincided with the most successful period in SLPMB’s history, so also is there evidence that SLPMB, under Mr. Suma’s tenure, became one of the best run companies in both the private and public sectors of SL, as noted above.

The untimely death of this very accomplished son of Kambia district leaves forever unanswered a tantalizing question, namely: Could Musa Khalil Suma have transformed our inefficiently-run country in the same manner that he had transformed an inefficiently-run SLPMB into the best run company it had ever been?

About the author: Mohamed A. Jalloh(photo), known to his friends as Moh’m, was head of the Economic Planning Department at SLPMB during most of Mr. Musa K. Suma’s tenure as Managing Director. Mr. Jalloh is currently Managing Director of Bridgedal Capital Management, LLC, a financial services firm based in suburban Washington, D.C. in the USA.

Comments