Commentary
By Craig Wellington, Canada
A glaring illustration of systemic anti-Black racism, is over criminalization and stigmatization of Blacks vs Whites for drug use.
Marijuana use is equal among Blacks and whites, yet Blacks are 3.73 times as likely to be arrested for marijuana possession. Roughly the same percentage of Blacks and Whites report being involved in selling drugs, yet Blacks are significantly more likely to be convicted and sentenced for selling drugs.
Once arrested for drug related charges, Blacks have significantly more sentences resulting in incarceration than Whites and are given significantly longer sentences. Blacks are 8.24 times more likely than Whites to be arrested for drug sales, but there is no statistical race difference in self-reports of having sold drugs. Whites have more charges indirectly related to drugs, such as committing a crime in order to buy drugs, or being high while committing a crime (80% vs. 53%).
Whites are also significantly more likely to report using hard drugs, such as heroine or cocaine.
Drug addiction by Whites is usually dealt with as a mental health issue, while drug addiction by Blacks is usually dealt with as a law enforcement issue.
Coming from Jamaica to high school in Canada, I was shocked at how open the drug and alcohol culture was especially among the white student population. Every week many white classmates boasted how ’smashed’ theyd gotten partying on the weekend or at rock concerts, and catalogued the litany of drugs and alcohol they’d consumed. No stigma. Just good fun. While parties by the Black and Philipino students were mostly about dancing and dance battles.
If anyone wanted to find drugs at school, the place to go was the smoking area where mostly white kids hung out. While Black kids were inside playing music, dominoes and ’salad a kick’ at lunchtime.
Even now white colleagues who grew up in rich neighborhoods like Lorne Park & Rosedale recount their drug & alcohol fueled high school weekends.
Years later visiting Toronto youth detention centres and adult prisons, I was bewildered that the majority of people incarcerated for non violent drug use were Black. What happened to all those white kids? Well, many went on to be executives, lawyers, police, elected officials, doctors, business owners, tradespeople, etc. with the drug use of their youth (and occasionally today), having no consequences on their present. While Black youth caught in the system were charged, stigmatized and had their life irreparably damaged.
So when we look at over incarceration rates of Black people, we have to be careful to not extrapolate that Blacks are more prone to criminality. Blacks are just more likely to be stopped by police, and charged for the same offenses Whites are committing at similar or greater rates. That initial charge and the barriers to opportunity and stigma it creates, leads to less economic advancement and greater likelihood of more involvement in the justice system. That’s systemic anti Black racism.

Comments