Salone News

A Reply to Professor Sheik Umarr Kamarah

5 January 2011 at 22:34 | 747 views

Rejoinder

By Abu Bakarr Karim, UK.

Dr. Sheik Umarr Kamarah, Professor of English and Linguistics in Virginia State University in the USA, published in the Patriotic Vanguard on December 28 a critique on the Keynote Address delivered by Dr. Abass Bundu at the “Maada Bio Campaign for SLPP Flag Bearer Fundraising Dinner” in Maryland on December 18.

Professor, quite apart from the impression you give of an academic closeted in his ivory tower, nourishing an amazing sense of self-delusion, your writing also betrays a kind of fence-sitting between secret support of the APC and secret support of a certain female aspirant for SLPP flag bearer. In any case, the flaws in your presentation are such that they cannot be allowed to pass without a response.

1. Far from exonerating Siaka Stevens from chastisement, as stated by the Professor, Abass Bundu is simply contrasting between governance by the SLPP and the APC and drawing attention to the fact that the RUF war in 1991 was a precipitation from the APC’s “rotten governance” (the Professor’s own words), ending with President Momoh’s years of misrule. Why the Professor takes umbrage with this, describing Bundu’s statement as “intellectual dishonesty,” defies comprehension? If, as he says, “the conditions for a national explosion had long been created” by Siaka Stevens, he cannot really quarrel with the assertion that those conditions had been further exacerbated and amplified during Momoh’s administration. Surely he cannot deny that Siaka Stevens misgoverned for 17 years (1968 to 1985) followed by Momoh’s misrule for 7 years (1985 to 1992). Abass Bundu did serve under Stevens but for only 3 of his 17 years and only in the dying years of his one-party rule (1982 to 1985).

2. The Professor asks: “What is wrong with having a northerner as president in 2012 if that individual is the people’s choice?” The APC will answer there is absolutely nothing wrong with a northerner being president provided he/she is APC. By the same token the SLPP will say there is absolutely nothing wrong in a northerner being president provided he/she is SLPP. But that is not the issue. The critical question is whether the latter is achievable in 2012? No party wants to remain in opposition indefinitely and is always looking for a winning formula. This is the burden of Abass Bundu’s argument. If I understand the learned Doctor correctly, he is saying, ideally, he would prefer a northerner (including himself, of course) as SLPP flag bearer but is this achievable in 2012? If the SLPP selects a northerner as flag bearer and pitches him/her against President Ernest Koroma of the APC, their chances of winning the presidency for the SLPP may not look bright for the reasons that Koroma is a northerner endowed with a huge presence, a charisma of immense proportion, enjoying the advantages of incumbency and with five years’ experience as president by 2012. Further, the APC with a northerner as presidential candidate and the SLPP with another northerner as presidential candidate, opens up the prospects of Charles Margai, leader of the PMDC Party, exploiting the fears of the south-eastern electorate to win votes in traditional SLPP strongholds, thus depleting the SLPP vote and denying them victory just as he did in 2007.

Evidently, except for the Professor, who condemns it as “privileging one group against the rest,” and as “crass regionalism or tribalism” most SLPP supporters find Abass Bundu’s argument not only exceedingly compelling but also resonant with realpolitik and pragmatism. It is just possible that the Professor has isolated himself in his ivory tower of academia for so long that he is now completely disconnected from the realities and vagaries of Sierra Leone electoral politics.

2. The Professor also asks what significant changes have occurred in the front-line of SLPP leadership besides replacing Alhaji U.N.S. Jah with John Oponjo Benjamin? Answer: A significant change took place in the front-line leadership of the SLPP in 2009: Dr. Kadie Sesay was elected Deputy Chairman of the SLPP and Isata Jabbie Kabbah was also elected National Womens’ Leader, unless the Professor doesn’t consider these to be significant.

3. The Professor further criticizes Abass Bundu’s use of the pronoun “he”, apparently oblivious of the fact that there are three aspirants that are of the opposite sex. Bundu may be forgiven for his orthodoxy, for as the Professor rightly observed, he may have been using the “representative or universal he in British English that stands for both male and female referents in a discourse.”

4. The Professor further criticizes Abass Bundu as “myopic … crafting a personal agenda”, etc. etc. Unlike Abass Bundu who is quite open in his support for Maada Bio, either the Professor is a secret supporter of one of the female aspirants for SLPP flag bearer or he is plainly averse to any aspirant who qualifies as a youth. Maybe you have stayed in the US too long to realize that no candidate can succeed as president if he or she does not enjoy the support of the youths. So, my advice, dear Professor, is that you need to climb off your high horse and get yourself and your female aspirant to embrace the youths because today they constitute the majority of the voters in the country.

5. Finally, Professor, in present-day Sierra Leone it is not a question of substance trumping looks but of substance and looks together combining in the right mix. Moreover, don’t delude yourself into believing that a sense of national identity is something that can grow out of the soil; it is a political construction born of political leadership. And that remains a priority aspiration of the SLPP. Have a happy 2011.

Comments